There really is no subjectivity to being a child of God. Either you are or you aren’t, haha. Yes how people define a true Christian may differ, but objectively we have scripture as the standard to give us the tenets of the faith.
When I say a “real Christian” I am not judging the heart of another but rather the lack of fruit in repentance. A complete disregard for righteousness and people will say they believe in God (deity) without actually having believed in Christ (the Son of God). They say they love God but they do not love their neighbor (1 John 4:20).
Their definition of a Christian is loose, and not grounded in truth. A profession in identity but not expressed in character. It reminds me of the question, what good is your faith? You carry His name but live as if He doesn’t exist. It’s sad. Both for their experience in life and for God, who desires that they know Him and experience His goodness.
When I say a “real Christian” I am not judging the heart of another but rather the lack of fruit in repentance. A complete disregard for righteousness and people will say they believe in God (deity) without actually having believed in Christ (the Son of God). They say they love God but they do not love their neighbor (1 John 4:20).
Their definition of a Christian is loose, and not grounded in truth. A profession in identity but not expressed in character. It reminds me of the question, what good is your faith? You carry His name but live as if He doesn’t exist. It’s sad. Both for their experience in life and for God, who desires that they know Him and experience His goodness.
I understand what you're saying, Ben. I'm sure that to God, there is certainly no subjectivity to being a Christian, and He would say you either follow Him or you don't as well.
But I have to politely disagree with the statement, "You either are or you aren't (a Christian)" when it comes to what people define in each other as being Christian or not. And the thing is, most people won't leave it at that -- they believe it's their Christian duty to change the other person into what they personally follow and believe, or that person's faith doesn't actually count.
Now, I agree with you that the basic foundation, and the one that DOES count, is believing in God as the ultimate being of the universe whom we must all subject ourselves to, and because we were all sinful from birth, we all need to have faith in Jesus whom God sent as the Savior of our sins, who died to take the punishment of sin for us.
HOWEVER, for most Christians, that's just not good enough (and it's been that way from the very beginning, as laws were piled on top of laws.) Take a look at this very forum -- look at all the ways people here define each other as being a "Christian" or not (I'm not taking any sides here, I'm just presenting some of the subjects I see argued over daily, both here on the forum and in real life.)
These are just a few things that will easily get a person thrown into the "not a Christian" pile:
1. If you smoke, drink, do drugs, have tattoos, unnatural hair colors, piercings or ones considered unusual -- you're not a Christian.
2. If you're Republican or Democrat; if you vote or don't vote; if you support government or anarchy -- whichever side you take, you're not a Christian. If you're not prepping, you're not a Christian. If you ARE prepping, then you don't really believe that God will protect you -- and therefore, you're not a Christian.
3. If you wear a mask or don't wear a mask; if you get the vaccine or don't get the vaccine; if you choose to social distance or go to packed indoor gatherings anyway -- there are mobs of angry people on both sides of either issue, each one accusing the other of not being Christians. Look at all the people here who will tell us if we wear a mask, we don't really trust Jesus; and on the other hand, another group of people will tell us that if we don't wear a mask, then we don't really love Jesus because we're not loving our neighbors. Again, I'm not judging or taking sides. I'm just saying, Christians only say you're a Christian if you're following what they personally feel is being a Christian.
4. If you were baptized one way and not the other -- you're not a Christian. If you don't believe in taking communion the same way we do or believe the same things about it as what is taught in this particular church -- you're not a Christian and are not allowed to partake of it here. If you speak in tongues, it's from the devil; if you don't speak in tongues, you're not a real Christian.
5. If you have a certain amount of money (or not,) you're not a Christian, because having money means you'll turn into one of the camels who can't get through the eye of a needle; if you have a lack, it must be because you're lazy or just don't have enough faith that God will provide.
And of course, the list goes on indefinitely
Now, God certainly has His own standards as to who and what His people really are.
The problem is, we human beings then go on to decide that's just not good enough and so along with believing in Jesus as your Savior, you have to jump through everyone else's individual hoops in order to get their stamp of approval as being a Christian.
It shouldn't matter all that much to us -- only what God says to us or how He defines us should matter -- but unfortunately, we do have to face and sometimes even pander to this to some extent. We could just close ourselves off from everyone, which I know some do, but unfortunately, we don't learn very much about other people or how to help them if we don't actually have regular contact with people. (Believe me, if there was a way to do it, I'd be one of the first to sign up.)
- 1
- Show all