Nope. She has said that as well. You just kept making a strawman and changing her argument to something untrue.
Not By Works
- Thread starter dcontroversal
- Start date
-
Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.
If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!
To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Sis.... this guy's cheese seems to have fallen off of his bologna sandwhich.
If he keeps imputing false beliefs to you ignore that dishonesty. It has been exposed twice already.
You're speaking of the opposite.
Peter denied Jesus -> lack of a righteous work and it was seen before man as lack of faith.
In james there is teaching AGAINST a loveless (lack of righteous works) to SHOW the love of God in us as witnesses. (His body)
You're either being dishonest or making a strawman out of confusion.
No you can never be seen before a brother or sister as "justified as a true believer" by works. Lack of love (which manifests as works) before man will cause you to be less than blameless. They can doubt your faith. If you are blameless, before these men your faith is justified. They have nothing to point at to say "oh look, hypocrit... liar... Jesus wouldn't want that how can you say you love Him"...
For john
I replied to part of this earlier, now I'm addressing the other part of your response now.
If a man has faith and no works to go along with it, he is a FAKE CHRISTIAN. That kind of faith, head knowledge, is the same faith all fake professors of Jesus Christ have, it is not LEGITIMATE faith, it's head knowledge.
That's the whole point of James 2, what demonstrates true faith - works. I can't stress this enough, James 2 shows the difference between real faith and head knowledge.
I don't believe he even understands the Plan of Salvation. At any rate, I certainly don't agree with him period.
E
EleventhHour
Guest
NOT determining salvation... one does not even know what salvation is before one is born again.
James is speaking to show non-believers.
I assume that you believe there are two churches and two different gospels. One church being flesh descendants of Israel, these are saved by grace and keeping the law. Then there's another church, those Jews and Gentiles after Christ. These are saved by faith only and no law keeping.
Abraham saw the death burial and resurrection of Christ when he was on his way to offer up Isaac. Christ dwelt in the church in the wilderness and they drank from that Rock. The Old Testament is FULL of prophecies of the death burial and resurrection of Christ. How can we say that they didn't know about it, and even look forward to it the same way we look back at it.
It doesn't matter if a person lived before Christ or after Christ, it is Christ and Christ alone that gives salvation.
To be honest, sticking with the clear reading of the word...I'm not convinced. Has God chosen not to know certain things, future decisions, until man decides?
What about the Nineveh? Did God know that they would repent and in turn He would not destroy them in forty days? He declared He would destroy them in forty days? Did God lie, or simply change His mind based upon their response to the message?
You're speaking of the opposite.
Peter denied Jesus -> lack of a righteous work and it was seen before man as lack of faith.
In james there is teaching AGAINST a loveless (lack of righteous works) to SHOW the love of God in us as witnesses. (His body)
You're either being dishonest or making a strawman out of confusion.
No you can never be seen before a brother or sister as "justified as a true believer" by works. Lack of love (which manifests as works) before man will cause you to be less than blameless. They can doubt your faith. If you are blameless, before these men your faith is justified. They have nothing to point at to say "oh look, hypocrit... liar... Jesus wouldn't want that how can you say you love Him"...
Believers know it is God who saves us.
That is a separate issue from appearing to not have been made a new creature before man.
You can not prove to me you are saved John. It is impossible.
But you can certainly behave in ways which make you look like you don't know God or love Him.
A member of Christs body which is VOID of any sort of work of righteousness, a loveless walk, would before man who can not see the heart.... seem to be a faker...
You are wrong. The claim is not what you think it is.
Read those quotes. You are imputing false beliefs to others and rejecting proper reproof.
Lol, Abraham believed in the d,b,r of Christ? You know that was a mystery hid from everyone until it was fulfilled. Not even His disciples knew about it. We can look back and see the pictures, but only with the knowledge of the NT.
Nobody was "looking forward" to the cross. That's a man made doctrine. They were looking forward to a Messiah, a deliverer, but the cross was hidden.
So, non-believers can determine who is really saved by looking at works? Really?
Only one way to eternal salvation through Jesus Christ. The word gospel doesn't always have to point to eternal salvation. That is evident. It's simply glad tidings, good news.
So you are born again by grace through faith, which I take it your faith allows you to see the Kingdom of God, spiritually of course. I always viewed 'spirivision' as interesting since it is written, in Luke 24:39, Behold my hands and my feet, that it is I myself: handle me, and see; for a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as ye see me have.
That bread definitely has the aroma of the Pharisees leaven with looks of promise.
While 'faith without substance' is hope seeing that hope with substance is faith.
Thus, it is written, "for we are saved by hope:" not by our faith since faith comes by hearing and hearing the Son of God.
Thus it is written, "but hope that is seen is not hope:" so if faith comes by hearing the word of God then for what a man sees, why does he yet hope
Agreed. But one can appear to have been saved, but is lost. One can go to church, pray, do good works and be lost. What we see in the flesh has no bearing on the reality. Likewise, one may choose not to live according to the Spirit but after the flesh, and this person is saved. We are never to judge a man's salvation.
Ok, then to whom do we justify ourselves through our good works? God? The lost? Other believers?
We have all said this and you have falsely imputed beliefs to the person you quoted.
No one ever once said here works of righteousness can prove anything. Before man or God.
No one did.
We know it's not that because 'believes' in John 3:16 is a present tense verb in the participle mood.
The person in John 3:16 is presently 'believing' in Him.
So the condition that varies must be whether or not the presently believing person will always be presently believing in Him.
Then explain James. The question James is answering: Can faith save him?
24 Ye see then how that by works a man is justified, and not by faith only.