Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
People may be hateful and bitter, but this crosses all denominations and beliefs. Calvinism or any other ism isn't responsible. People are.

But, God has Calvinists sovereignly hating others.
It is His will they hate because He decreed it.
 
What! Since when have you stopped trusting in the efficacious power of your personal "freewill" choice to believe and repent?

Here is the problem with you, sir...


"Whoever loves discipline loves knowledge,
but whoever hates correction is stupid."

Proverbs 12:1


God said it!
 
period ? So no such thing as Gods enabling grace then, do you realise where talking about an unsaved person here ? How about God's enabling will power to make choice, don't you still have that ? Well whilst your thinking about that, what makes you think an unsaved person wouldn't need enabling will power to make a choice, when a saved person does ? Speaking about the fruits of spirit and self control. ( Temperance )


And I wonder is there such a person as a calvinist are you sure that's not another projected false idol your imagining

Could you show me a sermon of a person calling himself a calvinist ?
I don't think you'll find many as if you do he's probably decided to be one, by people like you projecting a false image every where that there's all these Calvinists on the loose
"enabling grace"
Pursuing this this Calvinist dogmatic construct to its logical conclusion will inevitably lead to "pre-birth sovereign lottery". As it always does.

@Magenta introduced another philosophic synthetic construct today: "already believing". Which analyzed will ultimately lead to the same result.

Neither has been substantially proven as of yet. Attempting to do so (and inevitably failing) would defeat their purpose.
 
The fact of the natter is it's not just the liberals not going to Heaven.... most on the right won't be going to Heaven either.

Yeah...but look at the really bright side: Very, very few libertarian freewillers won't make it through Heaven's pearly gates either.
 
Here is the problem with you, sir...


"Whoever loves discipline loves knowledge,
but whoever hates correction is stupid."

Proverbs 12:1


God said it!

Oh wait...let me come up with a oft-repeated, tiresome, childish FWer refrain: You're cherry-picking isolated verses taken out of context. Anything else you have in your impoverished grab bag of tricks?
 
"enabling grace"
Pursuing this this Calvinist dogmatic construct to its logical conclusion will inevitably lead to "pre-birth sovereign lottery". As it always does.

@Magenta introduced another philosophic synthetic construct today: "already believing". Which analyzed will ultimately lead to the same result.

Neither has been substantially proven as of yet. That would defeat their purpose.

Yep I'm the devil there you go.

Your free to curse to me hell.

Have a nice day
 
Funny how determinism thinks it has a lock on the word "efficacious" and uses it pejoratively by attaching it to human volition.

Only in a deterministic mind is it pejorative. I'm actually OK with it. It does what God designed it to do.

Efficacious Grace Offer <> Efficacious Volitional Receipt (aka faith-obedience) <> Efficacious Grace Salvation.

Well...something has to effectually trigger a response to the gospel. Since YOU and your ilk despise the idea that God's efficacious, then it must be your "freewill". So, no one is using "efficacious" as a pejorative but merely taking the FWer's steadfast rejection of the nature of God's saving, rescuing power (grace) to its only logical conclusion.
 
Maybe read. I didnt say Jesus was teaching Law. I said He was teaching the Jews. He came for the Jews. Bringing gentiles into the fold was a mystery not revealed.

Read the Abrahamic Covenant someday. :rolleyes:
 
And it's truly amazing, Magenta.

It's the depravity of the human heart that motivates the carnal desire to be like God -- or in FWers' case -- to be better than God since they can do things that God himself cannot do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rogerg
But, God has Calvinists sovereignly hating others.
It is His will they hate because He decreed it.

Have you ever read any of the imprecatory Psalms? And are you aware that scripture is loaded with paradoxes? Are you aware that is right for God's people to hate what He hates? Has it ever occurred to you that Jesus didn't pray for the world in Jn 17 because He had no love for the ungodly world? And the final question: Why are you so simple-minded after your gazillions of hours of bible study? :rolleyes:
 
What! Since when have you stopped trusting in the efficacious power of your personal "freewill" choice to believe and repent?
So I take it that your trust resides in the efficacious power of the "loaded dice" and "rigged gaming tables" that God must facilitate in His salvation scheme, as He is incapable of achieving His goals honestly and honorably?
 
And, you are one of those experts (who does time travel)....

Both the Hebrew - 'min bit'en' - and the Greek -'ek kolia' literally mean, "out from the womb.

Stick with your kiddy translations if it makes you feel good.
What I am talking about is "meat" for those who wish to mature in Christ.
I use many translations. You use the one in your head that makes you better than all of the others. How "convenient."
 
Not true or there would not be those saying that man is born with everything he needs to come to believe. .

Why do you keep applying that to whom it does not apply?
No one is born with everything he needs to believe.

Everyone is born with a soul.
And, it is with his soul (heart) that man believes onto salvation.

But! That soul is imprisoned by the depraved flesh which forbids that soul to believe.

So?
How did God solve the problem?

Does God force the soul somehow to believe (irresistible grace)?
Or, does He force by his power of grace for the flesh to be still and silent?
Thus allowing for a soul make up its own mind without coercion?

Grace makes everyone accountable to God!
Because God provides grace, there will be no excuses... "My flesh made me do it!"

Grace forces the depraved flesh to be still and silent!
Allowing a soul to think for himself.

Keep in mind, those who reject God were free to while God was applying drawing grace!
Grace did not make them have to believe.
Because of God's drawing grace, no one can not blame the flesh.
Flesh that Adam caused them to have!


Without grace taking control?
No one could could choose to believe.

grace and peace ..........
 
Why do you keep applying that to whom it does not apply?
No one is born with everything he needs to believe.
Why do you keep lying?

Perhaps you should tell that to the one who claims man is born with everything he needs in order to come to belief.

It seems you may be ignorant of who that is.

Keep your eyes open.
 
Calvinistic ***salvation*** via conspiracy and tyranny? Prove it.

I have yet to hear anything compelling from the determinists. Chronister would destroy these determinists BTW. As you well know.

the unsolved problem isn't that if God can sovereignly save why doesn't He save everyone - - it's why does He save anyone at all?

attributing our salvation to His mercy towards us, refusing to give our own will any credit, is not equal to double predestination. that's the knee-jerk jump of logic i was mentioning earlier.
 
Have you ever read any of the imprecatory Psalms? And are you aware that scripture is loaded with paradoxes? Are you aware that is right for God's people to hate what He hates? Has it ever occurred to you that Jesus didn't pray for the world in Jn 17 because He had no love for the ungodly world? And the final question: Why are you so simple-minded after your gazillions of hours of bible study? :rolleyes:
Lots of paradoxes. Like freedom. The world's idea of freedom is to be free to do as they please. But by virtue of their nature...simply being finite...they cannot achieve freedom. It's an allusion. Equally paradoxical is true freedom. It is not found in the ability to do things, but in a person who by virtue of yolking oneself to, is free to pursue all that God has to offer. Who knew true freedom was found in bondage?
 
Why do you keep lying?

Perhaps you should tell that to the one who claims man is born with everything he needs in order to come to belief.

It seems you may be ignorant of who that is.

Keep your eyes open.

I would tell him the same thing I have been telling you.