So the consensus is: Any man who is a biblical Christ follower that can speak well enough to teach can be a pastor. I believe that is the vitae of the majority of pastors in the country. What training? Very little with some experience on the job. Many coming from youth ministry the overarching ministry failure in the church today. Just check their report card over 75% of youth coming out of our youth ministry have turned their backs on the church and their Christian faith. Check out the facts for yourselves.
I have read and thought about your post and have come to wonder what it is that you were trying to express. Is it a lack of higher education, a lack of oversight, a lack of something else?
Many have pointed to 1 Timothy 3 for the qualifications of a pastor. Yet, in your response it appears that you have either honed in to the ones you wanted to choose from or have simply not read them.
You stated how many youth leaders have led their group of youth and yet when these kids reach adulthood they leave the faith. You seem to suggest that this is a failure of the youth leader. I would ask you if this makes Jesus a failure? He had a following of thousands at one point but His teachings were to hard for them and so they left. He sent out 70 men to heal and cast out devils in His name but by the end only 12 remained and even one of them betrayed Him.
There is a failing in our churches that we judge success as the world judges success. We look to numbers and activity, but Jesus looks at the heart. It is not how many follow but I'd those who follow do so in truth and spirit.
Pastors are to be blameless the husband of one wife, vigilant, sober, of good behavior, given to hospitality, apt to teach, not given to wine, no striker, not greedy for money, patient, not a brawler, not covetous, one the rule that his own hose well, having his children in subjection with all gravity, not a novice, and having a good report of them which are not of the church.
Looking at this list, the qualifications are extremely hard to meet and hold. It is much more than being a Christian and able to speak well.
In fact, Malachi 2 speaks about those who hold the office of the priest...what we would call the pastor today, and says that those who do not hold true to the office and glorify the name of God shall have dung spread upon their faces and will become contemptible and base before the people. This means that it is not only that the qualifications are high, but if one dishonors the office they are granted then the penalty is stiff and most unpleasant.
Yes, we yave too many hold the office that shouldn't, but this is not a fallacy od the office or the qualications for the office. This is the fault of the church by allowing unqualified men behind the pulpit and not holding them accountable according to the Word of God.