Why I now believe that salvation can be lost.

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Jackson123

Senior Member
Feb 6, 2014
11,769
1,371
113
Holy Spirit does not leave us.
Repenting over and over again does not keep your salvation secure ... Jesus keeps our salvation secure, because of His work not ours.
Soy our do not need to repent when you kill or rob? And you not lose your salvation no matter you do because Jesus secure our salvation?
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,402
113
murder is a sin and sin ends in death BUT David and Moses REPENTED and that is what saved them .. they "returned" to God and "changed" from doing their Will back to doing God's Will .. we all sin and only repentance can restore the life from death sin brings .. no repentance no forgiveness and no forgiveness no salvation aka eternity in lake of fire with Satan and his demons, the unbelievers, and the unrepenting sinner believers
false..........
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,402
113
The incorruptible sin does not sin, is that make us incapable of sin?
That spirit which has been born again does not sin and is exactly why eternal life CANNOT BE LOST....however...it is still BOUND in a fallen body that is weak and sins.....the battle ground is the MIND which needs to be TRANSFORMED BY THE WORD OF GOD...the greater the transformation the less we sin although NEVER SINLESS until we receive a glorified body
 

Jackson123

Senior Member
Feb 6, 2014
11,769
1,371
113
That spirit which has been born again does not sin and is exactly why eternal life CANNOT BE LOST....however...it is still BOUND in a fallen body that is weak and sins.....the battle ground is the MIND which needs to be TRANSFORMED BY THE WORD OF GOD...the greater the transformation the less we sin although NEVER SINLESS until we receive a glorified body
So you believe born again people Spirit never sin, but body is sin.

And God not punish our body when our body commit sin, because our spirit not commit sin, am I correct?
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,402
113
So you believe born again people Spirit never sin, but body is sin.

And God not punish our body when our body commit sin, because our spirit not commit sin, am I correct?
I mean exactly what I said.......it is not difficult to understand!!
 

preston39

Senior Member
Dec 18, 2017
1,675
240
63
Holy Spirit does not leave us.
Repenting over and over again does not keep your salvation secure ... Jesus keeps our salvation secure, because of His work not ours.
You are wrong...so please explain this for the newbies....?
 

preston39

Senior Member
Dec 18, 2017
1,675
240
63
Amen......Irrevocable, kept, lose nothing, eternal life, leave the 99 to find the one that wandered, sealed, in Father's and Son's hand, never perish, he abides faithful if we become faithless etc....and on and on......so many truths must be swept aside, skewed, denied, rejected, embellished and or context twisted and denied to peddle a losable salvation........
Wrong....you need to study the Bible.
I suggest the KJV 1611 edition because to reach your conclusion you are using the latest new age religion edition.
 

Margo74

Active member
Jul 11, 2019
147
63
28
I wonder how anyone can say God cannot do this or that, or saints cannot rebel and fall.
How many stories are their of sinners who become servants of God and then fall under judgement?

The whole story of the prodigal son is the son chooses to leave and chooses to come back.
There is no promise of being safe except before the left and after they returned.

So insecure are some, to know you are loved is not enough, you need to imprisoned and
shackled so you cannot leave. But this is absurd as nothing in heaven has been created this
way. It is not part of Gods nature as demonstrated by the cross. God bless you
God CAN do anything and everything He chooses to do .. He CAN stop us from sinning but He chooses to ALLOW us to choose to sin or not to sin and if we choose to sin, to choose to repent or not to repent .. God chose us and desires that we choose Him .. He CAN but WILL NEVER force Himself on anyone .. God chose me and I choose God .. God will never abandon me but will I never abandon God? .. and if I ever do abandon God, will I REPENT and return to God and to loving Him and doing His Holy Will? .. I can say I would never abandon Him but only time will tell and I can say that IF I ever abandon Him, I would REPENT and return to Him and His Will but, again, only time will tell .. I pray daily that I never deceive nor mislead anyone and that I am not being deceived nor mislead and that no matter what, I shall always have the courage and faith to remain with God .. none of this is rocket science .. we can believe and love and obey but disobey occasionally and then repent or not .. our choice and our consequential eternal happiness or eternal torture .. pray you make the right choice as do I pray I do such ..
 

Margo74

Active member
Jul 11, 2019
147
63
28
You are wrong...so please explain this for the newbies....?
no need to repent over and over again IF you stop succumbing to sin over and over again .. but as often as you choose to sin you must choose to repent or not .. repenting stops and is no longer needed when one stops sinning .. repentance is the remedy for sinning .. no further sinning would mean no further need of repentance remedy .. your choice and your choice alone ..
 

Margo74

Active member
Jul 11, 2019
147
63
28
You were being given a second change...because you are dead wrong.
with God all things are possible .. without God nothing is possible .. if we choose to have Christ in our lives, we have His everlasting love and help .. but Christ will help us attain righteousness but WILL NEVER help us remain in unrepentant unrighteousness ..

and one who chooses to remain in unrepentant unrighteousness aka sin IS "dead wrong" and "DEAD" eternally .. With God STAY; with Satan STRAY .. with God LIVE; with Satan DIE ..
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,402
113
Wrong....you need to study the Bible.
I suggest the KJV 1611 edition because to reach your conclusion you are using the latest new age religion edition.
Shows what you don't know or maybe what you think you know....for the record genius...I use a Cambridge Black letter edition, wide margin, Berkshire leather bound, KING JIMMY....the difference between you and I is, I actually believe it, study it and let it speak without religiously skewing it to fit my own dogma.....!!
 

Sipsey

Well-known member
Sep 27, 2018
1,502
713
113
Salvation is simple (from a friend)

We are separated from God—we cannot see God, we don't hear His voice, we are trapped in a world of hate and deceit and pain, and we have no contact with God. The reason for this is that God is holy and righteous and we are not. We are born with innate sin. Those who have children know that the child's first two words are "momma" and "daddy" (or vocatives to that effect), and the third word is invariably "no!" This is the expression of the innate old sin nature. I know that some of you believe, or want to believe, that man is inherently good, and I am forced to admit that in just about every person I have met, there is some good in them. However, there is also in every person that I have met, a tendency to lie, or steal, or cheat, or to be self-righteous, or greedy, or self-centered. Somewhere in that person are imperfections. I don't care how wonderful a person is, ask any married person by week 3 or 4—their spouse, with whom they are madly in love, has some imperfections, even some characteristics predilections which are wrong. We cannot have fellowship with a perfect and holy God while we are in sin. His righteousness and justice demands that a penalty be paid for any sin committed against Him. This punishment is eternal separation from Him. We receive a taste of that separation from God here on earth. We receive a taste of living with man in possession of his old sin nature here on earth. Our salvation was obtained by Jesus Christ through His payment for our wrongdoings. On the cross, He received the equivalent of an eternity of separation from God on our behalf. The punishment which we deserved, He took upon Himself. We cannot merit salvation, we cannot appropriate this substitutionary atonement by our works. We cannot dedicate our lives to Jesus Christ, we cannot promise Him that we will behave, we cannot grit our teeth and do whatever it takes to become better people, we cannot ask Jesus into our hearts or lives; there is nothing that we can do to make up for our guilt before God. Our salvation is a free gift which we appropriate be believing in Jesus Christ; by relying upon what He did on our behalf on the cross; by depending entirely upon Him for salvation. This eliminates works, intentions, promises, sincerity, and everything else from the picture. Therefore, what we do prior to salvation and what we do after salvation does not affect what Christ did on our behalf on the cross and cannot remove salvation once it is given to us. I realize that is unpalatable to some. What we do after salvation certainly is addressed in the Bible—however, no matter what we do after salvation, it cannot nullify salvation, for the gifts and calling of God are irrevocable (Rom. 11:29).
 

Jackson123

Senior Member
Feb 6, 2014
11,769
1,371
113
I mean exactly what I said.......it is not difficult to understand!!
If I correctly understand, after born again, keep rob the bank and killing not make you lose your salvation, because your spirit is not sin.

So before born again, your spirit sin

What is sin in spirit look like?
 

Sipsey

Well-known member
Sep 27, 2018
1,502
713
113
If I correctly understand, after born again, keep rob the bank and killing not make you lose your salvation, because your spirit is not sin.

So before born again, your spirit sin

What is sin in spirit look like?
I would suggest, that if one was a serial killer or serial robber or serial- you name the sin, cried out “save me,” but after crying out, remained a serial killer, or you name it, then the words cried out were empty and insincere and wasted.

A faith that doesn’t inherently change one, inwardly and outwardly is wishful thinking.
 

Margo74

Active member
Jul 11, 2019
147
63
28
Shows what you don't know or maybe what you think you know....for the record genius...I use a Cambridge Black letter edition, wide margin, Berkshire leather bound, KING JIMMY....the difference between you and I is, I actually believe it, study it and let it speak without religiously skewing it to fit my own dogma.....!!
how often does one need to be told, the gift of salvation is just that .. God's gift to ALL .. but not ALL accept it and not ALL who do accept it choose to keep it .. some who accept it misuse and abuse it and eventually lose it .. of the latter, some search to find it aka REPENT and retrieve it while others never search for it and have lost it forever aka have lost eternal salvation and have chosen eternal damnation .. no gift is eternally secure unless God and each person chooses to make it so and God does choose to make it so but not all who receive it choose to make it so .. only those whose names remain in the book of life are eternally saved but God does blot some names out of the book of life .. why? .. coz those persons chose to leave Him and go their own sinful way and never turn back aka REPENT ..
 

Margo74

Active member
Jul 11, 2019
147
63
28
I would suggest, that if one was a serial killer or serial robber or serial- you name the sin, cried out “save me,” but after crying out, remained a serial killer, or you name it, then the words cried out were empty and insincere and wasted.

A faith that doesn’t inherently change one, inwardly and outwardly is wishful thinking.
sooooooooooooooooooo very true ..