I don’t blame you for not getting into Neon Genesis Evangelion, the extreme fan base around it is like “You’re stupid if you don’t understand the show or give it a 10/10”, I stand by how it does have flaws, but I can respect it as a really well done deconstruction of the Mecha genre, plus Shinji is one of my favorite characters, even though everyone else hates him, that’s probably why I like him, lol. Yeah I can believe that for Excel saga, I don’t know if you know about Midori Days, but that’s the anime where the main guys right hand becomes the girl he is crushing on, no it’s a legit show, actually a good romance too, but it’s all explained with that love-able anime logic, lol. You are right on the Big O being inspired, too bad Season 2 was awful, loved Season 1, and so does my brother, not enough people have seen that show, very underrated. I would say my favorite anime movies right now are Jin-roh, Millennium Actress, Kiki’s Delivery Service (Saw it for the first time 2 days ago), Redline, and mostly everything from Marmou Hosoda (Except Wolf Children, not awful, just not as good as Summer Wars, The Girl who leapt through time, and Mirai, in my personal opinion).
I would say my Top 10 list looks like this right now, I don’t like having favorites, but I do rate my anime, these are all of my 10/10 ratings:
1: Cowboy Bebop
2: Gurren Lagann
3: Tatami Galaxy
4: Steins;Gate
5: Nichijou
6: Shirobako
7: Baccano
8: Mushishi
9: Code Geass
10: Penguindrum
I do have other 10/10 rated shows, and this list is pretty old, as in there is some stuff on here I haven’t seen in a long while. I used to be into reviewing anime on Instagram, but with understanding how much Christianity matters to me and how I haven’t been finishing shows on a good pace, I decided to stop reviewing, I even called my reviews STR (Or Sh*t Taste Reviews, cause everyone into anime likes to joke about that stuff, as in “You like Attack on Titan? Well then you have sh*t taste”, lol), but I still have my MAL, so I can keep up with my lists and to see what I actually have finished in a easy way.