Not By Works

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
here I am, saying that regeneration is instant.

just to show that I did agree with someone in principle, but not word for word.

and, legalists will not accept anything but a word for word agreement.

that is why things can't be let go off by them...
Yes, AFTER I CORRECTED YOU, which is after you attacked me and called me all kinds of names.
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
You said that after I corrected you. Here is the insulting and ridiculous things you said before I corrected you.

regeneration is not what your phony lordship junk teaches. saved by grace, proved by works.

trash.

yes, I personally believe in regeneration, but you push INSTANT regeneration, that is a big fat lie. :eek:


it looks different for everyone. some folks are instantly regenerated , some it takes times for the Fruits of the Sprit to began to manifest.

all are saved the instant they believe, and stay so as long as they believe.

regeneration is a separate conversation.
Proved by works is a strawman, by the way.
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
Only when its tied to a necessity of/for salvation...which is what you believe correct?
So where did I say this?

The answer is no. I'm sorry that you, DC, GB9, Eternally grateful don't know what"come after" means. As in obedience, fruit etc follow/come after salvation.See 1 John 2:3

If that doesn't fit in your theology, take it up with the Elder.

OK if you guys don't address me anymore, I'll drop it.

Take care now.
 

VCO

Senior Member
Oct 14, 2013
11,995
4,615
113
Nope. Can you produce a post where I said that.

I do agree with what eternally grateful said though. Remember the quote that I had for my sig for a while.

When EG says things like that, you all high five him. When I say things like that, I'm a works salvationist

What was it that he said? Oh yeah, EG said "it is impossible for a Christian not to work, it is part of his new nature."

DC thumbs upped that one. But when I say the same thing, I get castigated.

I guess you all have your double standards. If that's what you like, OK.
 

VCO

Senior Member
Oct 14, 2013
11,995
4,615
113
Nope. Can you produce a post where I said that.

I do agree with what eternally grateful said though. Remember the quote that I had for my sig for a while.

When EG says things like that, you all high five him. When I say things like that, I'm a works salvationist

What was it that he said? Oh yeah, EG said "it is impossible for a Christian not to work, it is part of his new nature."

DC thumbs upped that one. But when I say the same thing, I get castigated.

I guess you all have your double standards. If that's what you like, OK.


YOU GOT TO CLARIFY THAT STATEMENT.

The Work Righteousness bunch do it to earn part of their SALVATION, and KEEP IT.

We do it JUST BECAUSE we want to LOVE him back.

MOTIVE is the reason Most will be COUNTED AS FILTHY RAGS.

Only LOVE is the PURE MOTIVE that GOD values, with out expecting payment.
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
@VCO. I have been accused of not being clear. Here is my position on the matter. Just a few quotes from literally hundreds that I could copy and paste

"Macabeus, post: 4037720, member: 279100"]...We don’t bring anything that was not first given to us by God[/"Macabeus, post: 3949236, member: 279100"]There are several ways the man can serve God in joy and gratitude. ANY born again person can serve God from joy and gratitude of being saved. :) If nothing else, the fact that I am justified should make me desire to see others saved, and lead to me at least praying for them, if not sharing my faith with them..Macabeus, post: 3949151, member: 279100"]We are justified by faith without works, yes, but when we are justified, we also receive a new nature, and if we have a new nature, we will have new desires, and thus, we will want to see God glorified (new desires) and will labor to that end. Not to be saved, but from love and gratitude..."Macabeus, post: 3948980, member: 279100"]Yes, and then after justification, we live our lives to God out of love and gratitude, BECAUSE OF OUR NEW NATURE. Not perfectly, but there should be SOME love and gratitude, and concern about other people IF WE ARE BORN OF GOD>.."Macabeus, post: 3948972, member: 279100"]. As I have stated many times, SALVATION IS FULLY ACCOMPLISHED, and then works follow from love and gratitude. Sorry if I wasn't clear. Macabeus, post: 3947604, member: 279100"]Yep, if it is of grace, then work is no more work. VERY GOOD scripture. KUDOSAnd to Him that has received grace, work is no longer reckoned as meritorious work, it becomes an expression of gratitude and love. 1 JOHN 5:3. AND no one has room to boast, for WHAT DO WE HAVE THAT WE DID NOT RECEiVE FROM GOD. 1 Corinthians 4:7 "Macabeus, post: 3947268, member: 279100"]Justified by faith ALONE, works follow out of love and gratitudeJust like fire produces smoke...All of Grace, it is all of grace, naught of myself, but all from Him, it is all of grace, that is all."Macabeus, post: 3946895, member: 279100"]Never said it had anything to do with salvation. I merely stated that those who are born of God will have the characteristics that John lists in his First Epistle.And we do not work to be saved. We work because we are saved and out of love and gratitude...."Macabeus, post: 4035414, member: 279100"]I agree that fruit is the result and fruit of salvation, not the cause or the root. .

Just a few clear quotes from a selection of HUNDREDS where I said that fruit and works flow from salvation and love and gratitude for God for saving us.[/QUOTE][/QUOTE]
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
@VCO. I have been accused of not being clear. Here is my position on the matter. Just a few quotes from literally hundreds that I could copy and paste

"Macabeus, post: 4037720, member: 279100"]...We don’t bring anything that was not first given to us by God[/"Macabeus, post: 3949236, member: 279100"]There are several ways the man can serve God in joy and gratitude. ANY born again person can serve God from joy and gratitude of being saved. :) If nothing else, the fact that I am justified should make me desire to see others saved, and lead to me at least praying for them, if not sharing my faith with them..Macabeus, post: 3949151, member: 279100"]We are justified by faith without works, yes, but when we are justified, we also receive a new nature, and if we have a new nature, we will have new desires, and thus, we will want to see God glorified (new desires) and will labor to that end. Not to be saved, but from love and gratitude..."Macabeus, post: 3948980, member: 279100"]Yes, and then after justification, we live our lives to God out of love and gratitude, BECAUSE OF OUR NEW NATURE. Not perfectly, but there should be SOME love and gratitude, and concern about other people IF WE ARE BORN OF GOD>.."Macabeus, post: 3948972, member: 279100"]. As I have stated many times, SALVATION IS FULLY ACCOMPLISHED, and then works follow from love and gratitude. Sorry if I wasn't clear. Macabeus, post: 3947604, member: 279100"]Yep, if it is of grace, then work is no more work. VERY GOOD scripture. KUDOSAnd to Him that has received grace, work is no longer reckoned as meritorious work, it becomes an expression of gratitude and love. 1 JOHN 5:3. AND no one has room to boast, for WHAT DO WE HAVE THAT WE DID NOT RECEiVE FROM GOD. 1 Corinthians 4:7 "Macabeus, post: 3947268, member: 279100"]Justified by faith ALONE, works follow out of love and gratitudeJust like fire produces smoke...All of Grace, it is all of grace, naught of myself, but all from Him, it is all of grace, that is all."Macabeus, post: 3946895, member: 279100"]Never said it had anything to do with salvation. I merely stated that those who are born of God will have the characteristics that John lists in his First Epistle.And we do not work to be saved. We work because we are saved and out of love and gratitude...."Macabeus, post: 4035414, member: 279100"]I agree that fruit is the result and fruit of salvation, not the cause or the root. .

Just a few clear quotes from a selection of HUNDREDS where I said that fruit and works flow from salvation and love and gratitude for God for saving us.
[/QUOTE][/QUOTE]

@VCO, plus the statement in the post you replied to was qualified by the words "It is part of the New Nature"
 

Melach

Well-known member
Mar 28, 2019
2,059
1,526
113
probably not a good time for me to write lolz

there is a man on youtube finalcall jan and he is preaching sinless perfectionism to the full. he said Jesus isnt interested in losers, only winners. that really made me feel sad this is before i was saved in grace
because i am the biggest loser i know but i think now its opposite Jesus cares mostly about losers. i read 1 corinthians 1 and first shall be last.
 

Lightskin

Well-known member
Aug 16, 2019
3,165
3,665
113
probably not a good time for me to write lolz

there is a man on youtube finalcall jan and he is preaching sinless perfectionism to the full. he said Jesus isnt interested in losers, only winners. that really made me feel sad this is before i was saved in grace
because i am the biggest loser i know but i think now its opposite Jesus cares mostly about losers. i read 1 corinthians 1 and first shall be last.
Those who are well do not need a doctor. Thank God that Jesus is the Great Physician who desires to heal everyone who is sick. Now here’s the kicker; everyone is sick, especially “sinless perfectionists”.
 
U

UnderGrace

Guest
probably not a good time for me to write lolz

there is a man on youtube finalcall jan and he is preaching sinless perfectionism to the full. he said Jesus isnt interested in losers, only winners. that really made me feel sad this is before i was saved in grace
because i am the biggest loser i know but i think now its opposite Jesus cares mostly about losers. i read 1 corinthians 1 and first shall be last.
Finalcall07 on YouTube is a travesty, no one should listen to that guy :mad:
 
U

UnderGrace

Guest
oh you know him. are you from south africa also?
No not from South Africa...for some reason one false teacher on YouTube leads to another, so you know one and you discover all the others.

FinalCall07 actually teaches repent means to stop sinning...
 

Grandpa

Senior Member
Jun 24, 2011
11,551
3,190
113
No not from South Africa...for some reason one false teacher on YouTube leads to another, so you know one and you discover all the others.

FinalCall07 actually teaches repent means to stop sinning...
Well, while you are repenting you aren't sinning... probably... So he's kind of correct?? Probably not in the way he means...


But any other time its probably not going quite as well as the person who thinks they are sinless thinks it is...
 

Melach

Well-known member
Mar 28, 2019
2,059
1,526
113
its so ironic because to say you are sinless is a sin. lolz.

@Lightskin hello friend i cannot respond to your private message you have some setting where i cant send back to you. conversation closed for new replies it says
 
U

UnderGrace

Guest
Well, while you are repenting you aren't sinning... probably... So he's kind of correct?? Probably not in the way he means...


But any other time its probably not going quite as well as the person who thinks they are sinless thinks it is...
Sorry Grandpa he actually defines the word "repent" to mean "cease from sin"

So actually I would agree with Melach on this, it is a sin to think you can stop sinning.
 

Grandpa

Senior Member
Jun 24, 2011
11,551
3,190
113
Sorry Grandpa he actually defines the word "repent" to mean "cease from sin"

So actually I would agree with Melach on this, it is a sin to think you can stop sinning.
Well repent actually means to turn away from your own way and turn to God. So while you are in the actual act of repentance a by product of that is that you have ceased from sin.

But as soon as you are "finished" or go back to life or whatever, not in a repentant state, doing your own thing, you are subject to sin. You don't have to dwell on it or anything like that but you know that you aren't God and that you aren't Perfect.

And that is what the sinless perfectionist says "I am perfect like God is Perfect". No, sir. You are just as dumb and weak as the rest of us. Sorry to burst your perfect bubble...:ROFL:
 
U

UnderGrace

Guest
Well repent actually means to turn away from your own way and turn to God. So while you are in the actual act of repentance a by product of that is that you have ceased from sin.

But as soon as you are "finished" or go back to life or whatever, not in a repentant state, doing your own thing, you are subject to sin. You don't have to dwell on it or anything like that but you know that you aren't God and that you aren't Perfect.

And that is what the sinless perfectionist says "I am perfect like God is Perfect". No, sir. You are just as dumb and weak as the rest of us. Sorry to burst your perfect bubble...:ROFL:
Metanoia as a word used in scripture and apart from scripture in Greek writings means a "change of mind" there is nothing inherent within the word that relates to sin, it is not only a biblical word.

In scripture in context away from dead works to Christ

The root of the meaning of the word repentance: meta=after; noeo=to think. Put the two together and the effect of meta was “after the fact” or “afterwards.”

Essentially, it means to think about something later on and have a reversal of opinion about it. Thus, repentance meant “to change the mind.” Specifically—to change the mind about Christ.
 

Melach

Well-known member
Mar 28, 2019
2,059
1,526
113
Metanoia as a word used in scripture and apart from scripture in Greek writings means a "change of mind" there is nothing inherent within the word that relates to sin, it is not only a biblical word.

In scripture in context away from dead works to Christ

The root of the meaning of the word repentance: meta=after; noeo=to think. Put the two together and the effect of meta was “after the fact” or “afterwards.”

Essentially, it means to think about something later on and have a reversal of opinion about it. Thus, repentance meant “to change the mind.” Specifically—to change the mind about Christ.
in my language only one bible translation says change of mind its translated correctly in only one. its lutheran conservative translation. the mainstream translations are all saying repent means to change ur lifestyle and do better