I have wondered and prayed about that question. We all have things we are fond of and attracted to, as well as character traits and skills. That I believe goes for both men and women, Godly and worldly.
I know what I would enjoy in a man. I know my character and what would complement who I am and my weaknesses. ( help meet) as well as how I would complement and benefit his weaknesses. I do feel for folks that truly live for the Lord, they will seek a mate that has a heart that also truly seeks the Lord. (not perfect) but a solid root system in the Lord. (biblical)
Being a Godly woman, I would not choose a mate that is all about riches, partying, power, and other worldly desires. I will seek a mate that lines up with the bible. (equally yoked).
It is correct that we all are attracted to different looks, traits and skills. We are all uniquely made. What separates us from the world is our Love for the Lord and the desire to be obedient children. Oil and vinegar don't mix unless beaten together then separates quickly after. Just as worldly and Godly don't mix.