Do you think it's possible that all people living today will be saved?how do you know? isn't it possible all will or none will?
Do you think it's possible that no people living today will be saved?
Really?
Why did you ask this question?
Do you think it's possible that all people living today will be saved?how do you know? isn't it possible all will or none will?
Do you think it's possible that all people living today will be saved?
Do you think it's possible that no people living today will be saved?
Really?
Why did you ask this question?
That does not change the fact that He wants all people to be saved.because i want to point out that we know this of a certainty, because God Himself told us, ahead of time.
So your view is that 1 John 2:2 is speaking of sufficiency and not application?well, 1 John 2:2 doesn't let me conclude that 'the whole world' refers to believers. John writes, not only ours, but all theirs also. in that letter he defines who 'ours' is -- those that believe. so i can't escape that His propitiation is sufficient for all, His blood given for all.
when John the Baptist says that He is the Lamb taking away the sin of the world, he doesn't say 'all the world' like John does in his little letter. so it think scripture is making a distinction between the sufficiency and the application of atonement.
something that came to mind last night while i was talking to @brightfame52 was how Christ wept over Jerusalem saying 'all day long I have held out my hands' to them. i thought, this is like the topic of the atonement being limited or unlimited. it's not as though He is unwilling; if they would turn, He would save them -- but many won't turn.
we're going to have to get into quantum physics eventually with this topic. superposition of states & the observer effect -- that's where nature testifies of free will & predestination; it's something not intuitive to us as humans living in our macro-world, but the cat in the box is both alive & not, and the photon is both particle-like & wave-like ---- or maybe we ought to say, it's something else entirely outside our ability to describe..
His omniscience demands that He has known for all time who it is that believes and who it is that doesn't. even among the disciples He Himself chose -- but He didn't turn them away, rather let them turn away themselves, and His willingness to let them sit at His feet and learn from Him even while He knew they would eventually reject & abandon Him is a testimony against them & a testimony of His great love, isn't it?
But I just can't wrap my mind around the Lord being the propitiation for the whole world yet some don't get propitiated for.
It would make more sense (in my head) to say only the world of believers receive this propitiation since unbelievers in fact don't receive this propitiation.
Otherwise, you are inadvertently stating an impossibility. A person who has had their sins atoned for by Christ dying in their sins. Will not compute. The equation won't balance. It has to simplify down to (Die in sins = not atoned for)
If we truly know that Jesus is God, then we seeBut I just can't wrap my mind around the Lord being the propitiation for the whole world yet some don't get propitiated for.
Do you believe those who never become believers had their sins propitiated for ?So your view is that 1 John 2:2 is speaking of sufficiency and not application?
I won't argue about sufficiency. The Lord is absolutely sufficient in all ways.
But I just can't wrap my mind around the Lord being the propitiation for the whole world yet some don't get propitiated for.
It would make more sense (in my head) to say only the world of believers receive this propitiation since unbelievers in fact don't receive this propitiation.
Otherwise, you are inadvertently stating an impossibility. A person who has had their sins atoned for by Christ dying in their sins. Will not compute. The equation won't balance. It has to simplify down to (Die in sins = not atoned for)
That is the simplicity that I try to show. I don't think it is against what scripture says. It just doesn't describe the sufficiency of what God does. Which we can't really do anyway. Or what we would say would be insufficient...![]()
Your signature scripture reinforces your statement, Rom 8:1.False
people who believe are not condemned
people who are unbelievers are still in a condemned state
Not through our faith but through Christ's faith, Gal 2:16.His blood, his grace, and his mercy through our faith,
next
Christ's faith justifies us eternally. Gal 2:16, Our faith, which is a fruit of the Holy Spirit that is given in the new birth, can deliver us as we sojourn here in this world, through keeping the law in the old testament, and enduring to the end in the new testament, but our faith will not deliver us eternally.Everyone has always been saved by faith. In the OT, and in the book of Revelation, people were (and will be) required to demonstrate their faith. In the OT they were required to keep the law. In Revelation it explicitly states that they must "endure to the end". Saul lost the Holy Spirit, and did evil in the sight of the Lord. After David sinned, he prayed to God not to take the Holy Spirit from him.
Throughfaith is right. Christians are sealed with the gift of the Holy Spirit. People in the OT, and people who will be going through the tribulation, were not sealed with the Holy Spirit.
First post, gotta jump in somewhere..![]()
They were saved by his blood, through his death, burial, and ressorrection.Thats a different discussion, in any case they were saved by His Blood !
They were saved by his blood, through his death, burial, and ressorrection.
NopeNot through our faith but through Christ's faith, Gal 2:16.
When we chose to believe, yes.Christ's faith justifies us eternally. Gal 2:16
Our faith in Jesus Christ is precisely what delivers us eternally. When a person hears the Gospel, and decides to believe it, THEN he is sealed with the gift of the Holy Spirit, he guarantee of salvation (Eph 1:13-14).Our faith, which is a fruit of the Holy Spirit that is given in the new birth, can deliver us as we sojourn here in this world, through keeping the law in the old testament, and enduring to the end in the new testament, but our faith will not deliver us eternally.
The elect are people who freely chose to believe the Gospel. Nobody's destiny is predetermined.Salvation according to Greek definition = a deliverance. The elect are delivered eternally, and they are delivered many times as they sojourn here in this world.
That depends on what you mean by the "last day". Christ will return for the Christian church (AKA the rapture), then the tribulation, then Christ will return TO earth to fight Armageddon and set up the millennial kingdom.There will be no 1000 year reign after the last day.
Again, please define it. There are several "stages" to the last day.The last day means the last day.
The kingdom is not here yet. The kingdom will be here when Christ returns and sets it up.Christ has been reigning in his Kingdom, the church, ever sense the day that he set it up in the Apostles days, and will raise it up to heaven at the last day.
It is not what anyone believes or disbelieves but what God says:Do you believe those who never become believers had their sins propitiated for ?
Do you believe those who never become believers had their sins propitiated for ? Simple yes or no please.It is not what anyone believes or disbelieves but what God says:
And He [Christ] is the propitiation for our sins: and not for ours only, but also for the sins of the whole world. (1 John 2:2).
This verse is found in every bible, and in both the Received and the Critical texts.
Since you do not believe this, you do not believe God and Christ. You have put your faith in the doctrines of men.
Every one that he died for are, at sometime in their life, made alive, which is God's elect people.Eternal life is the word Jesus used
it means once a person is made alive who was dead, their life is eternal. And since it is based on Gods work and his promise, and not based on our work, we can be secure in our destination for all eternity
He died for everyone.Every one that he died for
Only if they choose to believe the Gospel.are, at sometime in their life, made alive
God's elect people are those who choose to believe, something anyone can do.which is God's elect people.
The unregenerate natural man, as described in 1 Cor 2:14, will not ever beg and plead to be spiritually saved, until God quickens him to a new spiritual life.Just to be clear: Are you claiming God chooses people to send to hell without any chance for them to be saved? They could literally beg and plead for salvation and God will not hear them?