If it be thy will

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
What you believe is irrelevant to what is true.
to you it is but not to me.

The Bible gives accounts of God changing His mind. God Himself says that He changes His mind. But because those facts do not agree with the God you imagine in your mind, you reject those scriptures and invent some incoherent philosophical work-around to justify your rejection of what God straight-forwardly tells us about Himself.

Jer. 18:5 Then the word of the Lord came to me, saying,

6 O house of Israel, cannot I do with you as this potter? saith the Lord. Behold, as the clay is in the potter's hand, so are ye in mine hand, O house of Israel.

7 At what instant I shall speak concerning a nation, and concerning a kingdom, to pluck up, and to pull down, and to destroy it;

8 If that nation, against whom I have pronounced, turn from their evil, I will repent of the evil that I thought to do unto them.

9 And at what instant I shall speak concerning a nation, and concerning a kingdom, to build and to plant it;

10 If it do evil in my sight, that it obey not my voice, then I will repent of the good, wherewith I said I would benefit them.

11 Now therefore go to, speak to the men of Judah, and to the inhabitants of Jerusalem, saying, Thus saith the Lord; Behold, I frame evil against you, and devise a device against you: return ye now every one from his evil way, and make your ways and your doings good.
Yep all Gods word being used which was, and has already been ordained. For all means to change things for you or i.


In the beginning was the word and the word became flesh for all means, all ready set in motion by his plan which you can't change, his plan is set in motion to change your mind not his.
 
I listened as I’ve listened to probably most of Sproul’s sermons on YouTube.

He really didn’t make a case for God not changing his mind though. God knows what we need before we ask. The problem is that most of the time we pray for what we want and not what we need because we don’t know what we need besides food, water, shelter, and Christ. I do believe that God sometimes changes His mind and gives us the things we want in order to let us fall on our face. Just as I sometimes give in to my children’s request to do something stupid. Them trusting that I know better is not enough for them so I change my mind after they request multiple times and let them learn the hard way. Wasn’t part of my plan so I changed my plan.

i believe the flood is proof of God changing His plan. You could say that God knew everything from the beginning so the flood was just part of His original plan, but was it? If so why not have Seth build an ark and flood it then? Could His plan not change based on whether we follow it or not?
Again he wasnt making a case For God changing his mind he was making a case for we can't change his mind.

God changing his mind is not something he needs to do, because he's already provided you the means and the plan he has for you, so where it looks as if he's changed his mind, What's actually happening is his plan is working, where by his means you have responded in away that trusts in his means.
 
Again he wasnt making a case For God changing his mind he was making a case for we can't change his mind.

God changing his mind is not something he needs to do, because he's already provided you the means and the plan he has for you, so where it looks as if he's changed his mind, What's actually happening is his plan is working, where by his means you have responded in away that trusts in his means.
Ok
 
God changes things by us trusting in his will, which he has already ordained, where as you make out that means nothing, Gods word makes out you have a reason to be actively involved in his will by coming to him, and being actively involved in his will by trusting in whatever means he has already set in place , so no, it's not as irrelevant as you think.
You are arguing two seemingly contradictory things.
1. God changes things.
And 2. God's will is already ordained.

Until you stop presenting contradictory premises as though they are compatible, your theology will remain internally inconsistent and nonsensical.

I agree that God makes out you have a reason to be actively involved in God's will by coming to Him. But not by trusting in means He has already set in place. But by trusting His promises to change the destiny to something good for those who begin to trust in Him.
 
you mean God's mind couldn't be changed ?

Here's a Tricky question.

I wonder if God can delay his decision ? for instance moses stepped in front of God who was just about to destroy the people for worshiping a golden calf, and because of moses doing that, did God Change his mind, or did God delay his choice, ? Did God just stop because Moses was in his way or was it God was striking fear into the people and knew Moses would beg for mercy ?

But do you think it was the plea of mercy from moses that changed Gods mind or delayed his choice, or was Gods mind changed, or could it be when mercy is asked for God can decide to change his way How God deals with people.

you think God, who created and called Moses against Moses's will, was surprised Moses did this?
 
You are arguing two seemingly contradictory things.
1. God changes things.
And 2. God's will is already ordained.

Until you stop presenting contradictory premises as though they are compatible, your theology will remain internally inconsistent and nonsensical.

I agree that God makes out you have a reason to be actively involved in God's will by coming to Him. But not by trusting in means He has already set in place. But by trusting His promises to change the destiny to something good for those who begin to trust in Him.
God changes things for you for your benefit you can't edify him, by his means already provided, nothing you can say can change what he already knows and has planed by his all knowing knowledge, for you to be able to change what he's already planned by his means would mean he hasn't thought of something,. And you have, and that you know something he doesn't, that's why prayer is about trusting in his will.

Which is what is meant by James 4:15

And James 4:15 should be included in James 1:4-5
 
You are arguing two seemingly contradictory things.
1. God changes things.
And 2. God's will is already ordained.
Yes Gods changes things

Yes God's will has already been ordained

Within Gods will, that has already been ordained is his means by which can change you.

That's what changes, is you if trust in his means that has already ordained,
.where as God doesn't need to change his will or his mind.

So once again in scripture where it looks as if he's changed his mind he hasn't.

For instance moses saying lord remember your promise before you kill them, do you think God had forgot that, noooooo. That was mans human nature being silly with God thinking God could forget or not knowing whether he had, or thinking and believing his plea for mercy was not as important as his plea to bargain with God and step In front of God

It was the plea for mercy that changed the outcome of the Israelites people, and a plea for mercy is a means which the lord has already provided. But was the lord decision only delayed ?

You don't change Gods plan by telling him to remember his promise.

Remember 600.000 men where left in the wilderness, where they the same 6000.000 men who worshipping the golden calf too, maybe there was less than that worshipping the calf within the 600.000 maybe when they where worshiping the calf, maybe they never stopped worshipping idols even tho moses helped there outcome, they carried on with there babblings, even tho God was providing his means.

The point is within the promise he made to them, where conditions they obeyed whilst he led them, so moses saying remember your promise means nothing.

So what do you think change there outcome, the plea for forgiveness or the Moses bargain the lord has forgot his promise ?
 
As for moses yes I believe that because moses stepped up and pleaded for mercy for his people that God's mind was changed because he loved Moses
I don't think it was delayed either I think it was that he changed his mind because of Moses
let me ask you in this way Do you think Moses attempted to become God's guidance counselor ?

Do you think it's possible a man can be Gods guidance counselor
 
Does scripture say how soon it is before we pray that God knows we are going to pray. Which scripture/s are you relying on for this claim?
are you saying you need proof that God knows what your going to pray before you pray it,

And again what does how soon he knows have anything to do with it ?
 
let me ask you in this way Do you think Moses attempted to become God's guidance counselor ?

Do you think it's possible a man can be Gods guidance counselor
No more like he was God's right hand man
 
No more like he was God's right hand man
in one way moses was yes but he was transformed by God.

It's believe he underwent a spiritual change on the mountain and was transformed by God so much so that his face was shinning with radiance when he came down,

But the question still stands, does being transformed by God mean you can become God's guidance counsellor meaning you can Guide God himself
 
Simply put everybody owes God something, and if they don't pay what they owe with God, then there futures is set in the direction it will go.

If they pay then so does there path.

What do you think the number one thing is you owe God

Tell me, what does everyone owe God? How does one pay this? Does payment differ depending on the desired change in path as you say? Can you pay too little and receive half a path change, or pay too much and receive two paths?
 
in one way moses was yes but he was transformed by God.

It's believe he underwent a spiritual change on the mountain and was transformed by God so much so that his face was shinning with radiance when he came down,

But the question still stands, does being transformed by God mean you can become God's guidance counsellor meaning you can Guide God himself
I see no reason why not