Your question has nothing to do with my opinion on the op's question. Instead of trying to derail this thread with your questions about Gen 2:17, go to the Bible discussion forum and ask your question in a brand new post. Yes, Adam and Eve disobeyed God, but, other than the general "all things are connected, and had Adam and Eve behaved themselves, life would a gooey bite of creaminess all the time, " logic, it has nothing to do with the op's questions. The ones in the Bible discussion are better equipped to give an opinion on this, since they debate the Bible more often.