Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
What has any of it to do with force and choice acting simultaneously? Try to be a little more specific please or I have no idea to what I should respond.

God wrote his script for all humanity in eternity. And all humanity willingly complies in temporal reality.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brightfame52
Freewill fell with Adam and is as dead as all his progeny. The human nature of man became corrupt and depraved and made all Adam's progeny helpless slaves to their evil natures.

And what do you think it means "to be free indeed"?

I know, that is why grace must precede any choice otherwise there is no choice.

Free means to be able to be perfectly human as God designed us to be (that includes to be able to choose freely, not forced to choose). To be anything less is not freedom but captivity.
 
Yes, it is exactly "presto", otherwise we would be using a deceitful heart to get a not-deceitful heart which isn't possible to do. You're giving man involvement a role in a process which he clearly doesn't have. The verse does not state or imply anything close to what you're saying - you're adding to the verse. Do you have a problem with the word "give"? You had the same problem yesterday with being given belief.

You weren't given belief your were given the privilege to believe. Try reading the verse in some other translations as well.

Then I guess if we are not involved in our becoming like Christ we can all go back to bed. Is that why it is so hard to get through to you, because you are asleep? ;):LOL:
 
In essence....
Their way of thinking amounts to?

We become God's slaves if He forces us to be His.
Not sons...

Don't start on the slavery thing. Been there done that and they weren't even Reformed or Calvinists. I think I would go into a coma if I had to argue slavery with a Calvie. ;)

o_O
 
here's a true teaching, but may I add this is how how genuine faith is preached by people associated and affiliated with the true Calvie teachings 🙂.

Let love be genuine

https://www.youtube.com/live/ktdFZ8PLhzU?si=5EQm8K_oytSQ74xX

Regardless, of the Reformers initial desire to translate the scriptures, and make them known to the people, many of them did not show any fruit in their own lives of being genuine followers of Christ. The leaders, men like Martin Luther, John Calvin and Zwingli showed the spirit of Antichrist by persecuting Christians who differed on minor points like infant baptism, drowning and burning them at the stake. Regardless of their theology they were MURDERERS like the father of all murder and "no murderer has eternal life residing in him"
(1 John 3:15)
 
Yes it does say that. And furthermore the lost in that scripture has the definite article, so they will always be lost, and never believe. It's literally the Gospel is hidden amongst the lost. Kinda agrees with Paul here 2 Cor2:15

15 For we are unto God a sweet savour of Christ, in them that are saved, and in them that perish:

I know it's lost among them because they don't believe.
 
You weren't given belief your were given the privilege to believe. Try reading the verse in some other translations as well.

Then I guess if we are not involved in our becoming like Christ we can all go back to bed. Is that why it is so hard to get through to you, because you are asleep? ;):LOL:

Where in Scripture do you find "privilege"?
 
You're actually telling me that you don't understand that verse?

[Luk 1:77 KJV] 77 To give knowledge of salvation unto his people by the remission of their sins,

You realise the knowledge in that verse is "gnosis" which, is data input. It is the knowledge of salvation, not salvation itself.

I think I may understand it better than you do. :)
 
Regardless, of the Reformers initial desire to translate the scriptures, and make them known to the people, many of them did not show any fruit in their own lives of being genuine followers of Christ. The leaders, men like Martin Luther, John Calvin and Zwingli showed the spirit of Antichrist by persecuting Christians who differed on minor points like infant baptism, drowning and burning them at the stake. Regardless of their theology they were MURDERERS like the father of all murder and "no murderer has eternal life residing in him"
(1 John 3:15)
ok Jim have it your way, but the true Calvie affiliates know different
Merry Christmas from the Calvin colledge

 
God wrote his script for all humanity in eternity. And all humanity willingly complies in temporal reality.

Really, try telling that to the victims of torture and abuse that God wrote that for their lives, that the perpetrators had no choice but to follow God's will.

:sick:
 
I'm not changing anything. I agree God gives us a new heart. I simply showed you how He does it. It is not some "hey presto" thing. I you want to believe in some hey presto moment and think your heart was in complete alignment with God's the second you were saved? Be my guest. No skin off my nose mate.



Go ahead, give us another dislike. :p

To the dislike you gave? Gold star for consistency. :ROFL:
 
It's a new man altogether Eph 4 24

And that ye put on the new man, which after God is created in righteousness and true holiness.

That's who believes in the Lord with his heart

I was told we have nothing to do with it so we can't put on the new man. Sorry, but you need to sort out the inconsistency with your fellow believer.
 
You realise the knowledge in that verse is "gnosis" which, is data input. It is the knowledge of salvation, not salvation itself.

I think I may understand it better than you do. :)

lol not by that reply. Salvation occurs first - we know that because sins are forgiven apart from anyone's actions. All that remains then is to edify those saved. It's really quite clear from the verse.