Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
But that wasn't the topic. You do this too often Cameron. There is no passive gnosis word in the Rom.1:21 verse so there is no comparison to Gal.4:9. You simply changed the subject to confuse the issue. Very disingenuous!

Part of the training, "do this too often"

How to Teach and Preach Calvinism
Desiring God, John Piper

One of many such website, tell me this isn't cultic...
 
He did his usual trick of deviating from the actual topic. He is quite devious inasmuch he doesn't go all 180 degree off, just slightly off so he can continue justifying his argument. He isn't necessarily wrong in what he argues but it simply wasn't what the topic was about, so has no application to the debate.

When the doctrine reveals its inconsistency, one tactic is to resort to gaslighting.
 
Indeed. The overwhelming pattern of Scripture testifies to this truth that they must ignore in order to make John Calvin's theology work.
Lets pray hearts and eyes will be opened to the truth of these Scripture verses.




....

They have to want truth.... I do not see any of them questioning, rethinking, re-examining even as the flaws in their interpretation of scripture is exposed, nope they double down.

People do break away, I read the testimonies all the time, but each one came to a place of discomfort with the system.

I find it ironic that one of their premier teachers, John Piper, named his website Desiring God.

I mean really .. :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: cv5
Part of the training, "do this too often"

How to Teach and Preach Calvinism
Desiring God, John Piper

One of many such website, tell me this isn't cultic...

Interpretation: Make it a Calvinist interpretation of scripture every time

1. Be rigorously textual in all your expositions and explanations and defenses of Calvinistic teachings. Make it a textual issue every time, not a logic issue or an experience issue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cv5 and HeIsHere
Part of the training, "do this too often"

How to Teach and Preach Calvinism
Desiring God, John Piper

One of many such website, tell me this isn't cultic...

Interpretation: Keep repeating Calvinista talking points ad nauseum, even when scripture clearly refutes calvignostic ideas

2. Don't be strident but gentle. Assume that working these great issues through to conviction may take years and that being in process is OK.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HeIsHere
they would have cried out if there soul was lost in the first place and people will always cry out to lord in desperation, for the unsaved its because God's is delivering a message to there hearts.

And there heart recognise the something they've lost.

Then what happens is heart is in grief as the moment passes away and they call out to lord.

See theres always more understandings than you realise,

But sadly your understandings are mostly about proving people wrong. And having people being seen as people you hate

Psalm 107 shows two interconnected problems:

1. Spiritual famine and darkness
2. Physical calamity and distress

Both are caused by their rebellion against God.
Look at the verses:

Their spiritual condition

Psalm 107:5 KJV
Hungry and thirsty, their soul fainted in them.

This isn’t just empty stomachs.
Their soul is starving.
This is spiritual emptiness and weakness.

Psalm 107:9 KJV
For he satisfieth the longing soul, and filleth the hungry soul with goodness.

God restores the soul with goodness.
That points to reconciliation with God Himself.

Psalm 107:11 KJV
Because they rebelled against the words of God, and contemned the counsel of the most High.

Their condition began with spiritual rebellion.

They rejected God’s Word and counsel, creating spiritual darkness.


Their physical condition

Psalm 107:12 KJV
Therefore he brought down their heart with labour; they fell down, and there was none to help.

God allows physical hardship
because of their spiritual rebellion.

Psalm 107:19 KJV
Then they cry unto the LORD in their trouble, and he saveth them out of their distresses.

Their distresses are real, physical dangers
flowing from a spiritual cause.

Psalm 107:20 KJV
He sent his word, and healed them, and delivered them from their destructions.

Their healing and deliverance
includes both soul and life.


Bringing the two together:

So what does the psalm show?
Problem: Spiritual famine + physical calamity
(because of rebellion against God’s Word)
Solution: They cry to God
(not because He forced them, but because they are in need)
Result: God delivers and restores
(both spiritually and physically)
Here is the beautiful repeated pattern:

Psalm 107:6 KJV
Then they cried unto the LORD in their trouble, and he delivered them out of their distresses.

Psalm 107:13 KJV
Then they cried unto the LORD in their trouble, and he saved them out of their distresses.

Psalm 107:19 KJV
Then they cry unto the LORD in their trouble, and he saveth them out of their distresses.

Psalm 107:28 KJV
Then they cry unto the LORD in their trouble, and he bringeth them out of their distresses.


In Psalm 107, the cry is not pointless

The cry is not programmed
The cry is not forced by prior regeneration
The cry is a natural response and not planned by God.
The order God reveals is unbreakable:
Rebellion → Spiritual famine + physical calamity → They cry → God delivers → They praise the LORD

Conclusion:

Psalm 107 teaches real human response.
Their cry is a call back to God
which He hears
which He answers
which He deserves to be praised for.
God restores both the soul and the safety of those who turn to Him.
No reverse order.
No forced regeneration.
No deliverance before the cry.
They cry because they need God.
God delivers because He is merciful.
They praise God because He is good.

That is the gospel pattern this psalm celebrates.





....
 
Interpretation: Keep repeating Calvinista talking points ad nauseum, even when scripture clearly refutes calvignostic ideas

2. Don't be strident but gentle. Assume that working these great issues through to conviction may take years and that being in process is OK.

Some people have missed that memo.. :LOL:

They know they have a reputation, that is why John Piper is sending out the training guide of how to behave to win people over.
The repetitiveness is very weird along with the obviously loaded questions. imo.
 
Part of the training, "do this too often"

How to Teach and Preach Calvinism
Desiring God, John Piper

One of many such website, tell me this isn't cultic...

Interpretation: Present total inability as a gentleman's agreement that you won't notice their sins if they don't notice yours

3. Speak of your own brokenness in regard to these things and how they are precious to you and why and how they minister to your soul and help you live your life.
 
Part of the training, "do this too often"

How to Teach and Preach Calvinism
Desiring God, John Piper

One of many such website, tell me this isn't cultic...

Interpretation: Use teachings of people marinated in calvignostic ideas rather than scripture

4. Make Spurgeon and Whitefield your models rather than Owen or Calvin, because the former were evangelists and won many people to Christ in a way that is nearer to our own day.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HeIsHere
Psalm 107 shows two interconnected problems:

1. Spiritual famine and darkness
2. Physical calamity and distress

Both are caused by their rebellion against God.
Look at the verses:

Their spiritual condition

Psalm 107:5 KJV
Hungry and thirsty, their soul fainted in them.

This isn’t just empty stomachs.
Their soul is starving.
This is spiritual emptiness and weakness.

Psalm 107:9 KJV
For he satisfieth the longing soul, and filleth the hungry soul with goodness.

God restores the soul with goodness.
That points to reconciliation with God Himself.

Psalm 107:11 KJV
Because they rebelled against the words of God, and contemned the counsel of the most High.

Their condition began with spiritual rebellion.

They rejected God’s Word and counsel, creating spiritual darkness.


Their physical condition

Psalm 107:12 KJV
Therefore he brought down their heart with labour; they fell down, and there was none to help.

God allows physical hardship
because of their spiritual rebellion.

Psalm 107:19 KJV
Then they cry unto the LORD in their trouble, and he saveth them out of their distresses.

Their distresses are real, physical dangers
flowing from a spiritual cause.

Psalm 107:20 KJV
He sent his word, and healed them, and delivered them from their destructions.

Their healing and deliverance
includes both soul and life.


Bringing the two together:

So what does the psalm show?
Problem: Spiritual famine + physical calamity
(because of rebellion against God’s Word)
Solution: They cry to God
(not because He forced them, but because they are in need)
Result: God delivers and restores
(both spiritually and physically)
Here is the beautiful repeated pattern:

Psalm 107:6 KJV
Then they cried unto the LORD in their trouble, and he delivered them out of their distresses.

Psalm 107:13 KJV
Then they cried unto the LORD in their trouble, and he saved them out of their distresses.

Psalm 107:19 KJV
Then they cry unto the LORD in their trouble, and he saveth them out of their distresses.

Psalm 107:28 KJV
Then they cry unto the LORD in their trouble, and he bringeth them out of their distresses.


In Psalm 107, the cry is not pointless

The cry is not programmed
The cry is not forced by prior regeneration
The cry is a natural response and not planned by God.
The order God reveals is unbreakable:
Rebellion → Spiritual famine + physical calamity → They cry → God delivers → They praise the LORD

Conclusion:

Psalm 107 teaches real human response.
Their cry is a call back to God
which He hears
which He answers
which He deserves to be praised for.
God restores both the soul and the safety of those who turn to Him.
No reverse order.
No forced regeneration.
No deliverance before the cry.
They cry because they need God.
God delivers because He is merciful.
They praise God because He is good.

That is the gospel pattern this psalm celebrates.





....
yep a person can't rebell against something that hasn't been active in the heart.

Rebellion is an internal state, get it ?



I still don't see an answer from you about the truth I posted you about John Calvin either
 
Regeneration doesn't remove choice, as much as you need it to.

If we are talking about Calvinism, there is no choice. In Calvinism, its only one option that will happen. It starts with a regeneration (salvation), and then it is followed by a belief in the gospel (only option). After a regeneration of the heart, there is no chance that they would reject the gospel in Calvinism. So there is no real choice here. A choice is when you can choose between options A, and B. That is not what happens in Calvinism when it comes to believing the gospel. Why do you think they call it, "Irresistible Grace"?



.....
 
Part of the training, "do this too often"

How to Teach and Preach Calvinism
Desiring God, John Piper

One of many such website, tell me this isn't cultic...

Interpretation: Pretend that God would ask such a stupid question that Calvinistas use to confuse and entrap gullible people

6. Work the five points out from the "I" in tulip not the "U". That is, show people that they don't really want to take final credit for their coming to Christ. They don't want to stand before God at the judgment day and respond to the question, "Why did you believe and others with your opportunities didn't?" with the answer, "Well, I guess I was smarter, or more spiritual." They want to say, "By grace I was brought to faith." Which is "irresistible grace." That is, grace that triumphs over all resistance in the end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HeIsHere
I don't have to ignore him he ignores himself with his own ignorance, it's the same for many in this thread

Can't recognise faith is a gift

Can't recognise the faith in the bible expresses the lords faith and claim it for themselves

Can't recognise the fruits of the spirit lives in you and desires to control you

Can't recognise that God doesn't allow bad things to happen

Can't recognise the will of father lives in you

Can't recognise the father will goes against human will.

Can't recognise the will of the flesh is the will of man

Won't recognise there own controling behaviour

Can't recognise wrongly accusing people

Won't recognise God's active word as enabling grace

Can't recognise the spiritual state of man's fallen condition

Can't recognise they give more ability to the unsaved than they do the saved

Can't recognise predestination correctly

Can't recognise God's active will inside a person

Can't recognise the state of the naturally wicked heart

Don't recognise God's prick to the conscience as enabling grace

Yep pretty ignorant people

Sounds like Genez is stone cold blind. Lot's of things he can't see.
 
Pointing out the logical implications of a view is not straw-manning it or misrepresenting it.
 
Part of the training, "do this too often"

How to Teach and Preach Calvinism
Desiring God, John Piper

One of many such website, tell me this isn't cultic...

Interpretation: Convey what a joy it is to not have to be responsible for anything related to salvation. Practice a phony joy privately, like actors do, so you can be convincing in public

7. Out rejoice your critics. The one who knows and rests in the sovereign grace of God should be the happiest saint. Don't be a sour or glum or hostile false advertisement for the glory of God's grace. Praise it. Rejoice in it. And don't let that be a show. Do it in your closet until it is spilling over in the pulpit and the commons.
 
Part of the training, "do this too often"

How to Teach and Preach Calvinism
Desiring God, John Piper

One of many such website, tell me this isn't cultic...

Interpretation: Never get off the hobbyhorse of works, and always accuse opponents of focusing on works

8. Don't ride hobbyhorses that aren't in the text. Preach exegetically, explaining and applying what is in the text. If it sounds Arminian, let it sound Arminian. Trust the text and the people will trust you to be faithful to the text.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cv5
If we are talking about Calvinism, there is no choice. In Calvinism, its only one option that will happen. It starts with a regeneration (salvation), and then it is followed by a belief in the gospel (only option). After a regeneration of the heart, there is no chance that they would reject the gospel in Calvinism. So there is no real choice here. A choice is when you can choose between options A, and B. That is not what happens in Calvinism when it comes to believing the gospel. Why do you think they call it, "Irresistible Grace"?



.....

Nonsense. Besides, you FWers have the same problem going the other way. The unregenerate heart cannot choose to obey God or his gospel; for the wicked neither love the Lord nor can they shun evil.