Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
When you say "activity of God" what you REALLY mean is "pre-birth sovereign lottery winners and losers" correct?

I mean, that's your message to the unsaved world. Right?

Feel free to chime in @rogerg and @Magenta ..... don't be shy.
My message is the gospel. You are just another dishonest person who ignores what people say and misrepresent them. The phrase you employ has never come forth from my lips.
 
So did I. And I share a reformed view of scripture. Your claim is demonstrably false yet you continue to repeat it.
I would like to know when they think I was told to go and make disciples.

Not that I expect the truth from them...

I have never baptised anyone either.

How many people have they baptised?

Eh. They may lie about that as well.
 
Not really doing this for you, roger. I don't expect you to care nor do I think you'll be able to interact if I get into the Greek or point to writings that do.

I first looked at this for myself some time ago and revisited it several times over the years and a few times since I started interacting on these threads. For several reasons the determinist interpretation IMO makes the least amount of sense.

If you'd like to read an article that gets into the commentaries and provides some degree of an analysis of them and comes to its own conclusion, I've read this among others.

The point is, there has been a lot of work done on this verse and just like the Gospel, people get to make a choice as to what to receive and what to reject.

This may be a duplicate post as I lost comm when I posted.
Anyway, I thought the post was addressed to me but probably misread it.
But you're correct, I definitely don't care about that.
 
These free will syncretists have abandoned the true faith.

How do I know?

Because they contradict quite a few things that Jesus said.

If not contradict, they just outright deny them.

And not just things that Jesus said. Things that have been said throughout Scripture from Genesis to Revelation,
from a plethora of Scripture writers, prophets, and apostles. Their error is wide-spread and contaminates the
whole of their theology and outlook on life. They refuse to acknowledge what the Bible plainly states,
and replace what the Bible explicitly articulates with their vain self-exalting philosophically based garbage.


They seem quite comfortable doing that.
 
What I said is that Adam effectively committed suicide to be with his now fallen bride in a calculated gambit to save both her and him, knowing full well the justice and mercy of his God. In other words, Adam knew EXACTLY what he was doing and why. And what he was doing was defeating Satan in a roundabout way.

His calculations were correct. The Greater Adam Who would be the necessary and effective and adequate sacrifice was prophesied immediately thereafter.

You failed to hear those awesome lectures that I posted? It's only perhaps 10 or 12 hours total. I have listened to them all (and the rest) at least 3 or 4 times apiece. Maybe 100 hours or so.

I guess that would be why I know exactly what I am talking about whereas you do not huh?
Click Here
 
No. Because I did exactly what you said doesn't occur on this site.
You will understand this is a compliment but you are the outlier of the Reformed belief members so you don't shock me when I see you doing the correct thing.
 
That's absurd. It is actually a matter of whom do you trust. And given the translations I posted effectively and independently are all saying the same thing thereby validating the doctrine - and Indiana cv5 Jones and Henry studier Jones, Sr., somehow were able to find a non-existent quirk that none of those translations were able to find - I'll just go ahead and trust the translations. Further, the translations align perfectly with salvation being by God's grace through Jesus Christ, as a free gift, and not by man's works, maintaining harmony with the rest of scripture. You do believe that it is by God's grace with you being a Christian and all, don't you? No, you probably don't since your trust is in your works and not in God's.


Faith is a work in your view, so you contradict scripture then. Understood.

As well, all you did was list various Bible versions, and your soteriology is completely at odds with traditional non reformed understanding of the Gospel.

Fifty years ago the SBC would have shown the Calvinists/Reformed the door, but stealth Calvinists have corrupted traditional Christianity. Yes the testimonies are everywhere of those who exit these churches who have been overtaken.

Thankfully there are a few here who have not been brainwashed by this stealth Calvinism.
 
Thankfully there are a few here who have not been brainwashed by this stealth Calvinism.
Thankfully there are a few here who believe what the Bible says in a plethora of verses throughout
the whole of the Bible from Genesis to Revelation, instead of replacing what is explicitly articulated
with your vain self-exalting philosophically based man-made precept which you pretend is a doctrine
despite there being zero Biblical support for it. Should we call what you believe HeIsHereism? No.

That would be a slur on His holy name, which you profane.
 
You will understand this is a compliment but you are the outlier of the Reformed belief members so you don't shock me when I see you doing the correct thing.
Overgeneralizations are almost always wrong. I personally know hundreds of the reformed faith who regularly share the gospel.
 
Spoken like a true seeker of the Truth.
More of your ego-driven self-aggrandizing misrepresentation.

Why would anyone be interesting in your bloviating?

Is it supposed to be entertainment, to see how many main and plain words you
can strip of their true meanings so they fit what you have been taught to think?
 
My message is the gospel. You are just another dishonest person who ignores what people say and misrepresent them. The phrase you employ has never come forth from my lips.
Ooohhhhh. But you DO believe it right?

-pre-selected/elected before birth? Check

-pre-selected/elected sovereignly with zero inputs from anybody? Check.

-Totally random as far as the winners and losers are concerned? Check.

Come on @rogerg @Magenta help me out here. Did I get that right?
 
Faith is a work in your view, so you contradict scripture then. Understood.

As well, all you did was list various Bible versions, and your soteriology is completely at odds with traditional non reformed understanding of the Gospel.

Fifty years ago the SBC would have shown the Calvinists/Reformed the door, but stealth Calvinists have corrupted traditional Christianity. Yes the testimonies are everywhere of those who exit these churches who have been overtaken.

Thankfully there are a few here who have not been brainwashed by this stealth Calvinism.
Actually, faith is a work according to you, as you say it results from the choice of man. Those who recognize that faith is a product of the grace of God in salvation make no such claim but ascribe all to the activity of God.
 
Actually, faith is a work according to you, as you say it results from the choice of man. Those who recognize that
faith is a product of the grace of God in salvation make no such claim but ascribe all to the activity of God.
They can't help lying. And let us not forget that in her theology, faith is not counted as something good.

It could be she has to cling to that lie just so she can say it did not come from God like all good things.

Which is what Scripture actually proclaims. But she denies.

It becomes horrifying after a while how much Scripture gets contradicted and denied by free willers.
 
The Numbers 21 bronze serpent scenario utterly dismantles every Calvinistic precept there ever was top to bottom. Despite them not having the slightest idea why.

Having said that, I also figure that every serpent bitten Calvinist-inclined soul in that camp surely perished.

Agree, there is no debate, and your presentation of this should have ended the thread, but what can they do, they have to save face, and descend to the most vile attacks.

I remember when there were pastors/churches which where not infected with this nonsense soteriology and held to the traditional plan.

It is very troubling when the simple plan of salvation has become corrupted .. for the appalling wait and see lottery selection process.
Responding positively to the personal GOOD NEWS of God's love and sacrifice......nope, not possible, here are the verses I have pulled out from any context which show the door is closed to you until God activates you, because your positive response is a work even if you could do it.

I find this so disgusting.

Numbers 21:6-9 (see also John 3:14)
The LORD sent fiery serpents among the people and they bit the people, so that many people of Israel died. So the people came to Moses and said, “We have sinned, because we have spoken against the LORD and you; intercede with the LORD, that He may remove the serpents from us.” And Moses interceded for the people. Then the LORD said to Moses, “Make a fiery serpent, and set it on a standard; and it shall come about, that everyone who is bitten, when he looks at it, he will live.” And Moses made a bronze serpent and set it on the standard; and it came about, that if a serpent bit any man, when he looked to the bronze serpent, he lived.

Dave Hunt a great man of the correct soteriology states:

Dave Hunt:

“The healing from the poisonous snakebite was not for a select group within Israel whom God had predestined to be healed, but for ‘everyone...any man.’ The only limitation was to look in faith to the upraised serpent.

Likewise, everyone who has been bitten by ‘that old serpent, called the Devil, and Satan’ (Revelation 12:9) is healed if they will but look in faith to Christ lifted up on the Cross.” (What Love is This?, pp.259-260)
 
  • Like
Reactions: HealthAndHappiness
Actually, faith is a work according to you, as you say it results from the choice of man. Those who recognize that faith is a product of the grace of God in salvation make no such claim but ascribe all to the activity of God.

Nowhere does scripture state that God gifts the initial/saving faith to His selected favorites, nope not even Ephesians 2:8.
It was posted awhile back.