Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Proud people can get saved. At the moment of salvation they were humbled.

But, after a time settled in, they sinned, lost the filling of the Spirit, and reverted back to their old ways of doing things

Believers can result in becoming proud people again.
They will be saved.
R. Ruining
U. Unlimited atonement
F. For
U. Unbelievers
S. Succinctly
:p
 
Proud people can get saved. At the moment of salvation they were humbled.

But, after a time settled in, they sinned, lost the filling of the Spirit, and reverted back to their old ways of doing things

Believers can result in becoming proud people again.
They will be saved.

But proud people never receive God's rescuing grace because that grace is given by God to His humble elect in eternity. It's not given to his elect in just temporal reality. All sinners desperately need the power of God's grace in to to be saved; but God clearly doesn't give that grace to all! Of course, I explained yesterday how God's elect were qualified by God to receive His precious grace in my 9963.
 
The Arminian has no problem seeing, or accepting, the exclusive love of God in the Old Testament for the nation of Israel, but fails to see the equally Biblical proposition of God’s love in the New Testament being exclusively for those whom He has chosen out of the world, and given to His Son.
The Arminian has no problem seeing, or accepting, the exclusive love of God in the Old Testament for the nation of Israel

False. God's love was by no means exclusive to Israel. Nothing could be further from the truth. In fact Israel was God's salvation program back then, by which men could obtain covenant promises and life. Because God loved the gentiles back then just as He does now.

And many DID choose the God of Israel back then.

This error is now becoming standardized Calvinist false doctrine.
 
The Arminian has no problem seeing, or accepting, the exclusive love of God in the Old Testament for the nation of Israel

False. God's love was by no means exclusive to Israel. Nothing could be further from the truth. In fact Israel was God's salvation program back then, by which men could obtain covenant promises and life. Because God loved the gentiles back then just as He does now.

And many DID choose the God of Israel back then.

This error is now becoming standardized Calvinist false doctrine.
This is why the conversation is ALWAYS at the basic/starting gate........Christ Died for ALL.

Doctrine cannot continue or advance if we don't know this BASIC principle.
 
Pray tell: Why don't you define "FWer" for us.
I have asked for a definition ... only to be told "it's difficult to come up with a working definition since it is not a Biblical concept".

you throw the term around ... surely you have a definition ???

please enlighten us and "define "FWer" for us".




Rufus said:
Are you not a FWer?
shrug ... don't know, since those who throw the term around have yet to define the term.



Rufus said:
Define yourself!
believer in the Lord Jesus Christ ... a member in particular placed by God in the body of the Lord Jesus Christ as it has pleased Him ... the one body over which the Lord Jesus Christ is the Head.

now ... how about you "Define yourself!" ...
.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kroogz
The Arminian has no problem seeing, or accepting, the exclusive love of God in the Old Testament for the nation of Israel

False. God's love was by no means exclusive to Israel. Nothing could be further from the truth. In fact Israel was God's salvation program back then, by which men could obtain covenant promises and life. Because God loved the gentiles back then just as He does now.

And many DID choose the God of Israel back then.

This error is now becoming standardized Calvinist false doctrine.
So when Saul was commanded to annihilate the Amalekites, that was a missionary journey? Who knew?
 
  • Like
Reactions: BillyBob
But proud people never receive God's rescuing grace because that grace is given by God to His humble elect in eternity. It's not given to his elect in just temporal reality. All sinners desperately need the power of God's grace in to to be saved; but God clearly doesn't give that grace to all! Of course, I explained yesterday how God's elect were qualified by God to receive His precious grace in my 9963.

You are not understanding.

Being proud is not limited to the unbeliever.
Legalistic believers are saved.
Not all of them, of course.
 
So when Saul was commanded to annihilate the Amalekites, that was a missionary journey? Who knew?


NO.... But when Jonah was told to preach to the degenerate, depraved, war-like Ninevites, it was a missionary journey.

Saul was commanded by God to have a preemptive attack on what God knew would be a problem for Israel.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kroogz
You're quite welcome. Of course, Jn 10 has some very explicit statements along the same lines. God only personally, intimately and covenantly knows His own people. The rest in the world, He has no such knowledge of. See also Ex 33:12, 17 wherein this truth is also taught.
It speaks to this whole error we see being repeatedly "voiced" in here, that nothing in Scripture
attests to man's inability, when in fact there are quite a few verses that address this very thing,
though the people who contradict and deny what the Bible says refuse to acknowledge such.
I wonder that they can keep repeating the same lies after the truth has been shown to them.
They must adhere to their false doctrine or throw it over for the truth. They prefer their false doctrine.
 
I'm not sure you got the point exactly, however here it is, the point was God for-knew you, so he already knows if your going to believe or not.

Knowing you will believe is not the same as choosing you to believe which is what the reformed mob teach.
 
I suppose that would depend on what you mean by "for-knew". What do you make of Mat 7:23? Or of 1Cor 8:3? Or of 2Tim 2:19?
It's means, he already knows your whole life before your born, even the time when he says to whoever I never knew you.

You could look at that scripture and think hang on a minute here is some one who the lord never knew at all. But you must remember even if that was so, it could have been put forward with different meanings, one being you don't get to know Jesus until the father is ready to hand you over.

Or it could be something else, I believe one of the interpretations is based upon those who will cry out for the lord but he won't listen,

Refering to those who think they know the lord, but they really don't because they haven't been handed over to the son from the father.

Also there's another interpretation that indicates when lord says gets away from me I never knew it's quite possibly leaning towards his return, as in those days refering to his return when many will say lord lord.

So it may even be refering to a future tense,
 
So when Saul was commanded to annihilate the Amalekites, that was a missionary journey? Who knew?
Saul was commanded to kill King Agag, and not necessarily all the Amalekites. Also, the commandment is to remember to forget Amalek who is associated as an enemy of Israel, and to not forget what he did. That is, ambushing and attacking Israel. Of course, God defends the legacy of those that love Him and so wouldn't support any of His enemies.
 
Some in here claim everyone hears. However, that is decidedly NOT what Scripture teaches.

John10-27-28es.png

John 10 verses 27-28 My sheep hear My voice, I know them and they follow Me. I give them eternal life, and they will never perish. No one can snatch them out of My hand.
:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cameron143
NO.... But when Jonah was told to preach to the degenerate, depraved, war-like Ninevites, it was a missionary journey.

Saul was commanded by God to have a preemptive attack on what God knew would be a problem for Israel.
The problem?.......The reformed/calvies/tulips look at them as pre-selected for the LoF. They are not the "Chosen."

And never look at the chance after chance of GRACE.
 
I must have missed that post. When did he ask you to be his judge?
it looks like you've missed a lot or perhaps your blissfully lazy daisy 🤔

Would you prefer if I don't judge bad inappropriate behaviour and just turn a blind eye ?
 
Knowing you will believe is not the same as choosing you to believe which is what the reformed mob teach.
I'm not sure I understand you. Anyone who is saved have been chosen

Who's the reformed mob btw.

Sounds like you've been watching to many mafia movies.