Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
A person begins to believe as they hear the Gospel preached and regeneration takes place immediately afterwards.
An individual believes when they hear and understand. The natural man believes the things of God are foolishness. It is the Spirit of God who gives life and enlightenment for one to receive that which is spiritual. Until such time, an individual remains in darkness.
 
An individual believes when they hear and understand. The natural man believes the things of God are foolishness. It is the Spirit of God who gives life and enlightenment for one to receive that which is spiritual. Until such time, an individual remains in darkness.

The Gospel is enlightenment and no-one here has ever said it is anyone other than God who informs the person as to his state (sinner) and his need (salvation).

You do God a disservice by suggesting He can deliver the Gospel but can't make a man understand what he's hearing. It is either received or it is rejected but God's grace has been effectual in what He set it out to do. To those who believe, more grace is given to effect salvation. To those who don't believe, no more grace and they remain dead in their sins.
 
The Gospel is enlightenment and no-one here has ever said it is anyone other than God who informs the person as to his state (sinner) and his need (salvation).

You do God a disservice by suggesting He can deliver the Gospel but can't make a man understand what he's hearing. It is either received or it is rejected but God's grace has been effectual in what He set it out to do. To those who believe, more grace is given to effect salvation. To those who don't believe, no more grace and they remain dead in their sins.
The study of his word requires that we receive it without bias or preconcieved doctrine in our hearts you either take him at his word or not trying to make it say something it isn't or trying to make it fit out specific beliefs will only make us blind to his word

Some have not taken this step yet and so they teach something that is flawed at best.
 
An individual believes when they hear and understand. The natural man believes the things of God are foolishness. It is the Spirit of God who gives life and enlightenment for one to receive that which is spiritual. Until such time, an individual remains in darkness.
But it's not Natural Man doing anything at all, it's the spirit inside of Natural Man. In fact, you can be saved 100 years and still have disbelief. Your spirit believes because it's directly connected to the Holy Ghost but the flesh will always be Natural Man and it doubts all that you believe in God.
 
But it's not Natural Man doing anything at all, it's the spirit inside of Natural Man. In fact, you can be saved 100 years and still have disbelief. Your spirit believes because it's directly connected to the Holy Ghost but the flesh will always be Natural Man and it doubts all that you believe in God.
The spirit speaks to the spirit not the flesh so even if we live in fleshly bodies the natural man still receieves what is spoken in spirit.
 
The Gospel is enlightenment and no-one here has ever said it is anyone other than God who informs the person as to his state (sinner) and his need (salvation).

You do God a disservice by suggesting He can deliver the Gospel but can't make a man understand what he's hearing. It is either received or it is rejected but God's grace has been effectual in what He set it out to do. To those who believe, more grace is given to effect salvation. To those who don't believe, no more grace and they remain dead in their sins.
I never said God can't make someone to understand. I say just the opposite. When an individual does understand, it is so by the activity of God. And I'm the one who introduced Isaiah 55:11 into the discussion. I believe salvation is totally and fully dependent upon God's purpose in sending forth His word. It is those who believe in freewill that say otherwise.
 
The spirit speaks to the spirit not the flesh so even if we live in fleshly bodies the natural man still receieves what is spoken in spirit.
Not if he does not have the Spirit.

It is where the whole free will argument falls down. They have the man without the Spirit receiving
and understanding Spiritual things, which Scripture plainly says the natural man cannot do. To get
around this some of them then claim the gospel is not a spiritual matter nor a deep thing of God.
They will say the natural man is not one without the Spirit, but simply a carnal Christian. They
strip the truth of the truth all in the name of clinging to their their vain self-exalting idol.


Spiritoftruth.png

Now the Lord is the Spirit, and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom (2 Cor ch 3 v 17). If anyone does not have the Spirit of Christ, he does not belong to Christ (Rom 8 v 9b). The world cannot receive the Spirit of truth, because it neither sees Him nor knows Him (from John 14 v 17). Those not in Christ are not free (see Heb 2 v 15). Praise God if He has rescued you from the dominion of darkness! (see Col 1 v 13)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cameron143
But it's not Natural Man doing anything at all, it's the spirit inside of Natural Man. In fact, you can be saved 100 years and still have disbelief. Your spirit believes because it's directly connected to the Holy Ghost but the flesh will always be Natural Man and it doubts all that you believe in God.
The Spirit can indwell an individual and he isn't saved?
 
The Bible specifically shows us several examples of the Holy Ghost coming upon people before they were Saved, never inside them first.
What you are speaking of is the baptism with the Spirit, and not the indwelling of the Spirit. Romans 8:9 says if one does not possess the Spirit of Christ, one doesn't belong to Christ. 1 Corinthians 12:3 says no one can call Jesus Lord except by the Holy Spirit.
 
1Corinthians2-14.png

The natural man does not accept the things that come from the Spirit of God. For they are foolishness to him, and he cannot understand them, because they are spiritually discerned. 1 Corinthians ch 2 v 14
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cameron143
What you are speaking of is the baptism with the Spirit, and not the indwelling of the Spirit. Romans 8:9 says if one does not possess the Spirit of Christ, one doesn't belong to Christ. 1 Corinthians 12:3 says no one can call Jesus Lord except by the Holy Spirit.
Actually I am showing the proper process how it happens to us all.

10 While Peter yet spake these words, the Holy Spirit fell on all them that heard the word


This is not inside them but upon them.
 
Actually I am showing the proper process how it happens to us all.

10 While Peter yet spake these words, the Holy Spirit fell on all them that heard the word


This is not inside them but upon them.
Right...the baptism with the Spirit. It is a sealing, and not an indwelling. Ephesians 1:13...after they believed, they were sealed. But in order to believe, they must already be indwelt...1 Corinthians 12:3.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blain
Not if he does not have the Spirit.

It is where the whole free will argument falls down. They have the man without the Spirit receiving
and understanding Spiritual things, which Scripture plainly says the natural man cannot do. To get
around this some of them then claim the gospel is not a spiritual matter nor a deep thing of God.
They will say the natural man is not one without the Spirit, but simply a carnal Christian. They
strip the truth of the truth all in the name of clinging to their their vain self-exalting idol.


Spiritoftruth.png

Now the Lord is the Spirit, and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom (2 Cor ch 3 v 17). If anyone does not have the Spirit of Christ, he does not belong to Christ (Rom 8 v 9b). The world cannot receive the Spirit of truth, because it neither sees Him nor knows Him (from John 14 v 17). Those not in Christ are not free (see Heb 2 v 15). Praise God if He has rescued you from the dominion of darkness! (see Col 1 v 13)
Wow people really think like this? it makes no sense the natural man cannot never has and never will understand the things of the spirit you can be a carnal Christian but that is not a good thing that is bad very bad.
 
The Spirit can indwell an individual and he isn't saved?
Cameron, do you think it is possible that God regenerated a non believer long ago - but the person is not saved until many years later. Or, do you think they must take place together. Just asking. . . .
 
But no one was regenerated until the Holy Ghost fell upon them and that didn't happen until after they heard the Gospel preached.

We have a perfect example of the complete process and verse 11 says they began Speaking in Tongues which was evidence they were Saved to those witnessing.

The Bible is very specific and clear how the process takes place.
 
Wow people really think like this? it makes no sense the natural man cannot never has and never will understand
the things of the spirit you can be a carnal Christian but that is not a good thing that is bad very bad.
Yes, they have said those ridiculous things and many others besides, and as
you well know some would rather blaspheme God than admit they are wrong.


They go to great lengths to cover up who the natural man is so they can say he is the one
who receives and understands what Scripture says the natural man cannot. Some would have
him not exist at all as if nobody is never not indwelt with the Holy Spirit of God. And they
continually ascribe to the natural man what is only possible of the spiritual man.
 
Right...the baptism with the Spirit. It is a sealing, and not an indwelling. Ephesians 1:13...after they believed, they were sealed. But in order to believe, they must already be indwelt...1 Corinthians 12:3.
People can confuse the sealing with the indwelling and this causes problems in understanding because without the indwelling one cannot receieve the things of the spirit to begin with because the carnal man perceives not the things of the spirit

The sealing however involves sealing what is already there Peter already had the spirit in him "Blessed are you, Simon son of Jonah, for this was not revealed to you by flesh and blood, but by my Father in heaven," after Peter declared Jesus is the Messiah

one cannot understand the father without the spirit saying otherwise is just silly
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cameron143
Yes, they have said those ridiculous things and many others besides, and as
you well know some would rather blaspheme God than admit they are wrong.
Yeah it is a pride thing people refuse to admit they are wrong due to pride.
If one wants to be in debates especially one as tricky as this one one has to be able to admit they could be wrong otherwise it is just pride and childish behaviour refusing to admit they were wrong for whatever reason is not a sign of a mature believer

I have learned a lot from being wrong I don't see what is so bad about it
 
But no one was regenerated until the Holy Ghost fell upon them and that didn't happen until after they heard the Gospel preached.

We have a perfect example of the complete process and verse 11 says they began Speaking in Tongues which was evidence they were Saved to those witnessing.

The Bible is very specific and clear how the process takes place.
Actually the scriptures say 1 Corinthians 2:14 New American Standard Bible - NASB 1995 (NASB1995) But a natural man does not accept the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him; and he cannot understand them, because they are spiritually appraised. so in order for Peter to understand that Jesus was the messiah he first had to have the holy spirit in him otherwise it would not have been made known to him.

There is a difference between the indwelling of the spirit and the baptism of it or the sealing