Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
They cling to their teaching involving total depravity because it helps them to avoid the feelings of guilt for how much they know they hated God.

They can not rightly divide the nature of man.

Flesh = depravity.
Soul = takes its lead from the flesh, but is not innately depraved like the flesh.

Grace separates the flesh's effect over the soul, from the soul.
Then, the soul is placed in a position to consider what God has to show the soul for it's consideration.

No man needs to be regenerated first to know he is a sinner.
For knowing one is a sinner is not a spiritual matter.

God looks to see what is in that soul when the Gospel is presented while grace is being given.

Then? While someone is placed in such a position to choose?

The soul either wishes the Cross were true (can not yet believe it is true).
Or, wants nothing to do with the Cross.

That is what determined who God will make their wish into a reality by grace and faith...
Or, discontinue drawing that negative soul.


God is a gentleman.
I believe your miss representing scripture here, there's plenty of scripture that paint the picture that sin is a direct consequence of our internal desires.

It has nothing to with anyone hating God, it's to do with what his word says,
 
Whoever belongs to God hears the words of God.

It does not say...

Whoever belongs to God obeys the words of God.

Adam belonged to God.
Adam heard the words of God.
..................

Adam was never in a covenant relationship with God!

And who hears the word of God hears with spiritual ears which leads to obedience.
 
I have another question for you FWers: Would this world be better off with more or fewer born again Christians in it who help with God's work of restraining evil? Think before you answer. :coffee:
 
I believe your miss representing scripture here, there's plenty of scripture that paint the picture that sin is a direct consequence of our internal desires.

It has nothing to with anyone hating God, it's to do with what his word says,

And hate isn't an internal desire? What is hate: just a corn on your big toe? :rolleyes:

P.S. You do know that God loves those who LOVE Him, right?
 
What did you ever do to deserve life? The wages of sin is death. All sin.

Do you think this makes God unfair? You already call Him unfair.

But then, you are a God-blasphemer after all.

Plus, my Bible says man is without excuse.

Does yours say something different???

Or do you just like to kvetch about God?

Says... the purple haired girl, whispering into the ear of a unicorn....

With a dragon tattoo on her left arm?

(Reminder!)

Your free will chose that avatar!
 
And hate isn't an internal desire? What is hate: just a corn on your big toe? :rolleyes:

P.S. You do know that God loves those who LOVE Him, right?
I've no idea how my reply to genez warranted this reply.

Genez said we hate God.

I said and meant it has nothing to with hating God why we say people are depraved it has to with what his word says.

Your just twisting everything Im saying now.

And still you can't answer if God decreed sin.
 
And still you can't answer if God decreed sin.

That is an awkward way of wording it.
It almost makes it look like God is the author of sin.
And, it is still not clear as to your exact intent.

But.. just the same.

God did not decree sin, per se.
Rather, God decreed with Adam the freedom to sin, if he should so so chose.
 
That is an awkward way of wording it.
It almost makes it look like God is the author of sin.
And, it is still not clear as to your exact intent.

But.. just the same.

God did not decree sin, per se.
Rather, God decreed with Adam the freedom to sin, if he should so so chose.
well listen you make it really hard for anyone to find agreement on this topic and if you could leave magenta alone that would be good, and I'm asking rufus, for his answer, because I've been discussing with him for 3 days.

So I'll wait for his answer,

That is all
 
absolute nonsense as usual from you
I do believe that Genez is correct in saying that Adam had the ability to obey or disobey. Since he disobeyed, he died to sin and brought a corruption to all men which they, themselves, cannot escape. Now man is without the ability to please God.
That is precisely why we need to be renewed by the Grace of God. Without this renewal, no man can come to Christ. John 3:3
 
  • Like
Reactions: Genez
absolute nonsense as usual from you

Not what you wanted to hear, eh?

For the time will come when they will not put up with sound doctrine.
Instead, to suit their own desires, they will gather around them a great
number of teachers to say what their itching ears want to hear.
2 Timothy 4:3​
 
I do believe that Genez is correct in saying that Adam had the ability to obey or disobey. Since he disobeyed, he died to sin and brought a corruption to all men which they, themselves, cannot escape. Now man is without the ability to please God.
That is precisely why we need to be renewed by the Grace of God. Without this renewal, no man can come to Christ. John 3:3

Correct...

Adam was created without sin.
Jesus was born as Adam had been created.

Therefore Adam had the ability to obey, or disobey.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rewriter
I do believe that Genez is correct in saying that Adam had the ability to obey or disobey. Since he disobeyed, he died to sin and brought a corruption to all men which they, themselves, cannot escape. Now man is without the ability to please God.
That is precisely why we need to be renewed by the Grace of God. Without this renewal, no man can come to Christ. John 3:3
being able to obey is not the same as God decreeing Adam to sin is it. and to be honest with you I'm more bothered by his nonsense of once again making magenta look evil in his post before this one your quoting.

So you believe God decreed sin to. ?

Obeying Gods will that lives in you when your sin free, is not the same as God decreeing sin. And I'll nit bother sharing why this important.. rejection of truth seems very popular here.

Anyhow im just about done giving my time here.

3000 posts I've made to this thread of absolute truths I may as well have not bothered, as I've had nearly every post twisted corrupted denied, hated, name called, you name it .

Well I'm taking a break from there probably for good

You take care of yourself.
 
being able to obey is not the same as God decreeing Adam to sin is it. and to be honest with you I'm more bothered by his nonsense of once again making magenta look evil in his post before this one your quoting.

So you believe God decreed sin to. ?

Obeying Gods will that lives in you when your sin free, is not the same as God decreeing sin. And I'll nit bother sharing why this important.. rejection of truth seems very popular here.

Anyhow im just about done giving my time here.

3000 posts I've made to this thread of absolute truths I may as well have not bothered, as I've had nearly every post twisted corrupted denied, hated, name called, you name it .

Well I'm taking a break from there probably for good

You take care of yourself.

God did not decree that Adam would sin.

That almost sound like God made Adam to sin.
Need to be careful how we word things.

God knowing that Adam would sin if given the chance via certain temptation, decreed to allow his fall to take place.


........
 
, God decreed with Adam the freedom to sin, if he should so so chose.

Err your the one who said God decreed sin,

I asked did he


What part of me asking did he says I believe he did.

You need help.

Anyway I'm done speaking you, you can't be helped
 
Err your the one who said God decreed sin,

I asked did he


What part of me asking did he says I believe he did.

You need help.

Anyway I'm done speaking you, you can't be helped

God decreed that you would have a low threshold for impatience.
 
God decreed that Adam would sin when tempted.
Not, God decreed Adam to sin.
That is an interesting view, but I trust that you are aware that the first mention of "sin" recorded is in Genesis 4:7 "If you do what is right, will you not be accepted? But if you do not do what is right, sin is crouching at your door." God, in Genesis 3 never calls Adam's or Eve's action as "sin"