Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
no. The gospel of Christ is the power of God unto salvation just as Scripture tells us.

Do you think the "knowledge of God through creation and conscience" can be one of the ways God draws us to Himself.
.
Sure, God can use anything. But this doesn't mean He always employs this means, or does so regularly. What we do know is that He employs it to hold man accountable and without excuse.
 
Titus 2:11-12 For the grace of God that bringeth salvation hath appeared to all men Teaching us that, denying ungodliness and worldly lusts, we should live soberly, righteously, and godly, in this present world

that all men do not learn the lesson does not mean the grace of God has not appeared to all men ... it just means some turn from the teaching of the grace of God to man's "teaching" (aka lies).
.

That "teaching" that takes place is not being told to not do something, and told to do something else.
It is a not a teacher-student arrangement.

My pastor taught Titus 2:11-12 to us from the Greek. He showed something that reading a translation for yourself would leave you without a clue.

That word translated "teaching' has a particular meaning.

It means to be taught a lesson by allowing someone to do something wrong.
To do something wrong so he would get hurt by doing it.
It is the hurting that teaches us to say "No!"

It is why we can see a wild generation growing up, and turning to marriage. Where before, everyone was wild with free sex.
They got terribly hurt from their sinning. Grace was there to give them the needed strength for the conviction to say "No!"

It is for all men. Not just the elect.
 
Seems that you decided to reply to a single sentence rather than the entire post.
If that is typical, then there is no need for me to answer your questions in the future.......

It took the entire post to address just that one sentence.

Now you are looking for an out to excuse yourself from the dialogue?

Until that one sentence was addressed it would make no sense to continue.
 
1-Corinthians1-20-25.png

1 Corinthians 1 v 20-25 Where is the wise man? Where is the scribe? Where is the philosopher of this age? Has not God made foolish the wisdom of the world? For since in the wisdom of God the world through its wisdom did not know Him, God was pleased through the foolishness of what was preached to save those who believe. Jews demand signs and Greeks search for wisdom, but we preach Christ crucified, a stumbling block to Jews and foolishness to Gentiles, but to those who are called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God. For the foolishness of God is wiser than man’s wisdom, and the weakness of God is stronger than man’s strength.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cameron143
It took the entire post to address just that one sentence.

Now you are looking for an out to excuse yourself from the dialogue?

Until that one sentence was addressed it would make no sense to continue.
I agree! I just want to answer, not start endless nit-picking.
 
That "teaching" that takes place is not being told to not do something, and told to do something else.
It is a not a teacher-student arrangement.

My pastor taught Titus 2:11-12 to us from the Greek. He showed something that reading a translation for yourself would leave you without a clue.

That word translated "teaching' has a particular meaning.

It means to be taught a lesson by allowing someone to do something wrong.
To do something wrong so he would get hurt by doing it.
It is the hurting that teaches us to say "No!"
right ... God trains through teaching, instructing, educating, nurturing ... and God trains us through chastening, reproving, rebuking, correcting ... all for our benefit.

Hebrews 12:11 Now no chastening for the present seemeth to be joyous, but grievous: nevertheless afterward it yieldeth the peaceable fruit of righteousness unto them which are exercised thereby.




Genez said:
It is why we can see a wild generation growing up, and turning to marriage. Where before, everyone was wild with free sex.
They got terribly hurt from their sinning. Grace was there to give them the needed strength for the conviction to say "No!"

It is for all men. Not just the elect.
in agreement.
.
 
Not so. I just disregarded it. I didn't try to keep it from my consciousness.
well ... whatever you did, you did not believe and you did not receive the salvation promised to those who believe (at that time ... I know you believed at a later point and God, Who is faithful, fulfilled His promise).
.
 
no probs it not worth looking at anyway I've posted the wrong number. I've decided to not post the right number as it will probably just make your mind go numb temporally like it did mine

He was asked a question about it and he ignored it.

So no doubt he will ignore you to and even if he doesn't ignore he will probably be ignorant in his post.
Okay, no worries, Jordon, I was just curious...

but I was also wondering about your apahsia, and racing, hoping the two are not closely related.

Do you race professionally?
 
It took the entire post to address just that one sentence.
some folks have so many rules to follow ... you must submit the whole post ... and if you do submit the whole post but you're only responding to part of the post, make sure you point that out ... whew!!! ... what the heck kind of "yoke of bondage" is being slung about in this thread ?!!!
.
 
some folks have so many rules to follow ... you must submit the whole post ... and if you do submit the whole post but you're only responding to part of the post, make sure you point that out ... whew!!! ... what the heck kind of "yoke of bondage" is being slung about in this thread ?!!!
.

Sorry, but Genez ask the following question:

How ... In your understanding .... Does grace alone save you?
Maybe if we can find out what it is you are thinking.

I believe that I explained my thinking quite well. However, the fact that he has used his freewill to disagree is not my problem.
 
well ... whatever you did, you did not believe and you did not receive the salvation promised to those who believe (at that time ... I know you believed at a later point and God, Who is faithful, fulfilled His promise).
.
All unbelief is not suppression. Some is simply rejection. And when I didn't believe, it was because God was not working in me to bring me to faith. When He did so, I did believe.
 
some folks have so many rules to follow ... you must submit the whole post ... and if you do submit the whole post but you're only responding to part of the post, make sure you point that out ... whew!!! ... what the heck kind of "yoke of bondage" is being slung about in this thread ?!!!
.
If you had simply said you were only responding to one aspect of a post, you could have easily have avoided confusion. That was your choice.
Also, many people here only quote part of a post to try to make a point by misrepresenting the entirety of what was said. That's why I ask people to quote my entire posts. You are one of a few with differing views who regularly does so.
Also, I offered an apology if to any who were offended by my post. Were you offended? No one else said they were offended.
 
Lots of people think free will exists also even though they can't show it from scripture.
That is because it is not there and also the fact that Scripture teaches the opposite:

According to Scripture, man's will is not free.

People are simply deceived.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cameron143
That "teaching" that takes place is not being told to not do something, and told to do something else.
It is a not a teacher-student arrangement.

My pastor taught Titus 2:11-12 to us from the Greek. He showed something that reading a translation for yourself would leave you without a clue.

That word translated "teaching' has a particular meaning.

It means to be taught a lesson by allowing someone to do something wrong.
To do something wrong so he would get hurt by doing it.
It is the hurting that teaches us to say "No!"

It is why we can see a wild generation growing up, and turning to marriage. Where before, everyone was wild with free sex.
They got terribly hurt from their sinning. Grace was there to give them the needed strength for the conviction to say "No!"

It is for all men. Not just the elect.
I remember Thieme saying something similar regarding that peculiar Greek terminology.
 
Okay, no worries, Jordon, I was just curious...

but I was also wondering about your apahsia, and racing, hoping the two are not closely related.

Do you race professionally?
yep they are related I hit an oil patch whilst cornering at high speed in race, a bit of a bump but I'm ok.
The only speech problems I get is I can't talk sometimes, but as soon a start to talk I'm ok

But mainly it can only be seen when I'm writing like here I've already had to correct leaving words out several times, and putting words in the wrong order. but I'm fine no real damage really memory is good,

I'm not allowed to race professionally anymore, so I just race with my vr head set now 😂.

Not the real deal but I love it just the same.
 
I agree! I just want to answer, not start endless nit-picking.
There was information being passed on that I believe you need to learn.
Not nit picking.

Why do you see that as nit picking?

You're treating the Word of God as it it is a trite matter?
When what I showed you was an important thing to know, that you have not yet been exposed to to consider?

I was trying to give you what would help you to better stand before the Lord and benefit your future.
 
Sorry, but Genez ask the following question:

How ... In your understanding .... Does grace alone save you?
Maybe if we can find out what it is you are thinking.

I believe that I explained my thinking quite well. However, the fact that he has used his freewill to disagree is not my problem.


It was not correct. It was simply a text book report from the denominational teachings you have been given.
I, in turn, wanted to show you how it is not correct.
Not to put you down.
But to maybe open a door to a better understanding.