David turns to her and says in a serious tone, "Have you seen a blue horse anywhere around the church property lately?" She answers, "No, is there a blue horse around here somewhere?" David says, "No, I was just wondering if you've seen any lately." By this time, he's looking directly at her and grinning from ear to ear.
Susan can't help but giggle a little.
I mean this in the nicest way possible but if any man said this to me, I would assume he's mentally disabled. I would be really nice to him but not interested romantically.
And the last sentence...it seems creepy to me.
As a woman, I have to agree with Noel's post.
I love that that first thread post was thoughtful and detailed, but I couldn't help raising my eyebrows at the scenario of David asking Susan if she'd seen a blue horse around the church -- and her "giggling" in response.
I know it was just an example, and examples can be hard to come up with, but the comment about the "blue horse" would be more like something I would have gotten from the kids while working in the children's church. And the only time I would have "giggled" in response is if I were hearing it from a 7-year-old.
If a grown man said this to me, I would be concerned. Granted, I'm someone who spent two halves of my life in churches that were polar opposites -- ultra conservative WELS (Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod) and then the Assemblies of God, where there seemed to be a strong emphasis on recognizing and rebuking demons.
Now, I certainly wouldn't think the man had a demon or anything like that, but, being the overthinker that I am, I would definitely want to know WHY he was talking about blue horses and why they were appearing to him at church.
I know this probably sounds crazy in itself and some will say, "Silly Seoul, can't you just take a little joke?"
But I live in an area where alcohol and drug use is rampant, so as much of a party pooper as I might be, my very first concern would be whether or not this person was under the influence of something a bit more radical than just the Holy Spirit.
Granted, it COULD lead up to a very interesting and undoubtedly unforgettable introduction.
But if not given the time to properly explain, it could, as Noel pointed out, be misinterpreted as a glaring red flag rather than a playful opening line.
Just out of curiosity,
@SteveEpperson, have you or anyone you know used the "blue horse" line before? If so, how did it go?