Do you attend church? I was going to suggest maybe invite a few ladies from church over a couple times a month for maybe a movie, game night, or just tea & fellowship. Or invite ladies from your work. Each person can bring a snack or drinks. You could hold a Bible study in your home, or perhaps a ladies exercise class. Anything where you can make friends and have fun, ya know? I actually did all those things when I was a young Christian because I had moved to a new location and was lonely for fellowship. I met a lot of great friends that way.
Believe me, you are not alone feeling that you're weird, LadyInWaiting. My entire family are weirdo nerds. I'm their leader.
We make the best of it by just owning it and laughing about it. But isn't it lots more fun being at liberty and not having to live up to some worldly cookie-cutter standards to fit in? From what I've observed on this site the past several years, I haven't seen too many people I would call "normal" here, have you? I think we fit in pretty well with these bunch of oddballs.