What makes a "Good Christian"?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

cinder

Senior Member
Mar 26, 2014
4,436
2,423
113
#1
For those who missed it, I got into a discussion in another thread about how we needed to become more specific when looking for a partner than just saying we want a godly or good Christian partner, but we should actually put some specifics to that. So for all those who want to date and possibly marry a good Christian. Here are some questions to think about and discuss both in what you mean by good Christian partner and maybe for the brave and brutally honest, to compare your answers with your actual behavior to see if you meet your own definition of good Christian:

1) How often does a good Christian attend church services? What does their church involvement look like?
2) What is a good Christian's personal devotional life like?
3) What holiday's does a good Christian celebrate (Puritans thought celebrating Christmas was evil. Some missionaries will try to work the truth of Jesus into existing local holidays)?
4) How much of their time and money does a good Christian give away?
5) How does a good Christian act a restaurant?
6) How does a good Christian respond to other people who are sinning? Does it make a difference if the sinners are acquaintances or strangers? Believers or unbelievers?
7) How does a good Christian interact with unbelievers?
8) What about dating and sexual behavior? How does a good Christian behave on dates? How does a good Christian deal with sexual temptations?
9) Is there a limit to how much money or power a person can have and still be a good Christian?
10) How does a good Christian conduct themselves at work? What policies do they have in place if they own a business and employ other people?

Ok that's enough for starters. Answers will vary and some people will be wrong ( I'm reminded of the scene in Ivanhoe where the most evil of the knights who is holding our protagonists hostage with plans to kill them tells the priest who comes to give them the last rites, " I am a good Christian") but this is mostly to get us thinking and talking about what we think of when we think of a good Christian.
 

seoulsearch

OutWrite Trouble
May 23, 2009
16,713
5,623
113
#2
For those who missed it, I got into a discussion in another thread about how we needed to become more specific when looking for a partner than just saying we want a godly or good Christian partner, but we should actually put some specifics to that. So for all those who want to date and possibly marry a good Christian. Here are some questions to think about and discuss both in what you mean by good Christian partner and maybe for the brave and brutally honest, to compare your answers with your actual behavior to see if you meet your own definition of good Christian:

1) How often does a good Christian attend church services? What does their church involvement look like?
2) What is a good Christian's personal devotional life like?
3) What holiday's does a good Christian celebrate (Puritans thought celebrating Christmas was evil. Some missionaries will try to work the truth of Jesus into existing local holidays)?
4) How much of their time and money does a good Christian give away?
5) How does a good Christian act a restaurant?
6) How does a good Christian respond to other people who are sinning? Does it make a difference if the sinners are acquaintances or strangers? Believers or unbelievers?
7) How does a good Christian interact with unbelievers?
8) What about dating and sexual behavior? How does a good Christian behave on dates? How does a good Christian deal with sexual temptations?
9) Is there a limit to how much money or power a person can have and still be a good Christian?
10) How does a good Christian conduct themselves at work? What policies do they have in place if they own a business and employ other people?

Ok that's enough for starters. Answers will vary and some people will be wrong ( I'm reminded of the scene in Ivanhoe where the most evil of the knights who is holding our protagonists hostage with plans to kill them tells the priest who comes to give them the last rites, " I am a good Christian") but this is mostly to get us thinking and talking about what we think of when we think of a good Christian.
Hey Cinder,

Thank you for taking the time to write out most of the questions I wish would be asked EVERY time we get a thread about how absolutely evil it is to date an unbeliever.

Now please don't misunderstand. I am in no way, shape, or form trying to argue with the Bible's wisdom that teaches us to avoid being unequally yoked.

But after growing up in the church community, this is the list of questions I wish would be asked OF BELIEVERS every single time the topic of "not being unequally yoked" comes up.

If someone prays to a heathen deity, regularly consults tarot cards for guidance, and talks to spirits through ouija boards, it's pretty much a no-brainer that this person would be an unequal yoking for a Christian.

But no one ever talks about the many, many ways in which Christians are unequally yoked with other Christians, and if we get down to the nitty gritty of what it means to be "equally yoked," how many of us will actually find someone to marry?

* If Sister Sally thinks A Good Christian goes to church once a week and Woeful William thinks every Good Christian worth their salt goes to church at least 3 times a week (and don't forget Bible class,) how equally yoked are they? Which church will they join? Will William start going to church less, or will Sally start going to church more? How many times a week will their kids be expected to go in order to grow up to be Good Christians?

* If Saintly Sarah believes in tithing 10% of her money to the church, and Believing Bill says that's an Old Testament law that he is no longer under, what will they both have to compromise in order to agree on how to manage their money?

* If Faithful Frances believes a good Christian must have read or know at least 50% of the Bible and Newcomer Norm just became a Christian a year ago and is just starting to learn it, how will Frances encourage Norm instead of looking down at him for what she perceives as his lack of knowledge?

I very rarely, if ever, see these types of questions addressed. Rather, we as single believers are just told to go out and find another believer to marry, as if that's as easy as picking out a bag of chips at the grocery store and tossing it into our cart, because apparently that's the "magic formula" that makes everything work out.

And yet no one mentions the realities of differences such as these, let alone how to deal with them, because these differences will come up and will make or break the relationship.

But no one gives us any guidance on how to deal with these differences, and in the meantime, we wonder why so many couples wind up divorcing. :rolleyes:
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
27,742
9,661
113
#3
Oh, for DATING specifically... um... yeah, can't help you there. I saw the thread title and thought I could contribute, but I have no idea what being a good christian constitutes when used as criteria for finding a spouse.

I'm pretty sure I could fake all the stuff in that list though, if I wanted the girl bad enough. You think a good christian teaches three bible studies a week? Sure thing babe, anything for you.

But... after we are married, after I "got her," I'm not sure how much longer I could keep up the act. And if she was putting on an act to get me, I'm not sure how long she would be willing to keep it up after we were married.
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,188
113
#4
what

about

the

bad

christians.

and why the obsession with marriage? Just because some weddings happen in churches doesnt mean everyone who marries in them is a believer. Also, you dont need to marry in a church. You could marry in a barn or hotel or a parking lot or the courthouse.

its not about how good or bad a christian you are. Marriage is more about how faithful you are to each other. How many people marry, then decide oh this person bores me now so I'll just go off and find someone else, and becomes UNFAITHFUL. And they could have believed in God, or the tooth fairy or that people evolved from rocks!
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,188
113
#5
sorry I just have this reaction when people talk about 'good christians' because Jesus was like why do you call me good...nobody is good except for God.

And He was right.
 

cinder

Senior Member
Mar 26, 2014
4,436
2,423
113
#6
Oh, for DATING specifically... um... yeah, can't help you there. I saw the thread title and thought I could contribute, but I have no idea what being a good christian constitutes when used as criteria for finding a spouse.

I'm pretty sure I could fake all the stuff in that list though, if I wanted the girl bad enough. You think a good christian teaches three bible studies a week? Sure thing babe, anything for you.

But... after we are married, after I "got her," I'm not sure how much longer I could keep up the act. And if she was putting on an act to get me, I'm not sure how long she would be willing to keep it up after we were married.
It doesn't have to be for dating specifically. Simply trying to define what makes a Christian a good Christian or what kind of person we actually have in mind when we talk about a good Christian. Because well it seems so many Christians believe that a good Christian practices their faith exactly like they do despite the known diversity of Chrsitian belief and practice.
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
27,742
9,661
113
#7
It doesn't have to be for dating specifically. Simply trying to define what makes a Christian a good Christian or what kind of person we actually have in mind when we talk about a good Christian. Because well it seems so many Christians believe that a good Christian practices their faith exactly like they do despite the known diversity of Chrsitian belief and practice.
Oh. That's a lot more simple. Christians are followers of Christ and should do what Christ did. He spent all his time helping people.

That'll burn a Christian out though, unless he understands why Christ did that. The whole thing about if I do this and that and the other, but don't have love, it's all worthless... that wasn't just a good morale booster. If you try to do what a Christian does, but don't have the driving force that Christ had, it gets real hard to keep it up after a while.
 
Aug 28, 2020
79
24
8
#8
As someone said a little earlier, there are no good people, hence no good Christians. We're all sinners, and that's the take away from the faith. We all do things that are sins and will continue to do so. Jesus that people were going to falter, and it's the reason that He had said to love and forgive one and other. Accept you're a sinner, bear and take up your cross, and follow Him.

All these questions seem redundant to even ask because we know how we should act out in public and we know how to celebrate holidays. If you wish to celebrate Halloween, go ahead, but just don't worship Satan and promote evil. If you want to have an alcoholic beverage, knock yourself out. Jesus drank wine because He enjoyed it. There's wrong with enjoying things like that, but just don't become an alcoholic. In other words, don't let that be the center of your life. Jesus also hung out with non-believers and made them believers through His Word and action. So there's nothing wrong with making them friends, but make sure not to be tempted into things that go against God's Word.

Basically everything asked here should have already been addressed from our parents/family members/foster-parents/guardians raising us. You KNOW how to act. The only thing here to ask do you CHOOSE to follow through on what you've been taught? Sexual immorality is something to avoid, but many people CHOOSE it anyway, Christian AND non-Christian. In other words, you CHOOSE to sin to make yourself feel better, even though it will cause more damage to yourself and the person(s) in front of you. That's part of the reason why we should avoid sin as much as what we can, but we're weak.

Same things can be made about dating. I see some on here that didn't like my last thread I made on here, which is fine, but this is where I was going with it:

For the men, do you choose to give into following the advice of others that don't even follow it themselves? They say we have to put on a song and dance for women in order to attract them. The answer to that is no you don't. They say personality is also what you need, so be yourself. It helps, but that's only partially true. You need to have some sort of physical appeal. Nothing overly sexual, and that's not where I'm going with this either. Dieting, working out, dressing better, and how you hold yourself up ARE part one on how to attract a woman. You're showing that you care for yourself enough that you took the initiative to look better, giving off a vibe that you want to be taken seriously. I noticed that when I was dating. The people I was with treated more like a mature adult rather than a kid. Dress like a slob or too goofy looking when you're noticeably out of shape, than they don't. And let's not play games here, women go for the guys that are attractive. David, before he became king of Israel, was described as a good looking man, which means he took care of himself, and he was also described as a man after God's own heart. So long as we stay faithful to God, there's nothing wrong with looking good, and feels great when someone, especially women, says we do. Only question is do you want to go that route?

For women, are you looking for a man that strives to do good and has standards and preferences based on their faith, or do you desire men who are selfish and will only go out with you to have bedroom fun? You listen to those that, more or less, tell you that a custom made man, by your own design, is the only thing that matters. Sure, the things you're looking for are great, but why go over the top with some of these other unnecessary qualities? And why force onto other men that may not possess them? That makes no sense whatsoever. I understand there are men that do that, but there's no need to do it yourselves. If you like a man the way he is, then allow him to take you out. Chances are good that he's not perfect, but you're not either. That's okay though because if he's a caring person towards you and others, that he means well, and he has given his life to Christ, that should be enough. And if you do want to be with him, you HAVE to allow him to lead. As a ballroom dancer, it's vital that the lead leads. Otherwise, the routine won't work. This also symbolizes and honors what Christ does for His people: He leads and we follow. Remember that.

All this, though is where we get into trouble as Christians and trying to have people believing in the truth. Many of us who proclaim ourselves as followers in Christ come off as arrogant, condescending, and extremely judgmental. Many of those same Christians don't take the time to sit and LISTEN to what's happening in a non-believer's life. Instead, we jump in so quickly to condemn them rather gather all the facts and information about these people. Being civil towards them seems like a task at times. Christ took it upon Himself to hear out what these people had to say. He gave truths, but was never harsh nor condescending towards these people. In place of that, He gave solutions, which led to real hope. That's how He was able to make friends out of them. So don't try to be perfect nor put on that persona that you are because you're not. But if people see that you're just as vulnerable as everyone else, while standing strong in your faith, people will come to you. Even though we're not entirely good, there's nothing wrong with trying to do good.
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
27,742
9,661
113
#9
*Lynx has a sudden coughing fit and walks away quickly with a paw crammed in his mouth.
 

RodB651

Well-known member
Feb 11, 2021
761
482
63
59
#10
Great questions Cinder... I'll have to think on this a while.
 

cinder

Senior Member
Mar 26, 2014
4,436
2,423
113
#11
As someone said a little earlier, there are no good people, hence no good Christians. We're all sinners, and that's the take away from the faith. We all do things that are sins and will continue to do so. Jesus that people were going to falter, and it's the reason that He had said to love and forgive one and other. Accept you're a sinner, bear and take up your cross, and follow Him.
Often such thinking becomes an excuse for lack of progress in sanctification. Or as a song from when I was a teen put it " You may say its only natural for me to act this way, I know it's only natural but I have not been made only natural. .... I've got the spirit of the living God alive in me giving me power so I don't have to be only natural." More recently the slogan that embodied this for me, though it was in a different context is " progress not perfection".

All these questions seem redundant to even ask because we know how we should act out in public and we know how to celebrate holidays. If you wish to celebrate Halloween, go ahead, but just don't worship Satan and promote evil. If you want to have an alcoholic beverage, knock yourself out. Jesus drank wine because He enjoyed it. There's wrong with enjoying things like that, but just don't become an alcoholic. In other words, don't let that be the center of your life. Jesus also hung out with non-believers and made them believers through His Word and action. So there's nothing wrong with making them friends, but make sure not to be tempted into things that go against God's Word.

Basically everything asked here should have already been addressed from our parents/family members/foster-parents/guardians raising us. You KNOW how to act. The only thing here to ask do you CHOOSE to follow through on what you've been taught? Sexual immorality is something to avoid, but many people CHOOSE it anyway, Christian AND non-Christian. In other words, you CHOOSE to sin to make yourself feel better, even though it will cause more damage to yourself and the person(s) in front of you. That's part of the reason why we should avoid sin as much as what we can, but we're weak.
But we don't all have the same parents raising us and Christians don't agree on what the most proper course of action is. Let's dig into just a couple of the questions that you didn't bother to answer as examples: Restuarants - should you ask the waitress for prayer requests? Should your faith influence how much you tip? Should you pray before your meal? How should a Christian respond when the service isn't that great? These are rubber meets the road type questions that help people who care to live out their faith.


Other practical concerns and areas of conflict, how much planning can you do and still live by faith? What decisions should you pray about together and what can you be trusted to decide on your own without consciously checking in with God? When the call comes to give for an emergency crisis, should you give everything in the bank and trust God to provide money to pay your bills or should you set some rational limits to what you are willing to give? How long and hard to you pray before you accept that it's God saying no and not a lack of faith on your part? Is demanding a certain level of intellectual rigor in discerning the voice of God wise or legalistic? And those are just questions that have come up in my own walk and interactions with other Christians.

Same things can be made about dating. I see some on here that didn't like my last thread I made on here, which is fine, but this is where I was going with it:

For the men, do you choose to give into following the advice of others that don't even follow it themselves? They say we have to put on a song and dance for women in order to attract them. The answer to that is no you don't. They say personality is also what you need, so be yourself. It helps, but that's only partially true. You need to have some sort of physical appeal. Nothing overly sexual, and that's not where I'm going with this either. Dieting, working out, dressing better, and how you hold yourself up ARE part one on how to attract a woman. You're showing that you care for yourself enough that you took the initiative to look better, giving off a vibe that you want to be taken seriously. I noticed that when I was dating. The people I was with treated more like a mature adult rather than a kid. Dress like a slob or too goofy looking when you're noticeably out of shape, than they don't. And let's not play games here, women go for the guys that are attractive. David, before he became king of Israel, was described as a good looking man, which means he took care of himself, and he was also described as a man after God's own heart. So long as we stay faithful to God, there's nothing wrong with looking good, and feels great when someone, especially women, says we do. Only question is do you want to go that route?

For women, are you looking for a man that strives to do good and has standards and preferences based on their faith, or do you desire men who are selfish and will only go out with you to have bedroom fun? You listen to those that, more or less, tell you that a custom made man, by your own design, is the only thing that matters. Sure, the things you're looking for are great, but why go over the top with some of these other unnecessary qualities? And why force onto other men that may not possess them? That makes no sense whatsoever. I understand there are men that do that, but there's no need to do it yourselves. If you like a man the way he is, then allow him to take you out. Chances are good that he's not perfect, but you're not either. That's okay though because if he's a caring person towards you and others, that he means well, and he has given his life to Christ, that should be enough. And if you do want to be with him, you HAVE to allow him to lead. As a ballroom dancer, it's vital that the lead leads. Otherwise, the routine won't work. This also symbolizes and honors what Christ does for His people: He leads and we follow. Remember that.
And circling back to the beginning point, no I don't want a man that strives to do good; I want a man who succeeds in doing good the vast majority of the time. And I want to be a woman who does good not who just tries hard and still keeps failing. Women give points for trying, but don't expect them to act as though trying to quit a habitual sin is of the same value as having overcome it. While there are some women who have really high standards that they don't meet themselves, seems like there are also a lot of guys who think their failures are a much smaller deal than women do and that their efforts and wanting deserve to be rewarded with a woman no matter how terrible of a partner they would make. And I've also known some good Christian men, who due to personality and lifestyle preferences would make terrible partners for me. Being a caring person who means well really isn't enough for a long term decision; it might be enough for a first date, but it might also be kind and caring to turn down a first date if you can't see any substance behind the caring who means well. After all, they meant well is usually what we say when someone unintentionally does harm; not when someone does something that benefits others.


All this, though is where we get into trouble as Christians and trying to have people believing in the truth. Many of us who proclaim ourselves as followers in Christ come off as arrogant, condescending, and extremely judgmental. Many of those same Christians don't take the time to sit and LISTEN to what's happening in a non-believer's life. Instead, we jump in so quickly to condemn them rather gather all the facts and information about these people. Being civil towards them seems like a task at times. Christ took it upon Himself to hear out what these people had to say. He gave truths, but was never harsh nor condescending towards these people. In place of that, He gave solutions, which led to real hope. That's how He was able to make friends out of them. So don't try to be perfect nor put on that persona that you are because you're not. But if people see that you're just as vulnerable as everyone else, while standing strong in your faith, people will come to you. Even though we're not entirely good, there's nothing wrong with trying to do good.
It's not just toward non-believers. I think often Christians are even more harsh with each other because believers who are sinning 1) should know better and 2) should have the power to overcome temptation if they're really saved . But I can agree that Christians are often arrogant and judgemental and all too often quick to blame the victim for the problems they face (don't have enough faith, don't love/ trust God enough, etc trust me stick around churches long enough and you will hear these things). But since Jesus was perfect, I don't think trying to be perfect is the problem, it's just pretending you're perfect when you aren't that is the problem. Such hypocrisy is a problem that Jesus was just as against as most modern unbelievers are.
 

tourist

Senior Member
Mar 13, 2014
42,665
17,120
113
69
Tennessee
#12
Hey Cinder,

Thank you for taking the time to write out most of the questions I wish would be asked EVERY time we get a thread about how absolutely evil it is to date an unbeliever.

Now please don't misunderstand. I am in no way, shape, or form trying to argue with the Bible's wisdom that teaches us to avoid being unequally yoked.

But after growing up in the church community, this is the list of questions I wish would be asked OF BELIEVERS every single time the topic of "not being unequally yoked" comes up.

If someone prays to a heathen deity, regularly consults tarot cards for guidance, and talks to spirits through ouija boards, it's pretty much a no-brainer that this person would be an unequal yoking for a Christian.

But no one ever talks about the many, many ways in which Christians are unequally yoked with other Christians, and if we get down to the nitty gritty of what it means to be "equally yoked," how many of us will actually find someone to marry?

* If Sister Sally thinks A Good Christian goes to church once a week and Woeful William thinks every Good Christian worth their salt goes to church at least 3 times a week (and don't forget Bible class,) how equally yoked are they? Which church will they join? Will William start going to church less, or will Sally start going to church more? How many times a week will their kids be expected to go in order to grow up to be Good Christians?

* If Saintly Sarah believes in tithing 10% of her money to the church, and Believing Bill says that's an Old Testament law that he is no longer under, what will they both have to compromise in order to agree on how to manage their money?

* If Faithful Frances believes a good Christian must have read or know at least 50% of the Bible and Newcomer Norm just became a Christian a year ago and is just starting to learn it, how will Frances encourage Norm instead of looking down at him for what she perceives as his lack of knowledge?

I very rarely, if ever, see these types of questions addressed. Rather, we as single believers are just told to go out and find another believer to marry, as if that's as easy as picking out a bag of chips at the grocery store and tossing it into our cart, because apparently that's the "magic formula" that makes everything work out.

And yet no one mentions the realities of differences such as these, let alone how to deal with them, because these differences will come up and will make or break the relationship.

But no one gives us any guidance on how to deal with these differences, and in the meantime, we wonder why so many couples wind up divorcing. :rolleyes:
If I was a single guy and romantically inclined I would be trending towards Sister Sally. Unequally yoked is one thing, being incompatible is something else altogether. Rather than strictly finding another believer I would rather marry someone that I get along with and enjoy being with. You have raised a valid point.
 

tourist

Senior Member
Mar 13, 2014
42,665
17,120
113
69
Tennessee
#13
what

about

the

bad

christians.

and why the obsession with marriage? Just because some weddings happen in churches doesnt mean everyone who marries in them is a believer. Also, you dont need to marry in a church. You could marry in a barn or hotel or a parking lot or the courthouse.

its not about how good or bad a christian you are. Marriage is more about how faithful you are to each other. How many people marry, then decide oh this person bores me now so I'll just go off and find someone else, and becomes UNFAITHFUL. And they could have believed in God, or the tooth fairy or that people evolved from rocks!
Have you considered Newcomer Norm? He was bad but now is trying to be good.
 

tourist

Senior Member
Mar 13, 2014
42,665
17,120
113
69
Tennessee
#14
But... after we are married, after I "got her," I'm not sure how much longer I could keep up the act. And if she was putting on an act to get me, I'm not sure how long she would be willing to keep it up after we were married.
Profound perception.
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,188
113
#16
Have you considered Newcomer Norm? He was bad but now is trying to be good.
uh what do you mean

this forum has new people join all the time
People are coming to faith ALL the time from all different backgrounds all over the world.

its not really for us to keep on judging others when we kinda need to be pulling the mote out of our own eyes.
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,188
113
#17
what is that proverb again

Every man proclaims his own goodness but a faithful man, who can find?
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,188
113
#18
It is Proverbs 20:6
 

G00WZ

Senior Member
May 16, 2014
1,318
453
83
38
#19
What is good depends on the person who is holding the standards of what is good to them personally. For example what is good for me might not be good for the next man. There is no default answer for what is good for everyone collectively. As for me personally how well a person can quote scripture or how much time and money they spend on a church isn't impressive to me but it might be something that someone else thinks looks for and defines in a person as "good".
 
Aug 28, 2020
79
24
8
#20
Often such thinking becomes an excuse for lack of progress in sanctification. Or as a song from when I was a teen put it " You may say its only natural for me to act this way, I know it's only natural but I have not been made only natural. .... I've got the spirit of the living God alive in me giving me power so I don't have to be only natural." More recently the slogan that embodied this for me, though it was in a different context is " progress not perfection".



But we don't all have the same parents raising us and Christians don't agree on what the most proper course of action is. Let's dig into just a couple of the questions that you didn't bother to answer as examples: Restuarants - should you ask the waitress for prayer requests? Should your faith influence how much you tip? Should you pray before your meal? How should a Christian respond when the service isn't that great? These are rubber meets the road type questions that help people who care to live out their faith.


Other practical concerns and areas of conflict, how much planning can you do and still live by faith? What decisions should you pray about together and what can you be trusted to decide on your own without consciously checking in with God? When the call comes to give for an emergency crisis, should you give everything in the bank and trust God to provide money to pay your bills or should you set some rational limits to what you are willing to give? How long and hard to you pray before you accept that it's God saying no and not a lack of faith on your part? Is demanding a certain level of intellectual rigor in discerning the voice of God wise or legalistic? And those are just questions that have come up in my own walk and interactions with other Christians.



And circling back to the beginning point, no I don't want a man that strives to do good; I want a man who succeeds in doing good the vast majority of the time. And I want to be a woman who does good not who just tries hard and still keeps failing. Women give points for trying, but don't expect them to act as though trying to quit a habitual sin is of the same value as having overcome it. While there are some women who have really high standards that they don't meet themselves, seems like there are also a lot of guys who think their failures are a much smaller deal than women do and that their efforts and wanting deserve to be rewarded with a woman no matter how terrible of a partner they would make. And I've also known some good Christian men, who due to personality and lifestyle preferences would make terrible partners for me. Being a caring person who means well really isn't enough for a long term decision; it might be enough for a first date, but it might also be kind and caring to turn down a first date if you can't see any substance behind the caring who means well. After all, they meant well is usually what we say when someone unintentionally does harm; not when someone does something that benefits others.




It's not just toward non-believers. I think often Christians are even more harsh with each other because believers who are sinning 1) should know better and 2) should have the power to overcome temptation if they're really saved . But I can agree that Christians are often arrogant and judgemental and all too often quick to blame the victim for the problems they face (don't have enough faith, don't love/ trust God enough, etc trust me stick around churches long enough and you will hear these things). But since Jesus was perfect, I don't think trying to be perfect is the problem, it's just pretending you're perfect when you aren't that is the problem. Such hypocrisy is a problem that Jesus was just as against as most modern unbelievers are.
So putting me down because you didn't get the answer you want rather than the answer that needed to be said. And things I said, it sounds to me you're intentionally twisting what I was saying, like strive to good. You know exactly what I meant, so don't pretend like you needed to correct me. You can already do good and still strive for more of it.

And since we're on this subject, let's talk about what is good in the dating realm. What do you define as good? Is it helping the poor? Is it earning a lot of money and giving it to charity? Is it doing unto others as you do to yourself? Is it helping people with physical/mental disadvantages? Does it line up with what God has outlined for us?

Let's look at this from a single man's perspective. Many women talk about good men in doing good, and these same females saying that's what they want when getting into a relationship. However, after they say it, they go after men who are the EXACT OPPOSITE of what they said. In other words, these type of women are all talk, and it makes me question if they were truly Christians to begin with.

I've seen women who would, either online or in person, quote scripture, be nice to everyone, and talk about how they want a good guy. Then, out of the blue, they're dating non-believers who were charming enough to rope them in. These women, man, do they ever LOVE these type of guys. They know that these guys are non-believers and they know they don't perform acts of good, but they stay with them anyway. They even go as far as making excuses for them. Breakups are rough for these women because, in their minds, these men were perfect for them, and when they do date other guys they compare them to the "perfect" one before.

A pastor's daughter, who I know, dated an atheist. They were together for quite some time, too. They went a lot, did fun activities together, and did the things that neither one even considered doing. The guy was tall, made good money, and good looking. However, there were all sorts of red flags about this man when they first met, but she stayed with him. Eventually, though, they did call it off because of beliefs. I don't know if I buy that reason because she knew that this guy was an atheist and continued seeing him. Something tells me the family stepped in, more than likely her father, and explained how this was not a good idea, based on not just what this man believed, but also his actions. The family were probably, also concerned that she was being led astray. This is very likely because I went through something similar (which I'll get into here in a bit). Since then, she's had other men, who WERE believers, but turned down each one. She says she's looking for a godly man, but it seems like she prefers men that are not.

Now, the flip side, from a single woman's perspective. Let's say they ARE looking for good men and live by their word through their own actions. There are men who say that they want good women, especially if they gave their lives to Christ. However, us men tend to get ahead of ourselves and try to fix the women we want to be a part of lives, rather than the ones that have been saved. It comes out of a place of pride and ignorance because we are wired to solve problems. But what we fail to realize is some things we simply will not fix, despite our best efforts.

I dated a woman last year who was not a Christian. In my mind, at the time, we grew up together through middle school, our families knew each other, and we were about the same age, so I thought we can make this work. However, I ignored the red flags. This woman had a mental episode after her brother's death, been engaged multiple times, a broken family, serious financial issues that she was not resolving on her own, and she's a heavy drinker. She also had baggage of being molested by one of her family members and abused by an ex fiance. Yeah, I thought I had my work cut out for me, but after the last time I was with her, I believed, at the time, I got through to her. Unfortunately, she called it quits out of nowhere. I didn't understand it at the time, but I'm beginning to believe more that I wasn't like her ex, who was charming, had a decent reputation for the line work he was in, and almost was married to him. You could say I didn't live up to what this man meant to her, even though I was told he was the ex that abused her. Either way, this woman's way of thinking I couldn't fix and I learned to accept it. And what happened to me was I missed church, missed out on hanging out with my friends, and it affected my work. I was a fool in going out with this woman and doubly one who though I could save her.

Was it good for us to go out with people who don't believe to have some sort of romantic love together? Hearts were in the right place, caring about someone's salvation and loving that person because it's a command to love one and other, but if they're showing no signs of wanting it, then it probably wasn't right to begin with. You could even say it isn't right. We said we wanted godly people to be in a relationship with, but instead, we turned out to be hypocrites. So speaking through experience, we need to be much more true to our word when we say things like this. Let our 'yes' be yes and our 'no' be no. Honestly, if I get back out in the dating market, I don't know who'd I go out with. I know what's good and what I'm looking for in a woman, but my greatest fear is that I will screw up again and choose unwisely. That's why I'm remaining single. But whenever I see a woman that I find interesting say they want a good man, they, typically, end up with the opposite. I see other men do the same thing. Besides, the Apostle Paul said it would be better, in many cases, to stay single and focus on God. For others, it would be better to be with someone, but problems usually arise from that, so they have to make sure God is at the center. I just hate seeing good people seeing good people, men and women, set themselves up for failure, and that's what I'm ultimately getting at.