Ink is a difficult subject. Apologies if this is rather long. I had expected to be rather short but due to a BDF thread I seem to just want to drone.
I appreciate the artistry of tattoos and once had an idea for a scripture on my wrist as a continual reminder. Then again, phylacteries in the OT could be removed and the Lord didn't ask for what "is written" to be carved on one's flesh. So while practical seemingly, it might represent a narrowing that is counterproductive. Like having a life verse or something. Line upon line... not one verse or word grouping having preeminence over others in such a fashion.
I'm not saying that people that feel this strongly are wrong if they hold such a verse to be so. Consider epitaphs...but I think it wise to discipline myself against that generally speaking though a small collection of verses are firmly fixed within me as promises.
That said. I haven't ever felt an overwhelming desire for tattoos. Thinking back...my father was
very against even fake tattoos (the lick and peel ones) and when we came to his house we had to scrub them off. This sort of put even henna out of mind for a LONG time. I don't even recall noticing them until my 20s except I probably did.
It's curious but I also don't ever recall seeing mushrooms until partway through my 20s. I knew they were real but I just didn't "see" them if that makes sense. Tattoos I vaguely recall seeing but not much. I legit have no memories of mushrooms at all.
Then I began to notice ink and seeing the person behind it and learning to appreciate the art of it. I applied this to non-believers though and it wasn't until I saw someone within the International house of prayer movement that I considered to be very close to the Lord as far as fervency and sweetness of spirit have one (that I noticed on a rafting trip) that I just was a bit baffled.
I thought of tattooing my animals that died as a memorial when I was 23 or so. Bessie 2012-2015 as you have to have a cow named bessie surely? Of course, that was just an vain imagination as I have no animals and although I someday want to farm, the idea has no real hold on me for a tattoo in their memory. Stuffing them perhaps as I see no moral quandary there.
There was just a thread on BDF about the verse in Deut about cross dressing and this falls in the same category. Some say it doesn't apply under grace and while the Lord obviously took the time to say it and expected people to follow it, ah we are free from all that "trifling" fun-ruining works righteousness stuff. Still others that we are still under the full weight of the law...like Jesus saved us from that and picked it up for a second just to let us know that and then slammed the yoke back down and said "Just do your best".
Personally I think it's a blend between the two. There is a heart behind the law and there is a reason why it is written. Much like saying not to cross dress it says not to get tattoos.
I can't personally say if it applies or not in the sense that it's a salvation issue. I rather doubt it as these are surface things...but they hearken unto potentially quite deep issues in our walk with the Lord. Do they always? Not necessarily. Some things are just more visible than others.
A smoker or someone heavily tattooed is easily seen as having their flesh manifest. A gossiper or someone who is covetous not as much. Pride can be one of the deepest (if not the) roots of sin and is invisible to some, especially if masked in humility (sometimes unintentional).
In any case, it is easy to call something sin that a person has no particular inclination or desire to do and that is clearly commanded against in scripture. I myself have very little inclination to ever get a tattoo because I like me. At the same time someone with this overwhelming attraction to tattoos (like smoking) may use whatever rationale suits them and once it is done, may feel little compunction/conviction about it afterward. Were they right? It wouldn't be for me.
This is most likely one of those "work out your own salvation" issues but don't forget the second part of that verse "with fear and
trembling".
I haven't ever parsed a verse like that before but I have heard pastors do that a bit and I think it works here.
I am disinclined to encourage anyone to get one and if I'm ever a pastor I'll probably have more insight if I were to shepherd other people with this issue. I think it's sin, but we all sin and I'm not judging anyone for it but I'll do my best to steer them away from it when the time arises.
In the past year or so a super serious attempt at that occurred with someone close to me but they were dead set. I was so against it for them that I had to check my motives and heart. Am I being pharisaical about this? Why do they even want one so badly? They felt led to do so and I questioned this but based on this I eventually ended up privately pursuing this. I used the channels I could and even my own parental figures said casually recently that they might get some tattoos. I couldn't really tell if they were serious but it was a bit bizarre so I didn't comment.
I have strong views on ink for believers but since some of these might be rooted in my flesh based on the anger I'm not sure if they are of God exactly.
Long I realize but I felt like I couldn't really leave much out. It's a strange issue for me as it brings up the law and the serious confusion within the church about that which in turn confuses me. So again, work out your own salvation
If someone does want to discuss it because it is causing a crisis of conscience feel free to reach out. I understand in my own way how it feels when you have one over a seemingly tiny thing that no one you meet really thinks important at all. I don't understand tattoos but I do understand private burdens that "seemingly" no one else has.