On the strange end of the spectrum:
2. Black powder. Think muskets (although a lot of black powder stuff is rifled, and a percussion mechanism is not cheating if you don't want to have to knap your flint all the time).
...They always come across as way too strong (seriously, sniff a woman's perfume, and then sniff some gasoline, the perfume is stronger). Cloying, overbearing, and lingering are three adjectives I'd use for most of the scents people douse themselves with. And most people have no idea what a proper application is.
It should be like walking through a fine mist. Do not apply directly to the skin or clothing, or you'll smell like a chemical plant. And just a small mist too. I've seen way too many guys (and women) who stand there emptying the bottle like a firing squad dispatching a target.