Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Why would a parent have children knowing they would disobey?
Are you erroneously assuming that all are God's children? And why do you keep pretending that making
choices amounts to having a will that is free when volition around mundane events is not the topic, but
the fact that man's will is enslaved to sin, as Scripture plainly teaches, until set free by Jesus? Are you
incapable of staying on topic, or do you really just not know what it is by now?
Please remove your gobbledygook speaking CDS beard to reply, thanks.
 
These heretics have the person choosing to believe with his incurably wicked heart what he cannot even understand.

And they think they are being logical, with this bad tree bringing forth the good fruit of faith, when Jesus said it was impossible.

Any interpretation that goes against the plain and clear teaching on the words of our Lord cannot be correct.

simplyprofound.gif

It is God Who works in you to will and to act on behalf of His good purpose. Apart from Me you can do nothing. No word from God will ever fail. “It is easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God.” Those who heard this asked, “Who then can be saved?” But Jesus said, “What is impossible with man is possible with God.”
While this may not have been your intention, the image of this necklace on this woman is designed with occult-style symbolism. The central blue turquoise stone represents the spiritual core, often associated in occult systems with inner vision, intuition, and psychic receptivity, since blue symbolizes spiritual insight and the element of water. Placed at the center of the chest, it functions as a “heart-of-power,” similar to a displaced third eye or a magical center that signifies hidden wisdom or mystical authority. The seven surrounding stones reflect the common occult use of the number seven, tied to chakras, celestial powers, and esoteric “completion.” The gold branching filigree beneath the main stone resembles a stylized Tree-of-Life or sigil pattern, symbolizing the flow of spiritual energy, while the overall downward-pointing triangle shape reinforces feminine mystical themes and receptivity. The purple backdrop and floral elements further reinforce a New Age or enchanted-priestess aesthetic. Together, the shapes, colors, and arrangement imitate a magical talisman that embodies intuition, spiritual power, and mystical energy according to occult design language.


Sources:

1. Blue/Turquoise stones meaning intuition, spiritual insight, and communication
Rock Paradise: “Blue Crystals and Gemstones – Names, Meanings, and Healing Properties.”
https://rockparadise.com/blogs/news...mstones-names-meanings-and-healing-properties

2. Blue stones associated with wisdom, insight, and mental clarity
Emmanuelle Guyon: “Symbolism of Stone Colors – Blue Stones.”
https://www.en.emmanuelleguyon.com/vertus1_en.php

3. Turquoise associated with protection and spiritual connection
GemSelect: “Top Ten Most Spiritually Powerful Blue Gemstones.”
https://www.gemselect.com/other-info/powerful-blue-gemstones.php

4. Downward-pointing triangle symbolizing feminine energy, water, and receptivity
Cassie Uhl: “Magical Meanings & Uses for Triangles & Pyramids.”
https://www.cassieuhl.com/blog/magical-meanings-uses-for-triangles-pyramids

5. Downward triangle as a symbol of the divine feminine
Atlas of Soul: “Divine Feminine Symbols.”
https://atlasofsoul.com/blogs/feminine-archetypes/divine-feminine-symbols

6. Number seven associated with chakras, spiritual completion, and esoteric mysticism
Esoteric Meanings: “Mystical Number Seven.”
https://www.esotericmeanings.com/mystical-number-seven

7. Number seven as mystical in occult sciences and ancient esoteric systems
Palash T. Thakur: “The Significance of the Number 7 in History, Chaldean Numerology and Occult Sciences.”
https://palashthhakur.com/the-significance-of-the-number-7-in-history-chaldean-numerology-and-occult-sciences

8. Chakra colors linking blue to communication, expression, and inner clarity
Chakra Anatomy: “Throat Chakra Meaning.”
https://www.chakra-anatomy.com/throat-chakra.html





……
 
While this may not have been your intention, the image of this necklace on this woman is designed with occult-style symbolism. The central blue turquoise stone represents the spiritual core, often associated in occult systems with inner vision, intuition, and psychic receptivity, since blue symbolizes spiritual insight and the element of water. Placed at the center of the chest, it functions as a “heart-of-power,” similar to a displaced third eye or a magical center that signifies hidden wisdom or mystical authority. The seven surrounding stones reflect the common occult use of the number seven, tied to chakras, celestial powers, and esoteric “completion.” The gold branching filigree beneath the main stone resembles a stylized Tree-of-Life or sigil pattern, symbolizing the flow of spiritual energy, while the overall downward-pointing triangle shape reinforces feminine mystical themes and receptivity. The purple backdrop and floral elements further reinforce a New Age or enchanted-priestess aesthetic. Together, the shapes, colors, and arrangement imitate a magical talisman that embodies intuition, spiritual power, and mystical energy according to occult design language.


Sources:

1. Blue/Turquoise stones meaning intuition, spiritual insight, and communication
Rock Paradise: “Blue Crystals and Gemstones – Names, Meanings, and Healing Properties.”
https://rockparadise.com/blogs/news...mstones-names-meanings-and-healing-properties

2. Blue stones associated with wisdom, insight, and mental clarity
Emmanuelle Guyon: “Symbolism of Stone Colors – Blue Stones.”
https://www.en.emmanuelleguyon.com/vertus1_en.php

3. Turquoise associated with protection and spiritual connection
GemSelect: “Top Ten Most Spiritually Powerful Blue Gemstones.”
https://www.gemselect.com/other-info/powerful-blue-gemstones.php

4. Downward-pointing triangle symbolizing feminine energy, water, and receptivity
Cassie Uhl: “Magical Meanings & Uses for Triangles & Pyramids.”
https://www.cassieuhl.com/blog/magical-meanings-uses-for-triangles-pyramids

5. Downward triangle as a symbol of the divine feminine
Atlas of Soul: “Divine Feminine Symbols.”
https://atlasofsoul.com/blogs/feminine-archetypes/divine-feminine-symbols

6. Number seven associated with chakras, spiritual completion, and esoteric mysticism
Esoteric Meanings: “Mystical Number Seven.”
https://www.esotericmeanings.com/mystical-number-seven

7. Number seven as mystical in occult sciences and ancient esoteric systems
Palash T. Thakur: “The Significance of the Number 7 in History, Chaldean Numerology and Occult Sciences.”
https://palashthhakur.com/the-significance-of-the-number-7-in-history-chaldean-numerology-and-occult-sciences

8. Chakra colors linking blue to communication, expression, and inner clarity
Chakra Anatomy: “Throat Chakra Meaning.”
https://www.chakra-anatomy.com/throat-chakra.html
Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar. The sky is blue. Oh no! It is occultic. .:censored:
 
  • Like
Reactions: OLDBUTNEW
These heretics have the person choosing to believe with his incurably wicked heart what he cannot even understand.

And they think they are being logical, with this bad tree bringing forth the good fruit of faith, when Jesus said it was impossible.

Any interpretation that goes against the plain and clear teaching on the words of our Lord cannot be correct.

simplyprofound.gif

It is God Who works in you to will and to act on behalf of His good purpose. Apart from Me you can do nothing. No word from God will ever fail. “It is easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God.” Those who heard this asked, “Who then can be saved?” But Jesus said, “What is impossible with man is possible with God.”
I loved that tree, I really did

I had a tree that lost the will to live,

In my will I stood desperately week after week, for months as I cut away branches where the leaves where drying out, I was young all knowing but daft in doing things my way.

Sime days I stood there holding its branches in prayer and hope,

Longing for the tree to bounce back.

All the hope I had was not enough and I lost that tree,

I stood there wondering many days why his neighbouring tree I planted was still alive, and still alive to this day, some 3 years later to. Because I had only pruned it's branches at start of spring

It was then I realised perhaps I did something wrong, I had,

I had to

I had pruned it's branches at the end of summer and it got diseased.

I was the bad gardener who pruned wrongly, and the poor tree died, it was a very special tree, every year it would produce beautiful leaves, and I never stopped to think I should have I should have seeked advice on how to care for it

In the end I learned how to prune and how to grow this rare tree an evergreen California I planted a new seed . and I planted a new seed and now it's flourishing 😂
 
  • Like
Reactions: OLDBUTNEW
Inability cannot exist if the Jews were resisting the Holy Spirit who is God (Please read Acts 7 again).,,,,

Of course it can. They didn't have the ability to cooperate and submit to the Holy Spirit. So...they did the only thing that any self-respecting unbeliever would do: Resist and disobey God's Word. They don't God's power or Spirit to do that. It comes as natural to them as breathing air is to all of us.
 
DOUBLESPEAK! God "enables and enlightens" with weak, impotent ineffectual grace. :rolleyes:

What if you are wrong and I am correct? After all, many of you here do give many non-answers to Scripture, we propose that you ignore or have no real good explanation for. Imagine if Prevenient Grace is how God actually operates. Would you still say this of God if that is how He actually operates? This is why I fear for you. From my perspective, you are attacking the goodness of God, and you fail to see the moral problem in your belief system.



.....
 
Of course it can. They didn't have the ability to cooperate and submit to the Holy Spirit. So...they did the only thing that any self-respecting unbeliever would do: Resist and disobey God's Word. They don't God's power or Spirit to do that. It comes as natural to them as breathing air is to all of us.
Somehow this salient fact flies over their head, while they invest much energy into teaching us about occult symbolism.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OLDBUTNEW
What if you are wrong and I am correct? After all, many of you here do give many non-answers to Scripture, we propose that you ignore or have no real good explanation for. Imagine if Prevenient Grace is how God actually operates. Would you still say this of God if that is how He actually operates? This is why I fear for you. From my perspective, you are attacking the goodness of God, and you fail to see the moral problem in your belief system.
The problem is you have the man Scripture says cannot receive or understand the Spiritual things of God
receiving and understanding them, but somehow this very understanding escapes your intellectual notice.
 
Again, you have to redefine what uncircumcised heart and ears means in light of the context. I see circumcision of the heart in the Old Testament as one being born again. In the NT, being born again happens AFTER one already has faith (which takes place under God's enlightenment, drawing, and conviction, etcetera). Calvinists see being born again as happening before one has faith. So naturally you must ignore the part about how these Jews resisting the Holy Spirit. Again, this scenario makes no sense in the Calvinistic worldview. This is just something you will have to deal with someday.
....

FALSE! God granted the promised grace of the Fear of the Lord, that was promised to only God's covenant people, to Cornelius BEFORE Cornelius was saved! God does the same thing with the gracious promise of a circumcised heart.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OLDBUTNEW
FALSE! God granted the promised grace of the Fear of the Lord, that was promised to only God's covenant people, to Cornelius BEFORE Cornelius was saved! God does the same thing with the gracious promise of a circumcised heart.
Cornelius wasn't saved until Peter preached the Gospel to him and his family.
 
FALSE! God granted the promised grace of the Fear of the Lord, that was promised to only God's covenant people, to
Cornelius BEFORE Cornelius was saved! God does the same thing with the gracious promise of a circumcised heart.
Psalm36-1-4.png

Psalm 36 verses 1-4 ~ An oracle is in my heart regarding the transgression of the wicked man: There is no fear of God before his eyes. For his eyes are too full of conceit to detect or hate his own sin. The words of his mouth are wicked and deceitful; he has ceased to be wise and well-doing. Even on his bed he plots wickedness; he sets himself on a path that is not good; he fails to reject evil.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OLDBUTNEW
I wonder if they freely chose out of their own free will to have sex and have kids. If not, then that means they got raped. But if the individual who they had sex with also had no free will, then he cannot be charged for that crime, nor any other crime.

Dear Blue1 ... this is the thing ..... a person can make all manner of choices ... but there is one thing that they can never do!!!

That would be to do what Jesus commands > believe in/trust in Him for salvation. Nope that is off limits!!

This god only wants his pre-selected and he had to make sure of it, so all people are born dead, dead, dead like programmed zombies.

Now these blind, unable to hear, black hearted, slaves to sin, held captive by Satan zombies are born hating god, probably the first words out of their young mouths are, "I hate god and I want to do evil 24/7."

Now you may be asking why ... well god creates and chooses the individuals for salvation according to his own good pleasure .... what I find weird is we are told to "love our enemies" but the god of Calvinism does not, so Christians have a higher moral duty than god.... hmm?
 
Reciprocal love is neither possible nor necessary in the Calvinist soteriology.

Why in the world would God bother with calling, wooing and pleading? For the Calvinist, the brutal shillelagh of stone-cold sovereignty is the preferred medicine.

Then comes the forced impregnations, lobotomies, kidnappings and shotgun weddings....🥲

You still wear your ignorance proudly and without shame, don't you? God loves only those who reciprocate His love! (You keep forgetting that God's love is conditional!) And why isn't reciprocal love possible since God sheds His own love abroad in His people's hearts? PLUS...the major spiritual benefit to heart circumcision is that it enables God's people to love Him and his Son!
 
Are you erroneously assuming that all are God's children? And why do you keep pretending that making
choices amounts to having a will that is free when volition around mundane events is not the topic, but
the fact that man's will is enslaved to sin, as Scripture plainly teaches, until set free by Jesus? Are you
incapable of staying on topic, or do you really just not know what it is by now?
Please remove your gobbledygook speaking CDS beard to reply, thanks.

You crack me up, sister!!
 
These heretics have the person choosing to believe with his incurably wicked heart what he cannot even understand.

And they think they are being logical, with this bad tree bringing forth the good fruit of faith, when Jesus said it was impossible.

Any interpretation that goes against the plain and clear teaching on the words of our Lord cannot be correct.

simplyprofound.gif

It is God Who works in you to will and to act on behalf of His good purpose. Apart from Me you can do nothing. No word from God will ever fail. “It is easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God.” Those who heard this asked, “Who then can be saved?” But Jesus said, “What is impossible with man is possible with God.”

Again, Modern Bibles are the new kids on the block (i.e., Westcott and Hort's ERV came out in 1881, and the Modern Bibles did not become popular until the 1980s with the NIV). Modern Bibles are based on entirely different Greek texts than the KJV, and there are textual differences that affect doctrine for the worse. You can check out these differences at www.affectionsabove.com. While Modern Bibles may be helpful at times in updating the uncommon words of the KJV on rare occasions, they are by no means reliable. The NIV falsely says that the heart is beyond cure. The CSB says the heart is incurable. None of the translators of the NIV or CSB is even close to the level of scholarship of the KJV translators. Just research it sometime, and you will see what I am talking about.



.....
 
Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar. The sky is blue. Oh no! It is occultic. .:censored:

Not when they are gemstones arranged in a certain way that imitates the activities of the occult. You may not see a problem with it, but the occult takes these things very seriously. The Bible says we are to avoid having any appearance of evil.





……
 
35 counts of calvinist bashing since I ask for Calvies to be blessed in Jesus name only yesterday from the people I asked
How can you Reason with such people ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: OLDBUTNEW
35 counts of calvinist bashing since I ask for Calvies to be blessed in Jesus name only yesterday from the people I asked
How can you Reason with such people ?
Is it by 35 different people or the same ones over and over?
 
Again, Modern Bibles are the new kids on the block (i.e., Westcott and Hort's ERV came out in 1881, and the Modern Bibles did not become popular until the 1980s with the NIV). Modern Bibles are based on entirely different Greek texts than the KJV, and there are textual differences that affect doctrine for the worse. You can check out these differences at www.affectionsabove.com. While Modern Bibles may be helpful at times in updating the uncommon words of the KJV on rare occasions, they are by no means reliable. The NIV falsely says that the heart is beyond cure. The CSB says the heart is incurable. None of the translators of the NIV or CSB is even close to the level of scholarship of the KJV translators. Just research it sometime, and you will see what I am talking about..
As it is written, There is none righteous, no, not one. God looked down from heaven upon the children of men, to see if there were any that did understand, that did seek God. Every one of them is gone back: they are altogether become filthy; there is none that doeth good, no, not one. The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it? The fool hath said in his heart, There is no God. They are corrupt, they have done abominable works, there is none that doeth good. A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit, neither can a corrupt tree bring forth good fruit.

Who can bring a clean thing out of an unclean? not one.

from-Rom7-18Gal5-17Isa64-6-Job-14-4Mark10-18Matt7-18Luke18-27.png

I know that nothing good lives in my flesh... For the flesh craves what is contrary to the Spirit, and the Spirit what is contrary to the flesh. Each of us has become like something unclean, and our iniquities carry us away like the wind. Who can bring a clean thing out of an unclean? Not one. No one is good except God alone. A bad tree cannot bear good fruit. “What is impossible with man is possible with God.” from: Romans 7 v 18, Galatians 5 v 17, Isaiah 64 v 6, Job 14 v 4, Mark 10 v 18, Matthew 7 v 18, Luke 18 v 27
 
  • Like
Reactions: OLDBUTNEW