Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Truth is a person named Jesus Christ (John 14:6).
Truth is also the Holy Scriptures (John 17:17).

If a person want to know they abide in the truth (Christ, and His Word), they can have an assurance of this if they find they are keeping His commandments (See: 1 John 2:3). Note: This is not the ceremonial laws of the Mosaic Law like the Saturday Sabbath, circumcision, animal sacrifices, dietary laws. Instead, believers are to follow the moral laws (like do not steal, do not murder, do not covet, etc.). They are to follow the law of Christ, etcetera.

But the person who says they know the Lord and yet they do not keep His commands, they are a liar and the truth (JESUS, & His Word) is not in them.

1 John 5:12 says that he that has the Son has life, and he that does not have the Son does not have life.



So you appeal to a sinful song with affectionate terms as a part of a holier than thou diatribe.
interesting you should mention do not do not covet m

Which means am obsessive longing to have something that's not yours.

Which is what you doing m, you keep having things your own way m
 
OK: So how does this sound: Do we all have Free Will to believe and trust in JESUS, and then, if we do trust in HIM, then HE will, through HIS GRACE, give us SALVATION?

Have I got this right, or do I need to go back to school?!

Please set me straight!

Arminians believe that God calls people at certain points in time in enabling a person's will to be able to freely choose. This is called Prevenient Grace, and others in the Arminian camp may define it a little differently. This means one cannot just freely choose God of their own according without God's conviction of their sin, without God's drawing, and without his opening their heart and eyes to see the truth. The Scriptures do say that the devil blinds people. But this is not a permanent state for all people. God loves people and He will come into their life and offer them the truth. Once that offer is made, it is up to them to decide or to exercise their free will under God's drawing.

Pelagians do not believe this and its all man's will and God's involvement is not really needed for them to see the truth or make a choice. I am against Pelagianism just as I am against regular Calvinism & Hyper Calvinism.



.....
 
interesting you should mention do not do not covet m

Which means am obsessive longing to have something that's not yours.

Which is what you doing m, you keep having things your own way m

Well, you can keep inventing those conspiracy theories if you like. But I see right through this tactic.
You sir are not dealing with the Scripture verses on this issue like 2 Thessalonians 2:10, and Jonah chapter 3.
Until then, you are just wasting everyone's time here.



....
 
  • Like
Reactions: OLDBUTNEW
Arminians believe that God calls people at certain points in time in enabling a person's will to be able to freely choose. This is called Prevenient Grace, and others in the Arminian camp may define it a little differently. This means one cannot just freely choose God of their own according without God's conviction of their sin, without God's drawing, and without his opening their heart and eyes to see the truth. The Scriptures do say that the devil blinds people. But this is not a permanent state for all people. God loves people and He will come into their life and offer them the truth. Once that offer is made, it is up to them to decide or to exercise their free will under God's drawing.

Pelagians do not believe this and its all man's will and God's involvement is not really needed for them to see the truth or make a choice. I am against Pelagianism just as I am against regular Calvinism & Hyper Calvinism.



.....

@Bible_Highlighter : Good answer, Bro! Thank you!
 
Arminians believe that God calls people at certain points in time in enabling a person's will to be able to freely choose. This is called Prevenient Grace, and others in the Arminian camp may define it a little differently. This means one cannot just freely choose God of their own according without God's conviction of their sin, without God's drawing, and without his opening their heart and eyes to see the truth. The Scriptures do say that the devil blinds people. But this is not a permanent state for all people. God loves people and He will come into their life and offer them the truth. Once that offer is made, it is up to them to decide or to exercise their free will under God's drawing.

Pelagians do not believe this and its all man's will and God's involvement is not really needed for them to see the truth or make a choice. I am against Pelagianism just as I am against regular Calvinism & Hyper Calvinism.
You do not seem to believe in free will at all. You are just confused about who comes to believes.

Although you also stated earlier that some do not have this choice at all, not having their
name written in the Book of life, so you contradict yourself, as those in error often do.
 
Well, you can keep inventing those conspiracy theories if you like. But I see right through this tactic.
You sir are not dealing with the Scripture verses on this issue like 2 Thessalonians 2:10, and Jonah chapter 3.
Until then, you are just wasting everyone's time here.



....
no you only cite scripture to promote condemnation in this thread anyway.

How about instead of looking for verses to not rely on your brother. and look for ones where credit was given to brothers and even sisters contributions to church and dont just think about money either.

Try searching romans and Paul the predestined Calvinist in your book,
He must be right if you don't believe being elected is true
 
@Bible_Highlighter : Good answer, Bro! Thank you!

Your welcome.
I just have a stronger distaste for Calvinism because it violates basic morality on several levels and I see how it affects the attitudes of others once they believe in it. While I am on friendly terms with two particular Calvinists who are KJV-only (because I hold to a similar position, i.e. Core-KJB), my general experience with Calvinists has not been so pleasant over the years.



....
 
no you only cite scripture to promote condemnation in this thread anyway.

How about instead of looking for verses to not rely on your brother. and look for ones where credit was given to brothers and even sisters contributions to church and dont just think about money either.

Try searching romans and Paul the predestined Calvinist in your book
He must be right if you don't believing being elected is true

It's the Calvinist who promote condemnation upon a good majority of men.
According to classic Calvinism: Only the Elect can be saved and the offer of salvation is limited to them.
People who are not Elect do not have a chance at salvation because they have not been elected by God.
God created them for the specific purpose to be damned as their fate and to be tortured for all eternity.
So in Calvinism, God creates a bunch of human life just to see it suffer.
If so, then saying "God is love" as Scripture proclaims would be an empty statement.


....
 
  • Like
Reactions: OLDBUTNEW
It's the Calvinist who promote condemnation upon a good majority of men.
According to classic Calvinism: Only the Elect can be saved and the offer of salvation is limited to them.
People who are not Elect do not have a chance at salvation because they have not been elected by God.
God created them for the specific purpose to be damned as their fate and to be tortured for all eternity.
So in Calvinism, God creates a bunch of human life just to see it suffer.
If so, then saying "God is love" as Scripture proclaims would be an empty statement.


....
yeah yeah your now the imaginary Arminian
 
That is such a lovely and true comment friend, Col 1:21-23 now has deep roots in me too. I'm still a pretty new believer, don't hesitate to post more scripture recommendations for me.

Okay, if I have not already posted these, I see

Matthew 5:17, the purpose of Jesus coming to rearth in the flesh first, to fulfill the Law for us all. Then, did that, then at the cross, yelled John 19:30, it is finished. Was his Matthew 5:17 completed? Per the disciples in 2 Cor 5:16-20 it was and is forever done by Son for us all.
Now I placed verse 16 there to see, truth "We once knew him in the flesh, today no more". Therefore it can only be of God Father's spirit and Truth, not of any flesh and blood works or can it? I see through out the First Testament not one could or did, not perfect ever.
New life in God Father's Spirit and Truth (John 4:23-24) cannot be of any person in of flesh and blood, but Jesus's, therefore be willing to be dead presently daily to God above everything else of this earth? Only Daddy, Father, PaPa knows who can or will, love it, thank you Father.
New life is offered in the risen Son, the death had to get done first willingly to be credited to all people, to get new life from day one anyone believes God as in Eph 1:13 states to me anyways. To see God has accepted and forgiven us all by Son it is done. Eph 1:6-7 it is done for each that choose belief to God personally to be new in God's Spirit and Truth, willingly daily be dead to self and all sin after them, learn to say no and stand in it, over time in not giving up, these learn to take no credit to self ever, at least learn to over time in growing up (Hebrews 5:12-Hebrews 6:3). Not of any flesh work to do, (Yet seems as one does have to) to see it is done for you too. This Love deeply resonates in you too, from God for you too as is for us all, otherwise, what Jesus did, is not of any value as per 1 Cor 15 tells me.
He is risen where new life is at for us all to be new in God's Spirit and Truth, dead to first birth willingly, thank you Father and Son as Won (One) for us all, otherwise no chance for me at least, as I can only truthfully speak for me, and hope for everyone else to choose God over it all and learn new in love and mercy given them too.
 
Well, you can keep inventing those conspiracy theories if you like. But I see right through this tactic.
You sir are not dealing with the Scripture verses on this issue like 2 Thessalonians 2:10, and Jonah chapter 3.
Until then, you are just wasting everyone's time here.



....
aw yawns m you Keep bringing this verse up m

Theses are dark scriptures m that should be left to lord.

Thats How I see that verse.
 
You do not seem to believe in free will at all. You are just confused about who comes to believes.

Although you also stated earlier that some do not have this choice at all, not having their
name written in the Book of life, so you contradict yourself, as those in error often do.

@Magenta : So how are you, dearie?! Are you having a good day? How are things in good old Canada?
 
Here is one of the many problems with Calvinism. The issue is that if God eternally decreed all events, all actions, choices, wills, desires, thoughts, intentions, motives of mankind, then that would also mean that He eternally decreed the fall, which would mean He eternally decreed Adam to sin. But nobody, not even Calvinists, would say that God was pleased with the fall. And I would agree with them on that. He was not pleased with the fall. But if He eternally decreed it (if He eternally decreed all events), because He eternally decrees, according to Calvinism, every man's actions, thoughts, desires, wills, motives and determinations, you name it, then how would that not be Him not being pleased with His own eternal decree? Not only that, but it would also mean that God, (taking Calvinism consistently) has eternally decreed Himself not to be pleased with His own eternal decrees.

Now, if Calvinists say yes, and God has eternally decreed the fall, then logically, according to Calvinism, taking it consistently, they would have to say that God would then be displeased with His own eternal decree. If they say no, He did not eternally decree the fall, then they are saying that Adam was able to do something that God did not eternally decree Him to do. But yet they would still say that God is still all-sovereign and powerful. So either way they answer it, Calvinism falls.

@cv5 @OLDBUTNEW @sawdust @HeIsHere @Bible_Highlighter
 
Here is one of the many problems with Calvinism. The issue is that if God eternally decreed all events, all actions, choices, wills, desires, thoughts, intentions, motives of mankind, then that would also mean that He eternally decreed the fall, which would mean He eternally decreed Adam to sin. But nobody, not even Calvinists, would say that God was pleased with the fall. And I would agree with them on that. He was not pleased with the fall. But if He eternally decreed it (if He eternally decreed all events), because He eternally decrees, according to Calvinism, every man's actions, thoughts, desires, wills, motives and determinations, you name it, then how would that not be Him not being pleased with His own eternal decree? Not only that, but it would also mean that God, (taking Calvinism consistently) has eternally decreed Himself not to be pleased with His own eternal decrees.

Now, if Calvinists say yes, and God has eternally decreed the fall, then logically, according to Calvinism, taking it consistently, they would have to say that God would then be displeased with His own eternal decree. If they say no, He did not eternally decree the fall, then they are saying that Adam was able to do something that God did not eternally decree Him to do. But yet they would still say that God is still all-sovereign and powerful. So either way they answer it, Calvinism falls.

@cv5 @OLDBUTNEW @sawdust @HeIsHere @Bible_Highlighter
I wouldn't recommend encouraging people to shoot the messengers m
 
  • Like
Reactions: OLDBUTNEW
Truth is a person named Jesus Christ (John 14:6).
Truth is also the Holy Scriptures (John 17:17).

If a person want to know they abide in the truth (Christ, and His Word), they can have an assurance of this if they find they are keeping His commandments (See: 1 John 2:3). Note: This is not the ceremonial laws of the Mosaic Law like the Saturday Sabbath, circumcision, animal sacrifices, dietary laws. Instead, believers are to follow the moral laws (like do not steal, do not murder, do not covet, etc.). They are to follow the law of Christ, etcetera.

But the person who says they know the Lord and yet they do not keep His commands, they are a liar and the truth (JESUS, & His Word) is not in them.

1 John 5:12 says that he that has the Son has life, and he that does not have the Son does not have life.



So you appeal to a sinful song with affectionate terms as a part of a holier than thou diatribe.
revealing sin is not a sin m

But in your imagination it is.

And when you and all the Calvinist bashers in this thread can apologise for your actions you may be forgiven.

But until then if you could just all answer the question why does The Calvin university teach obedience to the father if they think there already saved,

Then you may just all start to realise your sin

Be Careful how you answer now, because you may well shoot the messenger again
 
revealing sin is not a sin m

But in your imagination it is.

And when you and all the Calvinist bashers in this thread can apologise for your actions you may be forgiven.

But until then if you could just all answer the question why does The Calvin university teach obedience to the father if they think there already saved,

Then you may just all start to realise your sin

Be Careful how you answer now, because you may well shoot the messenger again

@Jordon : Bang, Bang!
 
Did Calvin write this and sneak it into the Bible when no one was looking?

Romans8-29-30-Ephesians1-5.png

Romans 8 verse 29-30; Ephesians 1 verse 5 ~ Those God foreknew, He also predestined to be conformed to the image of His Son, so that He would be the firstborn among many brothers. And those He predestined, He also called; those He called, He also justified; those He justified, He also glorified. He predestined us for adoption as His sons through Jesus Christ, according to the good pleasure of His will.

C'mon, sis, everyone on this planet knows that God [fore]knew who would believe and who would not. All he did was look into his cosmic crystal ball to learn that. :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: OLDBUTNEW