Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
I'm firm and stable in my Faith in Christ in Spirit. I can't tell you how many I've listened to and read by this point and the interactions I've had with some pastors and teachers and others who have approached and tried to influence me.

I do see this.... I was thinking just in case.
Reformed doctrine can be very seductive. :(
 
Has anyone ever taken you up on reviewing your statements and posted verses?

Not systematically (line by line), although Blain indicated that he agrees with all.
And during discussions I can distinguish those who probably tend to agree from the Tulipists and Actsers.
I would include you in the agreement camp, but do you want to discuss my proposal specifically?
(It is not set in stone; I added "love" most recently per someone's suggestion/feedback, for example.)
 
but do you want to discuss my proposal specifically?

Not at the moment. I'd want to focus on it and can't commit to do so right now.

I don't think it's surprising that you get a lot of disagreement but few willing or capable to get into the Scriptural details to systematically explain and prove why. I doubt you're surprised at this point either.
 
You wouldn't have heard of him. If you are truly interested in hearing him teach or preach, I'll tell you privately.
Sure. I'm sure you know how to use this system.
If you hover over the link under the moniker next to a post submitted by a user, a popup will appear ... there's a link "start conversation" ... that conversation takes place privately and does not appear in the open forum ...
.
 
If you hover over the link under the moniker next to a post submitted by a user, a popup will appear ... there's a link "start conversation" ... that conversation takes place privately and does not appear in the open forum ...
.
I did. It says I need to become a paid member to message privately.
 
This continual conflation is why this thread rages...

The truth is >>>>>> our complete inability to contribute to our eternal life is wholly separate from our inability to receive the free gift of eternal life by exercising personal faith.

Completely wrong and dishonest to mashup these two distinct ideas.

Yes, it is wrong to divorce our inability and divine enabling.
 
If you hover over the link under the moniker next to a post submitted by a user, a popup will appear ... there's a link "start conversation" ... that conversation takes place privately and does not appear in the open forum ...
.

Only available if you have paid for it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Komentaja
Time for @Cameron143 to change pastors IMO.
I have fled from many for many very good DOCTRINAL reasons.

And I have wandered from one to another for various reasons,
so now I could have membership in a few Baptist churches,
we belong to our most local church, which is conservative Methodist,
and my wife still attends our former Bible church.
 
Well, just share it publicly then, so we all can be edified.
Some would surely be edified. Others would stir up dissent. Since my pastor hasn't come here himself, I don't feel I should do it for him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GWH
The promise wasn't made concerning people?

You can read, yes? Do you see any people in the verse. God looks at Himself, loves the life He has and makes a promise to Himself to share it. Not rocket science.

What I find truly ironic, is the Calvinist/Reformed type, with all their insistence on God alone hype, quite often are the most egocentric crowd. It's always about what God has done for them.
 
Not systematically (line by line), although Blain indicated that he agrees with all.
And during discussions I can distinguish those who probably tend to agree from the Tulipists and Actsers.
I would include you in the agreement camp, but do you want to discuss my proposal specifically?
(It is not set in stone; I added "love" most recently per someone's suggestion/feedback, for example.)


One of the oppositions strongest arguments is that God does not love everyone, and

With regard to love, reading your exchange revolving around God's sovereignty generated a thought that I did some ruminating on so that it might emerge more clearly. You wrote, "God is love," and this generated the logical string of thought, "If God is love, and God is sovereign, then love is sovereign." And I suspect that this, love, is the fulcrum upon which our salvation hangs. Yet, that does not necessitate that God does not love the lost. There is a saying, "If you love some(one?thing?), set it free)," and similarly, this is exactly what Jesus had come to do. Yet, there are differences in opinion of what constitutes actual freedom and so, some believe that their slavery is freedom (from hunger in the wilderness per Israel's example) and would rather 'go back to Egypt.' Their example is of a generation that was stuck between slavery and freedom as they could not 'cross over' as Abraham had done and, indeed, that is the core meaning of a "Hebrew." Did God hate those that died in the wilderness, or did God only hate that they refused to do what was essential in successfully crossing over, that they should trust Him?

I may have not successfully expressed my ideas on this very clearly, but I didn't want to forget it altogether either, so I wrote.
 
Of course, but Jesus said to shout our faith from the rooftops (Matt. 10:27),
so I merely encourage him to have courage of his convictions.
our faith in Who? ... our faith in the Lord Jesus Christ ... Cameron and all who have posted on this thread are to shout from the rooftop the Lord Jesus Christ.

speaking of rooftops ...


.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GWH