Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
God-honoring, God-fearing, God-exalting, God-glorifying saints who KNOW in our hearts that we're in Christ ultimately by God's doing.

God saves all kinds....

And, He is not willing that any should perish.

There will be many in heaven who did not know what they were doing (even though sure of themselves)
who simply did one thing... And, that one thing landed them in salvation.

And, that one thing is?


They said, ‘Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved – you and your household.’

Acts 16:31
 
Is he hindering Jesus in any way? Then he's not hindering the church in any way? Do you not experience victory in Jesus?

Sorry to say it.... He leaves you alone because you tend to help his cause by spreading false teaching.
 
Sorry to say it.... He leaves you alone because you tend to help his cause by spreading false teaching.
I never said Satan doesn't attack Christians, or that I don't suffer persecution. But when Satan does that, he actually furthers the cause of Christ as God works all things to our good and more and more into the image of the Lord Jesus Christ. That's why we aren't merely conquerors, but more than conquerors, as God takes what Satan uses against us to make us into overcomers.

Guess more poor discernment on your part.
 
Jesus refused to use his own Deity's power while on earth.
He had it. But, had to refuse it and remain as a man.
He had to to remain in that needed status, to be tested and to die as a man, for all men.

Why do you think Satan tempted Jesus (knowing full well He is the Lord he knew in heaven) to turn stones into bread?
For if Jesus gave in?
And used his divine power to turn the stones into bread?
He would have immediately disqualified himself to die in our place...
Ceasing to be as a perfect man for the atonement.

The temptation in the wilderness was not about whether Jesus had power but whether He would obey the Father’s will during His fast. His purpose at that time was to fast for forty days and nights as Matthew 4:2 shows. Even if someone had offered Him bread, He would have refused it because He was committed to that fast. His refusal to turn stones into bread was not proof that He lacked divine ability but that He would not act against His mission of obedience.

Satan tempted Him to act independently from the Father’s plan. The test was whether Jesus would use His divine power outside of God’s purpose, not whether He possessed that power. Scripture shows that He clearly did use His divine power at other times. He gave life as the Father does (John 5:21), forgave sins (Mark 2:7), answered prayer (John 14:13–14), and upheld all things by the word of His power while purging our sins (Hebrews 1:3).

Therefore, the temptation reveals that Jesus’ divine power was fully present but perfectly submitted to the Father. His fast required restraint, not inability.



....
 
How did He stop functioning as God?

In regards to the humanity of Christ?

Simply do nothing to enable Jesus with His power of Deity.
Leaving all needed enabling by God's power up to the Father and Holy Spirit.

When the stones remained stones, and not bread?
It was not the Father's will to do so.
Satan was tempting Jesus to do it himself by means of His own Deity.

Jesus as God, could have turned the stones into bread.
But, he refused to.
Why?

As a man he needed to remain obedient to the Father's plan.

Though He was God’s Son, He learned obedience through what He suffered. Hebrews 5:8​


God does not have to learn obedience!


........
 
I never said Satan doesn't attack Christians, or that I don't suffer persecution. But when Satan does that, he actually furthers the cause of Christ as God works all things to our good and more and more into the image of the Lord Jesus Christ. That's why we aren't merely conquerors, but more than conquerors, as God takes what Satan uses against us to make us into overcomers.

Guess more poor discernment on your part.

Here it is again...

Is he hindering Jesus in any way? Then he's not hindering the church in any way? Do you not experience victory in Jesus?

He hinders the Church by tricking believers into false doctrines!

It is everywhere today.
 
Here it is again...



He hinders the Church by tricking believers into false doctrines!

It is everywhere today.
And God uses that for good. #winning

Jesus builds the church. We water plant. If Jesus isn't hindered, neither is the church.
 
Jesus... Because of the plan for atonement? Needed to keep on functioning as a man.
A man who would pioneer our needed thinking (faith) that we, as men, would be able to utilize for the Church age.

Fixing our eyes on Jesus, the pioneer and perfecter of our faith.
For the joy set before him he endured the cross, scorning its
shame, and sat down at the right hand of the throne of God." Hebrews 12:2​
He pioneered our faith for us as a man.
He had to do so as a man!
For it was to be tested and proven right for all men to use.
As God? What he would do, would be impossible for Christians to utilize for their own walk.

Hebrews 12:2 does not mean that we can imitate every act of Jesus, because many of His actions were done as God. Jesus was worshiped by others, and He accepted that worship because He is God (Matthew 14:33, John 9:38). We could never imitate that. He forgave sins (Mark 2:5–7) and declared that He is God (John 8:58). We cannot do those things because we are not divine.

When the Bible says to look unto Jesus or to follow in His steps, it is referring to the times when He acted as a man in submission to the Father. We are to follow His humility, His patience, and His faithfulness in suffering. Those are examples believers can follow. But His divine acts are not patterns for us to copy; they are proofs of who He is.

Therefore, Hebrews 12:2 does not mean that Jesus set aside His divine power. It means we are to keep our focus on Him as both the perfect example of obedience in His humanity and the source of faith and salvation in His deity.


Side Note:

Also, I hope you are not saying Jesus had faith like we do in some way. Jesus had declared God the Father and has seen Him. This would pretty much eliminate our faith if we had seen God the Father.



....
 
Is he hindering Jesus in any way? Then he's not hindering the church in any way? Do you not experience victory in Jesus?

Yeah, quite a bit. False doctrines abound, Christians killed and persecuted, the world lies in darkness, wars, organ harvesting, pedophilia, etc. Doesn't sound like he's running the world.
 
What ever miracles Jesus performed any Christian, God could lead him to do the same.
Look!
Even Peter was able to walk on water!
But Peter's faith was too weak to continue and follow through.

That does not mean Jesus did not act of his own power.
I am pretty sure Peter or you cannot forgive sin like Jesus (God) can.
Jesus also said He held all things together by the word of His power.
I am certain neither Peter nor you possesses this power.

You said:
Jesus finished salvation on the Cross as a man.

No, He did so as the God-man.

You said:
He then returned to heaven to be glorified and is once again be as God in full power.

His Omniscience was restored. Not His full power as God.
Again, just read the verses from the points I gave you before.

You said:
For in Christ all the fullness of the Deity lives in bodily form.
Colossians 2:9​

This verse actually supports my case, and not yours, my friend.



....
 
Yeah, quite a bit. False doctrines abound, Christians killed and persecuted, the world lies in darkness, wars, organ harvesting, pedophilia, etc. Doesn't sound like he's running the world.
None of this hinders Jesus. False doctrines bring out true doctrines. Except a grain falls to the ground and dies, it won't produce life. The persecuted church is always the fastest growing church. Do you understand that anyone desiring to live godly will suffer? That it is good for us to be afflicted?

Seems some don't understand what real victory is or how Christ builds His church.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OLDBUTNEW
I’m not comfortable with the idea He stopped functioning as God. But I agree that He never stopped being God when He took on flesh.


His Deity did not stop functioning as God.

Only in regard to enabling his humanity did His Deity stop influencing and enabling .

If His Deity stopped being God?
All the created things in creation would have vaporized!

And He Himself existed before all things,
and in Him all things consist (hold together). Colossians 1:17​


grace and peace!
 
None of this hinders Jesus. False doctrines bring out true doctrines. Except a grain falls to the ground and dies, it won't produce life. The persecuted church is always the fastest growing church. Do you understand that anyone desiring to live godly will suffer? That it is good for us to be afflicted?

Seems some don't understand what real victory is or how Christ builds His church.

Yeah, but he's not ruling the world; satan is. Jesus is building his temple and ruling his people.
 
@Jordon : No worries at all, Bro! I love it!! You've got a great sense of humour, and you're very witty! We're good mates now!
no worries bro, we have Our disagreements here, and no body is perfect we all make mistakes, but enduring to the end we must 😂 🤩
 
If you understand that the book of Deuteronomy is about God initiating a covenant with Israel with terms and sanctions for failing to keep the covenant, you will be able to understand the book of Revelation as God ending the covenant with Israel because they failed to uphold their obligations under the covenant.

Christ is ruling the earth and His kingdom is growing. Satan is bound as Jesus told us...I will build my church and the gates of hell will not prevail against it.

Judgment was poured out upon Israel in the 1st century culminating in the destruction of Jerusalem and the temple.

But those judgments in the book of revelations specifically say the world. Like all fresh water turns to blood causing all life in the water to die. What about 200 million riders from the black hole that hunt humans from one end of the earth to the other? The book a revelations does not say these things are only gonna happen in isreal the rest of the world is just fine. So who was the anti christ? Who was the false prophet? The man of sin must be revealed in order for tribulation to begin. There are written records going back to the babylonian captivity to back up the Bible. All be it scarce. Where are the written records from any civilization in 100 AD talking about the death of 50% of the human race? Or the sun going out or horse riders from the black hole? Or having to drink blood or all the wild life in the sea dying?
 
Jesus refused to use his own Deity's power while on earth.
He had it. But, had to refuse it and remain as a man.
He had to to remain in that needed status, to be tested and to die as a man, for all men.

Why do you think Satan tempted Jesus (knowing full well He is the Lord he knew in heaven) to turn stones into bread?
For if Jesus gave in?
And used his divine power to turn the stones into bread?
He would have immediately disqualified himself to die in our place...
Ceasing to be as a perfect man for the atonement.

Jesus... Because of the plan for atonement? Needed to keep on functioning as a man.
A man who would pioneer our needed thinking (faith) that we, as men, would be able to utilize for the Church age.

Fixing our eyes on Jesus, the pioneer and perfecter of our faith.
For the joy set before him he endured the cross, scorning its
shame, and sat down at the right hand of the throne of God." Hebrews 12:2​
He pioneered our faith for us as a man.
He had to do so as a man!
For it was to be tested and proven right for all men to use.
As God? What he would do, would be impossible for Christians to utilize for their own walk.

What ever miracles Jesus performed any Christian, God could lead him to do the same.
Look!
Even Peter was able to walk on water!
But Peter's faith was too weak to continue and follow through.

As men being aided and empowered by the Spirit, should be able to do the same as long as God called for it in His will.


Jesus finished salvatioss as a man.

He then returned to heaven to be glorified and is once again be as God in full power.

But, this time?
God in bodily form!

For in Christ all the fullness of the Deity lives in bodily form.
Colossians 2:9​
well buddy what you think isn't always accurate, i could start calling you a calvinist soon 🤩

By the spirit Jesus said do not put the lord your God to the test when satan was revealed by the spirit, as scripture says The spirit led Jesus to be tested but what's it's really saying is the spirit was leading Jesus to defeat satan and reveal satan for us. Knowing that Jesus would be put to test by satan the spirit led Jesus to where satan would test him.

And God says when tempted no one should say God is tempting them.

plus jesus could not be tempted

But other than that you've been quite pleasant today, keep it up 🤩
 
Yeah, but he's not ruling the world; satan is. Jesus is building his temple and ruling his people.
How? Satan doesn't have the keys to death and hell. He can't do anything God doesn't allow. What God does allow He uses for His purposes...Satan is actually doing God's bidding. He can't prevail against the church. How is Satan in control of anything?