Objections against Jesus' resurrection

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
wattie

wattie

Senior Member
#1
Feb 24, 2009
3,229
1,126
113
New Zealand
#1
There are theories from critics that people have held to over the years to say Jesus did not rise from the dead.

1... Jesus only swooned on cross

Here are some big problems with this and why this theory bit the dust..

The crucifixion process can kill someone before they are put on the cross.

So let's assume Jesus somehow survived that.

Well then the grave clothes would have suffocated any life left out of Him!

Let's assume he somehow survived that.. being completely ridiculous now..

How is he supposed to say I'm the risen Christ to the disciples in this mostly dead state?

Yes..so this is one theory that holds no water

What others do you know?
 
Dino246

Dino246

Senior Member
#2
Jun 30, 2015
25,404
13,746
113
#2
There is a view that the person who died on the cross was not Jesus but a lookalike, explaining how Jesus could appear to the disciples after His "death". If memory serves, it is the Moslems who teach this falsehood.
 
wattie

wattie

Senior Member
#3
Feb 24, 2009
3,229
1,126
113
New Zealand
#3
Dino246 said:
There is a view that the person who died on the cross was not Jesus but a lookalike, explaining how Jesus could appear to the disciples after His "death". If memory serves, it is the Moslems who teach this falsehood.
Click to expand...
And how would they back up their claim?
 
wattie

wattie

Senior Member
#4
Feb 24, 2009
3,229
1,126
113
New Zealand
#4
Another theory was Jesus hypnotized the disciples to believe He would be resurrected.

Problem with this is He would have not just had to hypnotise the disciples (12 people at once would be incredible anyway) but the 500 people who saw Him also.

That would give Him hypnosis power that basically no one else in history had.. giving Him deity powers anyway!

But.. the thing is with this theory.. and the first I put down.. is they are unintentionally agreeing with some of the gospel:

Jesus-- really living.. really dieing... and that the tomb was empty.
 
p_rehbein

p_rehbein

Senior Member
#5
Sep 4, 2013
30,669
6,860
113
#5
None of this surprises me. Given that there are hundreds of millions of people who do not even believe God actually exists. They prefer to believe they are descendants of some chimpanzee, or, even worse, some gooey blob that crawled out of the ocean a gadbillion years ago. Yean, none of this surprises me.
 
Eli1

Eli1

Well-known member
#6
Apr 5, 2022
4,665
2,000
113
46
#6
This is an interesting take in Eastern but I’m not sure why even bring it to a Christian circle for discussion.
This is a typical and tired atheist argument which is done to death.
Because people who believe this are the equivalent of believing that the Earth is flat. They’re considered a fringe group, even according to Wikipedia which are (most likely) non-believer leftists.

And you also have to distinguish between a non-believer and an atheist. A non believer is most likely an agnostic, but an atheist is actually a person who rejects God and is angry at God and these are the people who are considered fringe, who say that Jesus did not resurrect.
This is a long and tired topic so not sure why even bring it here in a Christian circle.

As Jordan Peterson said: No one thinks more of God than the committed atheist.
 
Eli1

Eli1

Well-known member
#8
Apr 5, 2022
4,665
2,000
113
46
#8
As far as Muslims go, they're a bit confused and it's sad because they were the enlightened ones during Europe's dark ages in science, mathematics and astronomy and now they've gone so far back ... where it's sad to see.
 
wattie

wattie

Senior Member
#9
Feb 24, 2009
3,229
1,126
113
New Zealand
#9
Eli1 said:
This is an interesting take in Eastern but I’m not sure why even bring it to a Christian circle for discussion.
This is a typical and tired atheist argument which is done to death.
Because people who believe this are the equivalent of believing that the Earth is flat. They’re considered a fringe group, even according to Wikipedia which are (most likely) non-believer leftists.

And you also have to distinguish between a non-believer and an atheist. A non believer is most likely an agnostic, but an atheist is actually a person who rejects God and is angry at God and these are the people who are considered fringe, who say that Jesus did not resurrect.
This is a long and tired topic so not sure why even bring it here in a Christian circle.

As Jordan Peterson said: No one thinks more of God than the committed atheist.
Click to expand...
Thinking about Jesus's resurrection, with Easter in mind.
 
Eli1

Eli1

Well-known member
#10
Apr 5, 2022
4,665
2,000
113
46
#10
wattie said:
Thinking about Jesus's resurrection, with Easter in mind.
Click to expand...
Amen to that.
I, along with the members of my church are prepped up and happy for this joyous season which is the defining moment of Christianity, where Jesus defeated death and rose from the dead after performing other miracles prior to this.

Anyone is welcome to challenge this event logically and reasonably with an open mind (like i did when i was an atheist) and you end up realizing that this event is the best thing that has happened to humanity ever!
It gives us a renewed spirit to continue our journey here while separated from God ... for a while ... but forever changed for being allowed to appreciate this event that God did for us by sending His son so we can know Him personally here in our fallen world.

Lee Strobel is another case where he found God by trying to challenge this very notion, that the resurrection of Jesus was false and ended up becoming a Christian in the process when he was following the evidence.
You can refer his movie and documentary to any atheist but most likely they're going to reject it because they're not looking at things with an open mind. Most likely, they are angry at something that happened to them in the Church with some immature Christian or Priest or are angry at God Himself and blame Him for some tragedy that happened in their lives.

So glory to God for all things and for blessing us with Faith in Him.
 
Nehemiah6

Nehemiah6

Senior Member
#11
Jul 18, 2017
26,074
13,771
113
#11
wattie said:
There are theories from critics that people have held to over the years to say Jesus did not rise from the dead.
Click to expand...
This began with the Pharisees and enemies of Christ, and continues with the enemies of God, Christ, and Christians. KJV 28:13 Saying, Say ye, His disciples came by night, and stole him away while we slept.

But the real enemy behind all this is Satan. He hates the fact that Christ died for the sins of the whole world, and rose again for our justification. He also knows that his doom is sealed.
 
Magenta

Magenta

Senior Member
#12
Jul 3, 2015
59,909
29,289
113
#12
wattie said:
And how would they (Muslims) back up their claim?
Click to expand...
For starters, they do not believe God has a Son, and they consider it "shirk" (blasphemy) that we do. As to the crucifixion
of Christ, they say someone was crucified in His stead, and that those who claim it was Jesus are confused ~ Surah 157:

Pickthall
And because of their saying: We slew the Messiah, Jesus son of Mary, Allah’s messenger – they slew him not
nor crucified him, but it appeared so unto them; and lo! those who disagree concerning it are in doubt thereof;
they have no knowledge thereof save pursuit of a conjecture; they slew him not for certain.
 
wattie

wattie

Senior Member
#13
Feb 24, 2009
3,229
1,126
113
New Zealand
#13
Nehemiah6 said:
This began with the Pharisees and enemies of Christ, and continues with the enemies of God, Christ, and Christians. KJV 28:13 Saying, Say ye, His disciples came by night, and stole him away while we slept.

But the real enemy behind all this is Satan. He hates the fact that Christ died for the sins of the whole world, and rose again for our justification. He also knows that his doom is sealed.
Click to expand...
Yeah, this theory doesn't hold water of the body being stolen for a lot of reasons.. but one of the main ones being.. if the disciples did this.. why would they then die for the cause of believing He is risen? It would be a bit ridiculous to carry on to the point of death proclaiming a lie. They would have more likely said 'no. It was a fabrication.. don't kill me.'

This theory though.. also like the first and second ones.. agrees with Jesus living, having disciples who followed Him, dieing.. and the tomb being empty.
 
wattie

wattie

Senior Member
#14
Feb 24, 2009
3,229
1,126
113
New Zealand
#14
Eli1 said:
Amen to that.
I, along with the members of my church are prepped up and happy for this joyous season which is the defining moment of Christianity, where Jesus defeated death and rose from the dead after performing other miracles prior to this.

Anyone is welcome to challenge this event logically and reasonably with an open mind (like i did when i was an atheist) and you end up realizing that this event is the best thing that has happened to humanity ever!
It gives us a renewed spirit to continue our journey here while separated from God ... for a while ... but forever changed for being allowed to appreciate this event that God did for us by sending His son so we can know Him personally here in our fallen world.

Lee Strobel is another case where he found God by trying to challenge this very notion, that the resurrection of Jesus was false and ended up becoming a Christian in the process when he was following the evidence.
You can refer his movie and documentary to any atheist but most likely they're going to reject it because they're not looking at things with an open mind. Most likely, they are angry at something that happened to them in the Church with some immature Christian or Priest or are angry at God Himself and blame Him for some tragedy that happened in their lives.

So glory to God for all things and for blessing us with Faith in Him.
Click to expand...
I have Evidence that Demands a Verdict from Josh McDowell and son. That has a lot of information on this.
 
Nehemiah6

Nehemiah6

Senior Member
#15
Jul 18, 2017
26,074
13,771
113
#15
wattie said:
I have Evidence that Demands a Verdict from Josh McDowell and son. That has a lot of information on this.
Click to expand...
That's a book worth reading. I also have a copy, along with More Evidence that demands a Verdict.
 
wattie

wattie

Senior Member
#16
Feb 24, 2009
3,229
1,126
113
New Zealand
#16
Eli1 said:
Amen to that.
I, along with the members of my church are prepped up and happy for this joyous season which is the defining moment of Christianity, where Jesus defeated death and rose from the dead after performing other miracles prior to this.

Anyone is welcome to challenge this event logically and reasonably with an open mind (like i did when i was an atheist) and you end up realizing that this event is the best thing that has happened to humanity ever!
It gives us a renewed spirit to continue our journey here while separated from God ... for a while ... but forever changed for being allowed to appreciate this event that God did for us by sending His son so we can know Him personally here in our fallen world.

Lee Strobel is another case where he found God by trying to challenge this very notion, that the resurrection of Jesus was false and ended up becoming a Christian in the process when he was following the evidence.
You can refer his movie and documentary to any atheist but most likely they're going to reject it because they're not looking at things with an open mind. Most likely, they are angry at something that happened to them in the Church with some immature Christian or Priest or are angry at God Himself and blame Him for some tragedy that happened in their lives.

So glory to God for all things and for blessing us with Faith in Him.
Click to expand...
Yea, I remember as a university student, joining a Campus Crusade for Christ club..called Tandem. (The Crusade in the name became un PC and associated with brutality killing of muslims).. Josh McDowell was a supporter of Campus Crusade (CRU in America, and Athletes in Action).

When the DaVinci Code movie came out, we were doing an evangelism outreach by taking a non Christian friend to it and then talking about it afterwards.

Like you say though .. most don't have an open mind and their heart is hardened. Also the movie was made not that well and no one was swayed its message anyway!

We were all thinking.. we gotta fight against the message of this movie..but the movie was such a fizzer, there was no controversy.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.