Native American Christianity

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
692
113
#21
Ok, a quick question. What do you think of Native American Christians using the sweat lodge, dance regalia, sweet grass, sage, mugwort(the last three items are used as smudge{incense}; hand drums, and pow-wow drums?
To the Romans Paul became as a Roman; to the Jews, as a Jew. To the native Americans Didymous became as a native American.
 

maxwel

Senior Member
Apr 18, 2013
9,526
2,609
113
#22
Regarding the Issue of Native Americans having a natural bias toward Christianity:



1. I think, as Didymous mentioned, the real point of philosophical contact is through physical contact... you have to SHOW them real Christianity, and SHOW them real Christian love.


2. I think after making a personal impact on them through personal contact, and showing them real christian love... you then STILL have to deal with some serious apologetic issues. You have to ANSWER their philosophical dilemmas.


3. I'm not an expert on Native Americans, but I think the general framework would be the same as when working with other people groups. (You first show them real love, then you answer the hard questions with real answers.)

A. Dealing with racism:
You need to move their focus from sins of racism, to sin in general... you need to help them see racism is only a "symptom" of a much deeper problem.


- You need to move them, emotionally, past the racism they've had to suffer, and help them to see racism isn't the real enemy, but racism is just a SYMPTOM of the real enemy. The real enemy is sin... something all people have in common.

- You might point to atrocities BETWEEN TRIBES, and use that to help identify that SIN is the real problem, and that racism (and tribalism) is just a manifestations of this deeper problem.

- Through pointing to sins occurring in tribal conflict, the point is NOT to minimize anything the U.S. govt has perpetrated, but rather, it is simply to shift the focus from SYMPTOMS (racism) to the UNDERLYING PROBLEM (sin).
(You want to say,
"Yes, the Europeans did all these bad things, truly, but wait, we've also done bad things to each other... WHY IS THAT? WHAT IS THE REAL PROBLEM? And why were some Europeans evil while other's were virtuous... WHY? What's really going on?"
- You need to push them beyond the simple paradigm of racism, so they have to look at the underlying problem.)



B. Dealing with Christianity:
You need to defend "Biblical" Christianity, and show that what some so-called Christians have done, is NOT Biblical Christianity, and has NOTHING TO DO with:

1) the Bible
2) God's commands and intentions
3) sincere, genuine Christians

- There are a number of approaches here, and a number of ways to go at this.

- You'd need to think through the different ways this can be approached, and then use the method that would best resonate in the culture.


4. I'm not an expert on Native American culture, but I think this general method is Biblical, and is effective in most cultures.
A. You show them real Christian love
B. Then you give REAL answers to their philosophical dilemmas... you have to give real answers to the hard questions.



Conclusion:
- This is what missionaries do.
- If you want to be a missionary to your own people, or if you want to be a missionary to another people, this is just what missionaries do.
- You show them genuine Christian love, then give a lot of very deep thought to how you best answer their philosophical dilemmas in a way they can understand.
- This inherently means you can't teach them anything until you first love them, and spend a lot of time listening to them.
 

maxwel

Senior Member
Apr 18, 2013
9,526
2,609
113
#23
I'm sure Didymous has already given much thought to the rudimentary things I mentioned above.

But maybe we have some young Christians here who've never really thought about these things.


It's important to think about these things.
 

preston39

Senior Member
Dec 18, 2017
1,675
240
63
#24
There are a number of significant reasons Native Americans are so strongly against becoming Christians, as the following will show.

First, the whole "Manifest Destiny" thing. The idea that white people were divinely ordained to settle the whole continent of North America-which necessarily meant removing and/or destroying the Native people already here. The premise that white people were inherently superior, and the conviction that God had ordained them to conquer the North American territories from sea to shining sea led to forced removal and/or violent extermination of the Aboriginal people who were viewed as blocking the furtherance of racial and technological progress.

What this meant for us was that the government would force us off our homelands onto reservations, where men professing to be Christians would steal most of the food allocated to us and sell it for their own gain. And then the government forced two generations of children to boarding schools. At these schools, men(and women)professing to be Christians beat, tortured, and raped these children. Punishment was for crimes such as speaking in the only language they'd ever spoken, and other "serious" offenses. My mother told me many stories of her experiences at Chemawa Indian School in Oregon.
When those children returned to their families, they no longer had anything in common with them. Many were sent to trade schools and forced to live and work in cities, so if they ever returned to their people's there was a vast gulf between who they were, and who they should've been.

Then there was the whole eugenics thing, where Indian Health Services clinics and hospitals were routinely sterilizing Native women-perhaps as many as 50% of all Native women, until the giovernment finally put a stop to that in the 1970s.

I am a Native man. Someone pointed out that I wasn't a full blood(which is true), but blood quantum wasn't an issue for us before colonization. Blood quantum is 100% a non Native creation, and nothing we went by prior to the coming of a white man.

Another person pointed out that I was racist, and implied that I thought "whity was bad.". I never thought that, and can't even understand why someone would think I would. Doing so would entail hating half of myself, and that would not only make me stupid, but crazy as well.

The reason I made this post was to let my Christian Brothers and sisters know the challenges I had to overcome, and the challenges other Natives are facing, before becoming Christian. These things are of vital importance to me, because I need to figure out how to respond to these obstacles. I was fortunate to meet a few Christians who weren't afraid to come witness to me where I was. There are a lot more JWs and Mormons out there doing the very same thing, and i've met so many Natives professing to be Mormons and JWs. It ought not to be so. The last time I saw Christians reaching out to this Native community was at Easter, and they came here from Russia to witness to the people in my youngest daughter's community. Some people think I'm angry, and I am, but not for the reason you might think. I'm angry with myself, because I don't know how to tell my own people that we've believed a lie all this time. Real Christians don't do all the things we've been believing they did. I know this because of a few brave souls who witnessed to me. I felt God's love through them, and even though I didn't get saved until years later, I never forgot those people who showed me Jesus Christ, and His love.

So, my brothers and sisters, I don't hate you, I love you. Like Paul, I have an overwhelming love for my people, who are being left to the JWs, and the mormons. I hope some of you will benefit from knowing how hard it is for Native people to even consider Christianity. The gospel of Christ is the power of God unto salvation to everyone that believes, and we know that the preaching of the cross is the power of God.

I know that God is in control, but I also know that He said that the harvest is plenteous, but the laborers are few
D....,

I share great remorse for the Native american.

But, I take exception to your inference that the Christian basis concluded that the...white man...was in any form ....superior. I don't find that conclusion in studies of early american history.

Perhaps you can guide us to that which you used to reach your conclusion.

Have comfort in the fact that G-d loves all humans.
 
L

LPT

Guest
#25
Ok, a quick question. What do you think of Native American Christians using the sweat lodge, dance regalia, sweet grass, sage, mugwort(the last three items are used as smudge{incense}; hand drums, and pow-wow drums?
nothing wrong with that, this Native American Woman uses hand drums and others things.


[video=youtube;j_l9YztCjNc]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j_l9YztCjNc[/video]
 

Nehemiah6

Senior Member
Jul 18, 2017
26,074
13,778
113
#26
Ok, a quick question. What do you think of Native American Christians using the sweat lodge, dance regalia, sweet grass, sage, mugwort(the last three items are used as smudge{incense}; hand drums, and pow-wow drums?
All of that belongs to the Animistic belief system of Native Americans. It is essentially pagan, therefore not for believers. It involves communication with spirits, and these spirits are certainly not from God and the Holy Spirit.

Native Americans who are Christians should be the primary missionaries to their fellow Natives. And once people are saved and baptized, they must separate themselves from all of this. Just like Jews, Hindus, Muslims, and Buddhists would have to separate themselves from their old religions.
 
M

Miri

Guest
#27
As to why I identify myself as Native, I've never had a choice. People have always thought I was either Hispanic, Pacific Islander, or Native American. My white father left me with my Native mother, so I never knew any other life.

Hey you think you got problems. I’ve had people ask me if I’m Asian, Chinese,
Egyptians, Spanish, Italian, Moroccan, South American! :)

Im mixed race, mum was British white, father unknown but he gave me a nice sun tan.

I decided long ago I was going to be me and I’m seriously not bothered any more by
other people’s expectations or attempts to put me in a nicely labelled box.

Im just me and if anyone has a problem with that, they get ignored or worse still
”that stare” lol


5143.gif
 

Didymous

Senior Member
Feb 22, 2018
5,047
2,101
113
#28
Hello Thomas. I am glad you asked that, because I have been curious about it :) I have participated in sweats and medicine circles, but that was before becoming Christian. The thing I am curious about the sweats you participate in is, are they traditional sweats where you give honor to your ancestors, or are the sweats you participate in Christian focused? Or is it a mix, with all beliefs welcome, giving you an opportunity to witness to others? Thank you for inviting our questions :) I have been wanting to ask, but did not want to pry :eek:
The whole purpose of my question was about CHRISTIAN Natives. I haven't been in a sweat for years, but have Native friends that do sweats. If I did go to a sweat, it would be as a Christian, and as a witness of Jesus Christ.

I remember attending sweats before I was saved, and remember White Christians coming to the sweats. In fact, my last testimony was about that
 

Didymous

Senior Member
Feb 22, 2018
5,047
2,101
113
#29
[FONT=&quot]28 [/FONT][FONT=&quot]There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus.[/FONT][FONT=&quot] [/FONT][FONT=&quot][/FONT][FONT=&quot]29[/FONT][FONT=&quot] And if you are Christ’s, then you are Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise. [/FONT][FONT=&quot]Gal 3:28-29

I put this quote up first because it is just so important.

I sympathise with your position, but would also direct your attention to other parts of the world, such as the African continent (sub-Saharan Africa in particular) that suffered under colonialism, sometimes for centuries, and the "official" churches of those colonising powers, yet saw through the paternalism, exploitation, and outright brutality sometimes shown by both coloniser and church to perceive and accept the essential truths of the Gospel. Also, much of the real heavy lifting, concerning the Gospel, in Africa was done by mission agencies and churches operating often against the wishes of the colonising powers. However, nothing was perfect here, yet, in reality, in the 21st century the centre of gravity of world Christianity is firmly in sub-Saharan Africa, NOT in Europe or North America. This is shown also by the volume of indigenous missionaries coming out of African countries that in most (uniformed) Christian's views still belong firmly in the camp of countries still requiring pioneer missions activity.

I grew up in a country (South Africa) that, amongst whites anyway, regarded itself as Christian, yet had some of the most racially discriminatory laws of any country in modern history. In addition, one of the major church denominations in the country, the Dutch Reformed Church, tried to give a theological justification to what the world came to know as Apartheid. I grew up as a so-called privileged white, but was also privileged to grow up with lots of negro's on our small farm. As a result, while I could see differences (some of them artificial and enforced) between them and myself, I could also see, as far as all the things that really count, essentially no differences at all. So, despite the laws of the land telling me, officially, that non-white ethnic groups were second-class citizens, I knew that however the government designated those people that they were NOT 2nd-class people!
However, in South Africa, despite all its ongoing problems the strength of Christianity amongst the non-white population of the country is very high (perhaps 40-50% of the population would be regular church goers)!

So, I completely get the paradox of a country that has a constitution such as the USA adopted, yet felt entitled to embark on a genocidal campaign against native Americans.
However, Christianity is NOT, and never has been, the "white man's religion."
It is also absolutely true that no ethno-linguistic group is intrinsically superior to any other (you don't really need me to tell you this, but it is important for me to explicitly mention it).

The merits of Jesus Christ stand irrespective of history!
And, Africans, praise God, have seen through all the insults, discrimination, violence and brutality thrown at them by whites, many claiming the moral high ground of professed Christian belief, to grasp Christ and have not let go!
I stand profoundly impressed, and have huge respect for African Christians who have responded to Christ in the way that they have in the face of their treatment by "white" Christians!

So, please understand that the situation of native Americans, while terrible, is not unique, having been repeated all across the globe to a greater or lesser degree wherever European nations established colonies, or some other form of "national interest".

Becoming a Christian, does not identify one with any other group defined politically or ethnoliguistically.
Children of God are found in every ethnolinguistic group on the planet, but are defined in these terms "There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus." Gal 3:28
So, no matter what our gender, race, or social standing...

We are all blood relations, but only by the blood of Christ, nothing else would bring us together...

[/FONT]
I appreciate your feedback. If I was in Africa, I'd be speaking of Africa. My whole point on ethnicity is not that I view it as important, but that to Natives, for the following reason, it is: Christian churches historically have told Natives that they needed to put all their cultural and traditional ways behind them-even language. While this may not be a widespread or blatent as it was initially, it is still a latent message being preached subconsciously by many churches reaching out to Natives.

I realize that most who responded here are more enlightened about this, and don't believe that way. Those who didn't, probably do.
 

Didymous

Senior Member
Feb 22, 2018
5,047
2,101
113
#31
I know some native Americans the chant "Yah, Yah, Yah" and don;t talk about it but they worship "the Great Creator" and say His name is YHWH, thus "Yah"

I think great evil has come agaoinst their population, just an example, CPS gets twice as much to take an native child from their family. very sad, however Yah knows those who are His and will reply all evildoers.
I've met some as well, and it was awesome to worship with them!
 

Didymous

Senior Member
Feb 22, 2018
5,047
2,101
113
#32
[FONT=&quot]28 [/FONT][FONT=&quot]There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus.[/FONT][FONT=&quot] [/FONT][FONT=&quot][/FONT][FONT=&quot]29[/FONT][FONT=&quot] And if you are Christ’s, then you are Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise. [/FONT][FONT=&quot]Gal 3:28-29

I put this quote up first because it is just so important.

I sympathise with your position, but would also direct your attention to other parts of the world, such as the African continent (sub-Saharan Africa in particular) that suffered under colonialism, sometimes for centuries, and the "official" churches of those colonising powers, yet saw through the paternalism, exploitation, and outright brutality sometimes shown by both coloniser and church to perceive and accept the essential truths of the Gospel. Also, much of the real heavy lifting, concerning the Gospel, in Africa was done by mission agencies and churches operating often against the wishes of the colonising powers. However, nothing was perfect here, yet, in reality, in the 21st century the centre of gravity of world Christianity is firmly in sub-Saharan Africa, NOT in Europe or North America. This is shown also by the volume of indigenous missionaries coming out of African countries that in most (uniformed) Christian's views still belong firmly in the camp of countries still requiring pioneer missions activity.

I grew up in a country (South Africa) that, amongst whites anyway, regarded itself as Christian, yet had some of the most racially discriminatory laws of any country in modern history. In addition, one of the major church denominations in the country, the Dutch Reformed Church, tried to give a theological justification to what the world came to know as Apartheid. I grew up as a so-called privileged white, but was also privileged to grow up with lots of negro's on our small farm. As a result, while I could see differences (some of them artificial and enforced) between them and myself, I could also see, as far as all the things that really count, essentially no differences at all. So, despite the laws of the land telling me, officially, that non-white ethnic groups were second-class citizens, I knew that however the government designated those people that they were NOT 2nd-class people!
However, in South Africa, despite all its ongoing problems the strength of Christianity amongst the non-white population of the country is very high (perhaps 40-50% of the population would be regular church goers)!

So, I completely get the paradox of a country that has a constitution such as the USA adopted, yet felt entitled to embark on a genocidal campaign against native Americans.
However, Christianity is NOT, and never has been, the "white man's religion."
It is also absolutely true that no ethno-linguistic group is intrinsically superior to any other (you don't really need me to tell you this, but it is important for me to explicitly mention it).

The merits of Jesus Christ stand irrespective of history!
And, Africans, praise God, have seen through all the insults, discrimination, violence and brutality thrown at them by whites, many claiming the moral high ground of professed Christian belief, to grasp Christ and have not let go!
I stand profoundly impressed, and have huge respect for African Christians who have responded to Christ in the way that they have in the face of their treatment by "white" Christians!

So, please understand that the situation of native Americans, while terrible, is not unique, having been repeated all across the globe to a greater or lesser degree wherever European nations established colonies, or some other form of "national interest".

Becoming a Christian, does not identify one with any other group defined politically or ethnoliguistically.
Children of God are found in every ethnolinguistic group on the planet, but are defined in these terms "There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus." Gal 3:28
So, no matter what our gender, race, or social standing...

We are all blood relations, but only by the blood of Christ, nothing else would bring us together...

[/FONT]
I agree with you, sir. The reality, though, for Natives, was that White people came, forced their idea of Christianity on the indigenous population while telling them they had to lie down their heathen ways and become white, so yes, that's how it was presented, and that's how it continues to be perceived. The main issue is still, that Natives are still being told they have to stop being Native and start being White. While the initial damage was done primarily by Catholic missionaries, the missiology of today's churches is still, primarily, the same
 

graceNpeace

Senior Member
Aug 12, 2016
2,180
107
63
#33
I appreciate your feedback. If I was in Africa, I'd be speaking of Africa. My whole point on ethnicity is not that I view it as important, but that to Natives, for the following reason, it is: Christian churches historically have told Natives that they needed to put all their cultural and traditional ways behind them-even language. While this may not be a widespread or blatent as it was initially, it is still a latent message being preached subconsciously by many churches reaching out to Natives.

I realize that most who responded here are more enlightened about this, and don't believe that way. Those who didn't, probably do.
Similar things happened in Africa!
That's why I felt it so important to use events in Africa for comparison...

The situation you allude to in North America is not unique...perhaps in specific details there were differences, but in principle not!

As for modern churches exhibiting paternalism that is most certainly still true!
However, it does need to be accepted that EVERY culture on earth needs to conform itself to Christ.
I come from an ethnic group (Anglo-Saxon) that certainly has indulged in the kind of cultural imperialism that you are so unhappy about.
However, I see my own ethnic group as in dire need of confirmation to the example of Christ rather than try to impose its culture on others...
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
61,133
30,265
113
#34
The whole purpose of my question was about CHRISTIAN Natives. I haven't been in a sweat for years, but have Native friends that do sweats. If I did go to a sweat, it would be as a Christian, and as a witness of Jesus Christ.

I remember attending sweats before I was saved, and remember White Christians coming to the sweats. In fact, my last testimony was about that
Yes, Thomas, I understood that part, you are asking about indigenous CHRISTIANS attending and/or participating in traditional Native ceremonial rituals. I did think you meant yourself, though, and apologize for the misunderstanding.
 

Angela53510

Senior Member
Jan 24, 2011
11,786
2,959
113
#35
We had exactly the same thing happen in Canada, with residential schools, children being beaten for using their native languages, by the Anglican and Catholic Churches. I think the last residential schools in Canada closed in the 1990's.

Yet, in seminary, I met some incredible native people, who were going back as missionaries to their own people. One man, saved out of skid row and alcoholism, had a church down where he used to sleep on the streets. People were coming to Christ. Another woman, absolutely brilliant, beautiful, with a real understand of culture, and where the native practices were pagan, as opposed to culture, was finishing her MDiv to go back and witness on her own reserve.

But others, are bitter, want government "reconciliation" money. Except, the bands get so much government money, and most of it goes to nepotism, while so many on the reserves do not even have clean drinking water. My son worked one summer auditing bands in Alberta, and the things they uncovered with regards to money usage for personal gain by the elders was shocking!

Truly, Christ is the only answer, regardless of where anyone has come from, their ethnicity, culture, and for all the hurts and damage we ALL experience growing up in a fallen world. God has not called me to missions with native peoples, although when I lived in northern BC, I had many native Christian friends. It was amazing to see God working in their lives. I knew one woman, who came from a tragic family background, backslid a lot. Then, she just seemed to move forward, and she was really living her life for God. But, she hated all the native practices and spiritualities. She said they were all from Satan. I don't know much about it, it could also be her background.

Anyway, I am glad you brought this up. I was brought up colour blind. My father used to build houses, and always picked the natives who were day labourers, and brought them back daily, if they wanted to work regularly. His mom was the same, always helping the natives, giving them a place to stay. We also had blacks and orientals in our house, because my dad was in sports. Sports was kind of the language my dad spoke, till he was saved 5 months before he died at 83. Then he talked about Jesus.

I guess my question would be to you, "What are you going to do about reaching your own people?" And "Is there anything we can do to help?"
 
Mar 28, 2016
15,954
1,528
113
#36
There are many traditions of men as laws of men that coincide with the tradition as law of God. I am some what aware of the traditions of the Stockbridge Muncie tribes long time friends of mine that originated in the New York area that were given a partial of land from the Menomonee Indian nation .

One of their daughters was elected Chief of the tribe sort of like in the government of Judges.... before there were any kings in Israel, Isreal rejecting God not seen as King but rather like that of Debra a Judge to show God sees no difference between man and woman (His bride the church) . That seemed interesting .What a great representative blessing that brings glory to God not seen

And sweat in the Bible is a sign that someone is pouring out their heart and soul using their life in jeopardy of it purchased for another ,His bride the church .It can be seen in the garden when the father poured out the cup of His wrath meant for us on the Son and he sweat as if it was drop of blood.

The life of the flesh is in the blood that life is spiritual unseen literal blood without the spirits simply return to the rudiments of this world
 
L

LPT

Guest
#37
The whole purpose of my question was about CHRISTIAN Natives. I haven't been in a sweat for years, but have Native friends that do sweats. If I did go to a sweat, it would be as a Christian, and as a witness of Jesus Christ.

I remember attending sweats before I was saved, and remember White Christians coming to the sweats. In fact, my last testimony was about that
just don't use the peyote lol jk...
 
L

LPT

Guest
#38
Actually sweating like that is good for the body has a detoxing effect. getting rid of impurities.
 
L

LPT

Guest
#39
Actually sweating like that is good for the body has a detoxing effect. getting rid of impurities.
Actually LPT you need to look that up before you make such a statement hehe.. That's what I've heard but I never looked it up only about 1% of heavy metals are secreted that way sry hahaha...
 
L

LPT

Guest
#40
Yea I know I feel, its all cool