Israel.

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Status
Not open for further replies.
The prophets foretold Israel's and Judah's regatherings after Israel's destruction in 722BC and after Jerusalem's exile in 586BC. That regathering began when a remnant returned from Babylon to rebuild Jerusalem and the temple, and was continued for centuries until Christ by a remnant of Israel that returned to the land out of all nations. The remnant of Israel and Judah that was born from above at Pentecost became the holy nation ruled by God that God said he wanted Israel to be in Exodus 19:6. Peter confirms the fulfillment of this holy nation in 1 Peter 2:9.

An earthly nation ruled by men was never God's will for Israel (1 Samuel 8:7). Since the priestly, holy nation that he wanted from the beginning has come into being in Christ, it's not realistic or sensible to think that God would want to restore an earthly nation ruled by men that he never wanted in the first place.

Since the holy nation born from above and ruled by God is the fulfillment of Israel's and Judah's restoration prophecies, there is no reason or warrant for a future fulfillment. By rejecting Christ and losing the land, Judaism put itself in the position of needing a future fulfillment of those prophecies. That is the horse you've hitched your wagon to.

Thank you for your reply.
Understanding ones view from start to finish helps for me to understand what is needed to be discussed in hopes of resolve according to scripture. This brings me to other questions that needs to be answered.

I believe the physical Israel needed to be in order to fulfill end time prophecy. The only nation to be born in one day as it is known is hard to deny that it wasn't prophecy fulfillment. Nevertheless here it is and here we are.

Jesus talked about the abomination of desolation, also we know that the anti-Christ will deceive Israel for the first half of the tribulation.
My questions to you is how could this ever take place if Israel never came about?
What other temple would be built and by whom, that anti-Christ would sit in.
What do you think is the abomination of desolation?

Please be patient with me I'm still learning.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2ndTimeIsTheCharm
Thank you for your reply.
Understanding ones view from start to finish helps for me to understand what is needed to be discussed in hopes of resolve according to scripture. This brings me to other questions that needs to be answered.

I believe the physical Israel needed to be in order to fulfill end time prophecy. The only nation to be born in one day as it is known is hard to deny that it wasn't prophecy fulfillment. Nevertheless here it is and here we are.

Jesus talked about the abomination of desolation, also we know that the anti-Christ will deceive Israel for the first half of the tribulation.
My questions to you is how could this ever take place if Israel never came about?
What other temple would be built and by whom, that anti-Christ would sit in.
What do you think is the abomination of desolation?

Please be patient with me I'm still learning.

Very well said, you are correct!
 
The prophets foretold Israel's and Judah's regatherings after Israel's destruction in 722BC and after Jerusalem's exile in 586BC. That regathering began when a remnant returned from Babylon to rebuild Jerusalem and the temple, and was continued for centuries until Christ by a remnant of Israel that returned to the land out of all nations. The remnant of Israel and Judah that was born from above at Pentecost became the holy nation ruled by God that God said he wanted Israel to be in Exodus 19:6. Peter confirms the fulfillment of this holy nation in 1 Peter 2:9.

An earthly nation ruled by men was never God's will for Israel (1 Samuel 8:7). Since the priestly, holy nation that he wanted from the beginning has come into being in Christ, it's not realistic or sensible to think that God would want to restore an earthly nation ruled by men that he never wanted in the first place.

Since the holy nation born from above and ruled by God is the fulfillment of Israel's and Judah's restoration prophecies, there is no reason or warrant for a future fulfillment. By rejecting Christ and losing the land, Judaism put itself in the position of needing a future fulfillment of those prophecies. That is the horse you've hitched your wagon to.

That is an anti-Septic remark!
 
There certainly is no spiritualizing the Israel referenced in Romans 11.

That's what the entirety of Roman 9-11 does. It makes a distinction between Israel of faith (spiritual Israel) and Israel of unbelief (natural Israel). Spiritual Israel is the remnant out of natural Israel.

I guess it's time to re-issue the Romans 9-11 Challenge that no one has taken up yet

Romans 9-11 Challenge
Show one verse in Romans chapters 9-11, excluding Romans 11:26, that states anything other than a remnant is saved.
 
I believe the physical Israel needed to be in order to fulfill end time prophecy. The only nation to be born in one day as it is known is hard to deny that it wasn't prophecy fulfillment. Nevertheless here it is and here we are.

As I explained in my previous post, this is because you don"t believe what scripture says, but you believe what Judaism believes.

Jesus talked about the abomination of desolation, also we know that the anti-Christ will deceive Israel for the first half of the tribulation.
My questions to you is how could this ever take place if Israel never came about?
What other temple would be built and by whom, that anti-Christ would sit in.
What do you think is the abomination of desolation?

The abomination of desolation is something that occurred prior to the Roman siege of Jerusalem in 70AD. What it was exactly is not clear, but Christians warned by Jesus to flee Jerusalem when they saw it happen, took heed and did so before the Roman army came and surrounded the city. This is a historical fact described by Josephus and Eusebius. IMO the abomination occurred when the zealots barricaded themselves inside the temple during their coup. Jerusalem endured terrible atrocities by them after that, and then the Romans completely destroyed it.

Any building that unbelieving men build now would not be the temple of God; it by itself would be an abomination to God; a slap in God's face.
 
That's what the entirety of Roman 9-11 does. It makes a distinction between Israel of faith (spiritual Israel) and Israel of unbelief (natural Israel). Spiritual Israel is the remnant out of natural Israel.

I guess it's time to re-issue the Romans 9-11 Challenge that no one has taken up yet

Romans 9-11 Challenge
Show one verse in Romans chapters 9-11, excluding Romans 11:26, that states anything other than a remnant is saved.
Chapter 9 explains the purpose of the remnant and that was saved
The introduction of chapter 11 places emphasis that God has not rejected "his people" and provides a definition of who is being referred to, "...Israelite myself, a descendant of Abraham, from the tribe of Benjamin." and verse elaborates the present time remnant chosen by grace. These are chosen, by grace, to fulfil Isreal's obligation, responsibility, to be a light unto the world and indeed, how many NT books were written by gentiles? And if the world has been so illuminated by just the twelve how much more will the fullness of Israel (differentiated in this chapter from the fullness of the gentiles).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2ndTimeIsTheCharm
That's what the entirety of Roman 9-11 does. It makes a distinction between Israel of faith (spiritual Israel) and Israel of unbelief (natural Israel). Spiritual Israel is the remnant out of natural Israel.

I guess it's time to re-issue the Romans 9-11 Challenge that no one has taken up yet

Romans 9-11 Challenge
Show one verse in Romans chapters 9-11, excluding Romans 11:26, that states anything other than a remnant is saved.

Why are you excluding 26?
 
As I explained in my previous post, this is because you don"t believe what scripture says, but you believe what Judaism believes.



The abomination of desolation is something that occurred prior to the Roman siege of Jerusalem in 70AD. What it was exactly is not clear, but Christians warned by Jesus to flee Jerusalem when they saw it happen, took heed and did so before the Roman army came and surrounded the city. This is a historical fact described by Josephus and Eusebius. IMO the abomination occurred when the zealots barricaded themselves inside the temple during their coup. Jerusalem endured terrible atrocities by them after that, and then the Romans completely destroyed it.

Any building that unbelieving men build now would not be the temple of God; it by itself would be an abomination to God; a slap in God's face.

So you don't believe in the rapture and believe Jesus has already returned.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DeanM
Well then?
Tell us, please?

Do you believe the Jews deserved Oct 7 because they stole the land?

Have you mentioned the synagogue of Satan ploy to pertain to all Jews?

Do you believe the Holocaust didn't happen?

:unsure:


I would apply that question to HeIsHere and Beekeeper ...
 
And if the world has been so illuminated by just the twelve how much more will the fullness of Israel (differentiated in this chapter from the fullness of the gentiles).

When Paul wrote

But if their falling [is] riches of the world, and their loss [is] riches of nations, how much more their fullness? Romans 11:12
He was not speaking of a time when natural Israel would be exalted to greatness, but was saying that natural Israel's fall resulted in spiritual Israel's greatness, Why? Because that opened the door to the gentiles who would become the fullness of spiritual Israel, ie, the body of Christ.

This was prophesied by Jacob when he gave the birthright to his adopted half-Egyptian son, Ephraim, making him the firstborn who inherited all of the promises to Abraham. He foretold that the seed of Ephraim (Israel) would become a fullness of gentiles. The name Ephraim is used synonymously with Israel in scripture.

And his father [Jacob] refused and said, I know, my son, I know. He also shall be a people, and he [Manasseh] shall become great. But his younger brother [Ephraim] shall become greater than he, and his seed shall become a fullness of gentiles. Genesis 48:19
The seed of Israel becoming a fullness of gentiles is obviously referring to the body of Christ that inherits all of the promises to Abraham

And if you are of Christ, then you are the seed of Abraham, and heirs according to promise. Galatians 3:29
For all the promises of God are yea and amen in Christ unto the glory of God through us. 2 Corinthians 1:20
 
To highlight the fact that every other part of Romans 9-11 says that only a remnant is ever saved. Verse 26 cannot contradict that rule that Paul meticulously established over the course of 3 chapters.


So why did he say it? I've heard it argued either way, as I have said, God knows the numbers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.