Loss of salvation???

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
They will live forever, but not in his presence or around his people. Christ is not going to allow any hurtful people (unfruitful) into his kingdom. They will be expelled from his presence.

Eternal life is "quality of life" those who have it go to heaven when they physically die.

"Fruit" can also refers to converts to the faith.
This makes the most sense in context, considering Jesus was speaking to His disciples
 
Do you believe born from above is a singular event in time?

Yes, being generated (conceived) from above happens only once, but being fully born doesn't happen until the resurrection when we receive the adoption as sons/daughters

ETA: Oh sorry, I thought you were talking with me
 
Scripture tells us that the moment we were Saved God began a work in us that wouldn't be finished until our resurrection even if death comes first. That means a lot of people that shouldn't be in Heaven will be there because the finished work is what God provides even if we struggle with a multitude of problematic areas.
 
I do not appreciate the idea of loss of salvation. You do not appreciate the TRUTH of eternal security.

We will never perish.

Are you one His sheep? Yes, you are. His sheep never perish.

Deduction:

You cannot call yourself one of His sheep if you think you can perish. His sheep NEVER perish.

I know you don't and to some degree understand why.

If it’ll settle you for the time being, yes - I believe in security, but see it far narrower than you do. Again, see #4188 for now
 
I question the person that tells me they're Saved but tries to never do what they read in the Bible or will ignore whenever God attempts to speak to them.

To me, the eternally secure Saved person is one who might have a trillion bad ways but they're trying to be better and to obey God.

I don't know how someone can truly know God and not become a better version of themselves because they're trying to follow God and obey God.
 
That's funny stuff right there.

You are doing all you can to get believers thrown into the LoF for all eternity. The most hurtful thing we can do to His body.

See my previous comment I made to you that says God will corrupt "believers" who corrupt the temple of God.
 
To me, the eternally secure Saved person is one who might have a trillion bad ways but they're trying to be better and to obey God.

God can work with people who acknowledge their own poverty and look to him, but those who trust in their spiritual nature he will spew out of his mouth.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lrs68
If it’ll settle you for the time being, yes - I believe in security, but see it far narrower than you do. Again, see #4188 for now
That's a good way to put it. Eternal security through the narrow door.

IMO that's really what this whole controversy boils down to: eternal security through the narrow door vs, eternal security through the wide door.
 
Can a person walk away from God even though God hasn't left them? And if they walk away from God then why wouldn't God give them their desire to be away from Him?

I will let scripture answer that since the Bible is the Lord's inspired word.

2 Timothy 2:13 — If we believe not, yet he abideth faithful: he cannot deny himself.

It seems that the Lord takes very seriously what He does when taking the sins upon Himself those who come to Him in faith. Removing from them the gift of salvation appears to be a matter of not only a denial of Himself, but also be a matter of unfaithfulness to His own Spirit since it would entail the Lord forfeiting His own Spirit.

So, if you would, how many people have you ever known who intentionally walked away from the Lord, and what was their basis for doing so? How do you know they had done so? How did you verify that? If you say it was you, how can you prove the Lord had ever removed your salvation from you? How do you know MM younever had it in the first place?

Lots of questions given that the claim for loss of salvation defies scripture, so therefore to be expected.

MM
 
The hope is that you focus on what I actually said instead of misrepresenting it, and recognize that someone who disagrees with you is not obligated to comply with your made-up constructs and challenges pertaining to God's sovereign determinations. See my parallel discussion with @HeIsHere regarding your imagined “line” argument. I've cc'd you.

There you go again, dodging straightforward questions with evasive claims for my allegedly not understanding what you stated before. Why not answer my questions? What is your game here?

MM
 
I will let scripture answer that since the Bible is the Lord's inspired word.

2 Timothy 2:13 — If we believe not, yet he abideth faithful: he cannot deny himself.

It seems that the Lord takes very seriously what He does when taking the sins upon Himself those who come to Him in faith. Removing from them the gift of salvation appears to be a matter of not only a denial of Himself, but also be a matter of unfaithfulness to His own Spirit since it would entail the Lord forfeiting His own Spirit.

So, if you would, how many people have you ever known who intentionally walked away from the Lord, and what was their basis for doing so? How do you know they had done so? How did you verify that? If you say it was you, how can you prove the Lord had ever removed your salvation from you? How do you know MM younever had it in the first place?

Lots of questions given that the claim for loss of salvation defies scripture, so therefore to be expected.

MM
Is not following God or having Faith/Belief in God the same as living for Satan after knowing God?
 
It seems that the Lord takes very seriously what He does when taking the sins upon Himself those who come to Him in faith. Removing from them the gift of salvation appears to be a matter of not only a denial of Himself, but also be a matter of unfaithfulness to His own Spirit since it would entail the Lord forfeiting His own Spirit.

How vain and deluded do you have to be to think that rebellious Christians could make God forfeit his spirit?