Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
True Calvinism claims God eternally decrees all events, including human actions.

Yet, scripture clearly says God did not command nor put into His mind the abominations of Israel and Judah (Jer. 32:35).

Therefore, if Calvinism were true, God would be both the author and non-author of sin at the same time, which violates His holiness and the law of non-contradiction. It makes God contradict Himself, which is inherently heretical.
only in the assassination of Persons faith does it.

John Calvin taught being obedient to the father.

What would be the point if you think he believed he would doing everything God had made him do.

He's doing it through mutualism, being saved

Nope what your reading is Someone's else's imagination.

Anyhow let's just say for one minute you think predestination is what your making out to be true of somebody that would be a crime.

But I don't see predestination as predetermining,

I don't see it as talking about God choosing you as forcing you

I talk about predestination as something nice

Same as God choosing you

Same as God putting his mercy in your heart.

Same as God willing you

Same as guiding and his sheep then following

What your doing is poisoning his well
 
only in the assassination of Persons faith does it.

John Calvin taught being obedient to the father.

What would be the point if you think he believed he would doing everything God had made him do.

He's doing it through mutualism, being saved

Nope what your reading is Someone's else's imagination.

Anyhow let's just say for one minute you think predestination is what your making out to be true of somebody that would be a crime.

But I don't see predestination as predetermining,

I don't see it as talking about God choosing you as forcing you

I talk about predestination as something nice

Same as God choosing you

Same as God putting his mercy in your heart.

Same as God willing you

Same as guiding and his sheep then following

What your doing is poisoning his well

@Jordon : You tell 'em, Bro!
 
OR...it indicates a man's will that has been set free by God's grace!
here you go @Blue155 found it for you here is Rufus saying God doesn't control you like a robot and saying he can give you enabling grace 😊 to be saved


He was quoting for God so loved the world he gave his only son, that whom ever should believe in him shall be saved.

So here is Rufus saying he can give you enabling grace to do so.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OLDBUTNEW
By wanting me to explain and by wanting to how God's eternal decrees don't make him morally culpable for sin per Calvinism, is basically saying that God's eternal decrees does make him morally culpable for sin, per Calvinism, otherwise the question would not be asked. That's what I've been saying about Calvinism all along, and so it has been affirmed that what I said is true of Calvinism. Which is this: Calvinism has God being morally culpable for man’s sin in His own eternal decree. Also, the fact the questionnaire has referenced Job 1 and Acts 4 as verses to suggest that, further proves that’s what Calvinism believes. I don’t have to answer any questions, as the questionnaire and responses from Calvinists on here has proved my point about Calvinism. By asking the question how God’s eternal decree doesn’t make Him culpable has proved the logical tension and inconsistency in Calvinism.
 
By wanting me to explain and by wanting to how God's eternal decrees don't make him morally culpable for sin per Calvinism, is basically saying that God's eternal decrees does make him morally culpable for sin, per Calvinism, otherwise the question would not be asked. That's what I've been saying about Calvinism all along, and so it has been affirmed that what I said is true of Calvinism. Which is this: Calvinism has God being morally culpable for man’s sin in His own eternal decree. Also, the fact the questionnaire has referenced Job 1 and Acts 4 as verses to suggest that, further proves that’s what Calvinism believes. I don’t have to answer any questions, as the questionnaire and responses from Calvinists on here has proved my point about Calvinism. By asking the question how God’s eternal decree doesn’t make Him culpable has proved the logical tension and inconsistency in Calvinism.
when tempted


No one should say God is tempting them


Question

.what makes you think a bible scholar like John Calvin wouldn't know this
 
  • Like
Reactions: OLDBUTNEW
The very will that God eternally decreed the man to have per Calvinism…which is the will that God eternally decreed to set man free, per Calvinism? Yet, since the individual is one of the elect, then God is having to set the elect’s will free, even though it has already been done in God’s eternal decree (since the man is the elect), per Calvinism? If God already eternally decreed the will to be free, why is there a need for grace to make it free? Hmmm….inconsistency abounds in Calvinism…
 
The very will that God eternally decreed the man to have…which is the will that God eternally decreed to set man free? Yet, since the individual is one of the elect, then God is having to set the elect’s will free even though it has already been done in God’s eternal decree as the man is the elect? If God already eternally decreed the will to be free, why is there a need for grace to make it free? Hmmm….inconsistency abounds in Calvinism…
I suggest you plug your ears to stop the day light shining through