Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
IOW, you have no idea what is going on in Gen 3:15? You don't see a sovereign divine decree being issued to the serpent on behalf of Eve?

The Jude passage does not teach that God destroyed all the Hebrews -- only unbelievers did he destroy.

Furthermore, the Exodus out of Egypt precedes the Hebrews' wilderness sojourn and occupation of the Land. The Exodus was just the first leg in the process of salvation, and God rescued the Hebrews from Egypt not because they were believers, but rather in spite of their idolatrous hearts!

If you don't want to walk by faith and be destroyed like the saved Israelites who didn't walk by faith were, that's fine with me.
 
Mine is solely Jesus Christ and Him crucified. That you glorify the works of man over God's is evident so no surprise there.
Anyway, discussions with you have proven fruitless and a waste of time so henceforth you'll be joining your compatriot @Genez on my ignore list.
I graciously accept your surrender.
 
Another verse for you to stumble over

Take heed unto thyself, and unto the doctrine; continue in them: for in doing this thou shalt both save thyself, and them that hear thee. 1 Timothy 4:16

I haven't stumbled over any. It is you who stumbles because you lift the above text out of context. Go reconcile your verse with something else Paul told Timothy:

2 Tim 1:8-9
9 who has saved us and called us to a holy life
not because of anything we have done but because of his own purpose and grace. This grace was given us in Christ Jesus before the beginning of time,
NIV

1Tim 4:16 is talking about "save thyself" in the context of sanctification. Timothy was already a justified believer. (See the chain of salvation in Rom 8:28-30). What Paul is telling his young protege that if he did all the things the apostle exhorted Timothy to do and Timothy in turn commanded others to do those things (1Tim 4:1ff), then Timothy and his hearers would be existentially ensured of his salvation -- a salvation that was started by God and will be completed by Him (Phil 1:6). In short, this was just another way of Paul expressing what he wrote in Phil 2:13, i.e. work out your salvation -- which in Timothy's case he already had.
 
a salvation that was started by God and will be completed by Him (Phil 1:6). In short, this was just another way of Paul expressing what he wrote in Phil 2:13, i.e. work out your salvation -- which in Timothy's case he already had.

Completed by him if we guard the deposit, ie, work out our salvation, ie, continue in the teachings/doctrine/faith of Christ
 
If you don't want to walk by faith and be destroyed like the saved Israelites who didn't walk by faith were, that's fine with me.

Why do you ignore Gen 3:15? (Rhetorical question,as I know why!) God saved Eve long before she walked by faith! And He saved her by his sovereign divine decree! Evidently, God was determined to save her! (And most likely without her permission.) And both of her subsequent acknowledgments of God are positive proof that whatever God has decreed in eternity will inevitably functionally manifest itself in temporal reality.
 
Completed by him if we guard the deposit, ie, work out our salvation, ie, continue in the teachings/doctrine/faith of Christ

Yes, "work out" what was God has already started for us and will complete for us. The text doesn't say "work for" our salvation.

Also, the New Covenant promises of God are unilateral, unconditional in nature. There are no conditions in any of the NC promises for any of God's chosen people to fulfill. Therefore, God's ongoing work in our sanctification in this age is not dependent on our response.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rogerg

And thank God that that receiving doesn't ultimately depend on our own corrupt volition, for the very next verse which your comrade conveniently omitted states:

John 1:13
3 children born not of natural descent
, nor of human decision or a husband's will, but born of God.
NIV
 
You need to get a good study on Jeremiah.
You have no idea how bad it was in his day.
They do not call him the "Weeping Prophet" for no reason.

You will not get it reading translations and typical commentaries.
The ones who printed them were usually too prudish.

ORDERING INFORMATION

Ask for "Jeremiah" - Series 540.

No money will be asked for.

you really don't think the same things are going on now?
 
Nope. Eternal life is a UNIQUE gift made available ONLY by the sacrifice of the Son. This is a work of REDEMPTION.

THIS gift is OFFERED and must be RECEIVED to complete the SPIRITUAL TRANSACTION.

You do grievously err.

Yes...in the same way the gift of physical life is received by ALL whose existence has been decreed by God in eternity.
 
Your core beliefs are not hidden and evident to all. You make it apparent that you simply do not believe in the Christ of the Bible.
Given that your core, foundational, belief is rotten and corrupt from bottom to top, then everything that comes out of it will be likewise

Yup, absolutely. Genez has allowed the evil one fill his mind with theological rubbish; therefore, as the old adage goes, "Garbage in, garbage out".
 
  • Like
Reactions: rogerg
You need to get a good study on Jeremiah.
You have no idea how bad it was in his day.

why does it matter what it was like in Jeremiah's day, if Jeremiah 4 is actually about a soulless race of proto-humans who were not accountable for any sin, thousands of years before Jeremiah's day, an unknowable amount of time before Genesis 1:2?
 
No of course it doesn't say to work to earn our salvation; it says to work to keep our salvation.

No, the text says nothing about "keeping" our salvation. Keeping (preserving) the saints is God's work (Jude 1, 14). You truly are ignorant of the unilateral New Covenant promises, aren't you?
 
And thank God that that receiving doesn't ultimately depend on our own corrupt volition, for the very next verse which your comrade conveniently omitted states:

John 1:13
3 children born not of natural descent
, nor of human decision or a husband's will, but born of God.
NIV
And the Verse before says God gave the right to be saved because of what God did. It's not because we created a way to be saved.

But you have taken Verse 13 out of context because everyone knows God is the one who offers the Gift of Salvation. No one said man can create a way to his own Salvation.

Verse 13 is only speaking about where Salvation comes from.

Your post literally has nothing to do with the post and conversation you quoted. You are interjecting something that the conversation is firmly aware of but not discussing because we're already aware of it.
 
No, the text says nothing about "keeping" our salvation. Keeping (preserving) the saints is God's work (Jude 1, 14). You truly are ignorant of the unilateral New Covenant promises, aren't you?

You're truly ignorant of a lot of scripture that clearly states we have to keep ourselves holy and in the faith in order to inherit eternal life.
 
And the Verse before says God gave the right to be saved because of what God did. It's not because we created a way to be saved.

But you have taken Verse 13 out of context because everyone knows God is the one who offers the Gift of Salvation. No one said man can create a way to his own Salvation.

Verse 13 is only speaking about where Salvation comes from.

Your post literally has nothing to do with the post and conversation you quoted. You are interjecting something that the conversation is firmly aware of but not discussing because we're already aware of it.

Verse 13 is extremely relevant to the preceding verse. First of all God gave the right as opposed to anyone having an inalienable right to become children of God! We ultimately become "children of God" by the new birth which has nothing to do with human decision-making! V. 13 actually qualifies v. 12! (See also Jn 3:1-15.) Tell me: Was Issac's birth a natural or supernatural birth? Who decreed Issac's birth: Abraham, Sarah, God or all three? :rolleyes:

Also, it's God who qualifies his elect to share in his inheritance (Col 1:12). No saint ever qualified him or herself!

If you were so "firmly aware" of these truths I just wrote, you wouldn't have written the garbage you did.
 
You're truly ignorant of a lot of scripture that clearly states we have to keep ourselves holy and in the faith in order to inherit eternal life.

Jude 1 & 24 don't for starters. So, give me chapter and verse proof that the responsibility persevering in the faith falls on the saints. AND....prove this also from any of the New Covenant promises -- promises to which you appear to be estranged from. Also, you might want to take note of someday that the divine work described in Rom 8:28-29 (chain of salvation) rests entirely on God. Reaching the final phase of salvation (Glorification) ultimately falls on God, not on any of his saints.
 
I graciously accept your surrender.
I am constantly amazed at your lack of understanding. Do you not even try to understand? How could any one person get things wrong every single time? I guess the odds are just against you.
Makes me wonder if you have ever actually read scripture. Titus 3:5-7 talks about the grace of God and the Holy Spirit being poured out on us abundantly through Jesus Christ our Savior, 7 that having been justified by His grace we should become heirs according to the hope of eternal life.

Maybe you were working on your umbrella that day!
 
Jude 1 & 24 don't for starters. So, give me chapter and verse proof that the responsibility persevering in the faith falls on the saints. AND....prove this also from any of the New Covenant promises -- promises to which you appear to be estranged from. Also, you might want to take note of someday that the divine work described in Rom 8:28-29 (chain of salvation) rests entirely on God. Reaching the final phase of salvation (Glorification) ultimately falls on God, not on any of his saints.

I'm not interested in proving anything to hardheads. If you can't hear what's plainly written, you won't hear it from me either.