House of David

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

JohnDB

Well-known member
Jan 16, 2021
6,446
2,660
113
#1
House of David is a movie series on Prime Video.

And many in my SS class have been caught up watching this movie series to watch David kill Goliath.

And I wanted your opinion about this.

After watching the first episode I already have opinions forming. I just wanted a forum to discuss this with those who also have seen this.
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
28,759
10,311
113
#2
The book is usually WAY different from the movie. Like, with Jurassic Park, in the book John Hammond dies, like that spoiled brat should have. :p

In the book David doesn't get hit by a spear. In the book David is not some kind of ninja. In the book Jonathan does not have to stop one of David's own brothers from shooting him.
 

ocean

Active member
Oct 15, 2024
420
213
43
#3
There is a disclaimer before the video begins (for every episode) that the story line has taken liberties from the biblical account. We all have opinions. I for one, do not think they did a very good job representing David with the person they choose.
 

Daisy2

Active member
Jan 31, 2025
114
51
28
#4
House of David is a movie series on Prime Video.

And many in my SS class have been caught up watching this movie series to watch David kill Goliath.

And I wanted your opinion about this.

After watching the first episode I already have opinions forming. I just wanted a forum to discuss this with those who also have seen this.
Modern movies often get the historical facts of the bible wrong even older movies aren't complete biblically correct. Hollywood probably does it on purpose but if it get them thinking about God and is not overly violent it's probably a good idea to encourage it.
 

Eli1

Well-known member
Apr 5, 2022
6,489
2,881
113
47
#5
Is this like The Chosen?
I haven't seen it but if i have time, i will watch it.
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
28,759
10,311
113
#6
There is a disclaimer before the video begins (for every episode) that the story line has taken liberties from the biblical account. We all have opinions. I for one, do not think they did a very good job representing David with the person they choose.
Reminds me of that reporter who found the lady on whose life "The Sound Of Music" was based. He asked her what she thought of the movie.

"It's a nice story. But it's not MY story."

If it's not fact, it's fiction. If it's fiction, you might as well go play a Japanese role playing game that has a few elements borrowed from Chinese mythology, a little bit of the Hindu pantheon and the main character lives in a town behind the Pearly Gates. It's all just a story.
 

JohnDB

Well-known member
Jan 16, 2021
6,446
2,660
113
#7
David,
Outside of Jesus, is one of the most described people in scriptures. Everything from appearance to attitudes and personality.

It amazes me how wrong they can get the guy. It's a wonder they all aren't speaking Elizabethan era English.
They spent a lot of money but somehow skipped the $20 for the hair dye for David?

Jesse, somehow, must have had his own Torah scroll. That part is a key fact missing from the movie. But completely evident with every Psalm David wrote. (Which David sang to the sheep all day every day he was shepherding)
David was as quick as greased lightning. And he had things he was quick tempered about. His Father Jesse would have been considered a wealthy man. The big sons would have helped make his farm a success. (Where was the farm?) David, being so young and small, wouldn't be allowed to farm but instead be the shepherd. David wasn't afraid of lions, bears, or wolves....he hunted them for sport and taunted them. The sheep he used as bait. Definitely not mild mannered or full of self doubt. When David was under duress he clung tighter to the LAW than when he wasn't under such stress.

And Samuel?
He could have given master classes in sarcasm and dry wit. He never had difficulty hearing God...and when he spoke he knew beyond all doubt he carried God's full might, power, and authority with him. He, like the books of Samuel 1&2, makes you feel stupid for not having faith in God.
His treatment of Saul is no different. He should be more angry and scolding.
Samuel is and should be used for comedic relief in the story line.

Saul should be whining more...more fearful....more paranoid. Not so crazy.

Also....this is a patriarchal and Caste-based society. Judah was a very small tribe at this time. But they would at least have known that their tribe was to be the leadership of Israel. Granted, one look at Eli and his sons....and it's a wonder that the people knew they had a God.
And if they did not prosecute Eli's sons for sleeping around....much less Saul's extra son.
The women aren't like today's women. They wanted children. They were desperate for them ALWAYS. They have a son and all is great in their world...children were their retirement plan. (Which requires sex) Most marriage contracts were written in such a way as to obligate the men for sex....the women always wanted more but the men were only required to provide what was in the Ketubah. (They wanted kids....the more the better)
 

ocean

Active member
Oct 15, 2024
420
213
43
#8
Reminds me of that reporter who found the lady on whose life "The Sound Of Music" was based. He asked her what she thought of the movie.

"It's a nice story. But it's not MY story."

If it's not fact, it's fiction. If it's fiction, you might as well go play a Japanese role playing game that has a few elements borrowed from Chinese mythology, a little bit of the Hindu pantheon and the main character lives in a town behind the Pearly Gates. It's all just a story.
My point being they state up front it is not biblically accurate.
 

JohnDB

Well-known member
Jan 16, 2021
6,446
2,660
113
#9
My point being they state up front it is not biblically accurate.
And I have to ask their reasoning behind why not make it more biblically accurate?

The elements of a great story are there.
All of them.

Where do you think all the great stories retold over and over (albeit different characters) come from?

They did a disservice to themselves and scriptures for not retelling the story accurately...

The original story with accurate elements is precisely what would sell as any modern story does today. It has obvious idiots, humor, heroes, villains, and inspiring moments. The Critical Drinker goes over the basic formulas for stories regularly and wonders how Hollywood messes them up so spectacularly. Especially when so much money is at stake.

This is no different.

IF it was accurately retold with truth, anthropology that made sense, and believable characters....it would have resulted in a small budget series punching well beyond its weight class. (Blair Witch Project)

The scriptures are filled with stories the authors were desperate to retell because they felt they were of premium importance. Others died willingly to protect and advocate for these collections of stories. The streets of Israel were literally flowing with human blood repeatedly over these stories...because they are inspiring.

Opportunity wasted. What a shame.
 

ocean

Active member
Oct 15, 2024
420
213
43
#10
And I have to ask their reasoning behind why not make it more biblically accurate?

The elements of a great story are there.
All of them.

Where do you think all the great stories retold over and over (albeit different characters) come from?

They did a disservice to themselves and scriptures for not retelling the story accurately...

The original story with accurate elements is precisely what would sell as any modern story does today. It has obvious idiots, humor, heroes, villains, and inspiring moments. The Critical Drinker goes over the basic formulas for stories regularly and wonders how Hollywood messes them up so spectacularly. Especially when so much money is at stake.

This is no different.

IF it was accurately retold with truth, anthropology that made sense, and believable characters....it would have resulted in a small budget series punching well beyond its weight class. (Blair Witch Project)

The scriptures are filled with stories the authors were desperate to retell because they felt they were of premium importance. Others died willingly to protect and advocate for these collections of stories. The streets of Israel were literally flowing with human blood repeatedly over these stories...because they are inspiring.

Opportunity wasted. What a shame.

If you have to ask why, then I will assume you want to discuss motives. I am actually far less concerned with a film maker's why than I am with believer's whys within the context of choosing what to believe or re-translating according to an opinion.

note: I am not referencing you above; I don't know you
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
28,759
10,311
113
#11
My point being they state up front it is not biblically accurate.
Exactly!

If they took such liberties that it is complete fiction, what's the point of even watching it? I can see a lot of fiction, most of it far more interesting.
 

JohnDB

Well-known member
Jan 16, 2021
6,446
2,660
113
#12
Exactly!

If they took such liberties that it is complete fiction, what's the point of even watching it? I can see a lot of fiction, most of it far more interesting.
Agree completely....

The director has destroyed the story and remade the characters....
To what purpose?
It's no longer a true story or an interesting one. The ONLY reason to watch it is to see David kill Goliath.
That's it....
The rest of the story they created out of whole cloth is boring and uninteresting. It's really sucks.

However, if they had actually stuck to the story the Bible tells....it would have been heralded by most Christians and viewed by heathen to see what the fuss is about.

But that would require someone to read the bible instead of the Talmud (which is where much of the inspiration for this movie came from...which was a very bad idea in this instance)
 
Oct 15, 2024
420
213
43
#13
Exactly!

If they took such liberties that it is complete fiction, what's the point of even watching it? I can see a lot of fiction, most of it far more interesting.
well my husband and I are watching it; or were watching it cause the 1st season is over with the killing of the giant

call it entertainment cause that is basically what it is with some biblical references/liberty to assume. it's quite the production though. I have not watched The Chosen at all.