To explain the existence of this thread:
- Burn said another thread was lame.
- I said Burn was free to start a thread he thought was better.
- Burn started this thread.
Burn1986 you didn't lay any groundwork at all for this thread, though. The first post is supposed to set the tone and parameters of the discussion at hand. In this case, since this is a "should we do this" thread, the first post should have at least put forth some pros and cons, maybe a single anecdote for either side, and your own reasons for believing we should be on one side or the other of the topic question.
So no, this is not a better thread than the one you said was lame. This is a pretty lazy thread. Much lamer than that other thread.