Did Jesus Die on The Cross for The Just/Elect/Saved Whose Names Are Written in The Book of Life OR

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Jun 30, 2024
12
15
3
I identified with what you came out of. I was a 60's till late 60's musician. Quit the business after I unknowingly became born again.

One thing I would like to say. "Late Great Planet Earth" was hugely popular, though I never read it back then.

Later on after finding my pastor teacher? I learned that Hal was a member of my church, and had attended before I became a member.

Hal had applied to Dallas Theological Seminary and was found initially not to qualify.
My pastor after finding out wrote a letter to DTS, and Hal was then accepted.
Same thing occurred with Chuck Swindoll, whom my pastor needed to write DTS, and was then accepted.

Late Great Planet Earth was found in the room of one of Israel's prime ministers after his death. I can not locate which one at this time, but had seen Hals Lindsey mention it in the past.

To make a long story short. Late Great Planet earth had its roots in Hal Lindsey gaining access to his pastor's thesis when he was working on towards his doctorate. It was never finished because pastor R.B. Thieme Jr became much too busy studying eight hours a day and teaching six nights a week to his avid congregation, and not to mention, an audio ministry that boomed world wide.

R.B. Thieme later was a wee bit upset with some things Hal said in his book because of some of Hal's speculations at times. And, RBT did not like that you could not get the book without paying money for it. Other than that? Hal mentions R.B. Thieme in several of his books.

In the Devil's world you will not get great reviews of someone doing an excellent work of exegeting God's Word from the original languages. Its expected to be lied about. Be that as it may. RBT's daily messages have been recorded and are available free of charge for anyone wanting to learn the Scriptures from the original languages.

I just remembered another.

Billy Graham once asked RBT to privately mentor him. But, RBT was so busy with his own church he had to turn Billy Graham down.
Yet, later I am sure, Billy was able to access the recorded messages if he wanted them.

No money asked for. Will send teaching messages free of charge. https://rbthieme.org/index.html#tabs-3

We are caught right smack dab in the middle of a spiritual warfare.
Therefore.. misinformation will abound along with truth.
One must find out for himself.

grace and peace ....................
Great testimony!
 
Jun 30, 2024
12
15
3
I've been reading through some of your discussions today and yesterday. Well done good and faithful servants!
 

PaulThomson

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2023
3,505
468
83
without faith, it is impossible to please God.

buut i suppose we humans think we have all sorts of power we do not possess.
The scripture does not say that without faith in the gospel, nor dors it say that without faith in Jesus Christ, it is impossible to please God. Clearly those listed in Hebrews were ignorant of the NT gospel and thd life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ snd yet pleased God with faith.
 

PaulThomson

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2023
3,505
468
83
Just because some people believe and assert St. Augustine's view does not mean he was correct, he saw himself as a complete degenerate and read that into scripture.

Natural man whose spirit is not connected to God, he is separated (dead) by the consequences of the fall.
Natural does not mean evil and Paul is not juxtaposing sinner versus saint in his letter to the Corinthians.
The Calvinist view is way out of line with the intent of the letter, the distinction is between “human wisdom” and “divine revelation.”

It is, of course, quite common to hear the view that the “natural” man is the unregenerated sinner who is so enslaved in sin as to be unable to apprehend the gospel of God unless “illuminated” by a direct operation of the Holy Spirit.The sad reality is, it is difficult to locate many scholars who have not been tainted with Calvin’s views of this matter (cf. Institutes of the Christian Religion, Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1975, Vol. I, Bk. II, 19-20)
Augustine was a good Manachaean gnostic dressed in Christian rhetoric. He considered the physical evil and considered that having the right metaphysical propositions, i.e. the right gnosis, was what saves.
 

PaulThomson

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2023
3,505
468
83
So true! Like all those who believe that the natural man's will is free to choose to believe prior to being made alive in Christ. Especially given the fact that according to the explicit teaching of Scripture, his will is taken captive by the devil and he is hostile in his mind toward God.
Where do you see a link in scripture between those who believe a man's will is free, and those who have been taken captive by the devil and those who are hostile in mind towards God.

Surely, to be "taken captive" one must first be free, as Paul in Romans 7 says he was, before sin took him captive thriugh the law. You can't take captive someone who is allegedly already your child and your captive at conception.
 

Genez

Junior Member
Oct 12, 2017
3,450
539
113
Its amazing to me...

That there are so many, who freely choose to believe, we do not have free will.
 

PaulThomson

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2023
3,505
468
83
Ok... so you were born spiritually alive having a human spirit. That is your belief?
Yes. That is what Paul teaches in Romans 7.
"I was alive without the law once. But when the law came, sin came to life, and I died."
 

Genez

Junior Member
Oct 12, 2017
3,450
539
113
Now, you're beginning to grasp the biblical concept of "captives" or "prisoners". We are indeed trapped in our Dead souls, sir! Why do you think God promised to give his people a new heart under the New Covenant? Why did Paul say that believers were formerly Darkness itself!?

It's time to wake up and smell the coffee!
We were not trapped in our dead souls.
We were dead souls.
You are your soul.

What was the trap?
The fallen flesh that soul was wrapped in.

:unsure: .... Beginning to grasp? Now?
Where you been?
 

Rufus

Well-known member
Feb 17, 2024
3,059
415
83
I identified with what you came out of. I was a 60's till late 60's musician. Quit the business after I unknowingly became born again.

One thing I would like to say. "Late Great Planet Earth" was hugely popular, though I never read it back then.

Later on after finding my pastor teacher? I learned that Hal was a member of my church, and had attended before I became a member.

Hal had applied to Dallas Theological Seminary and was found initially not to qualify.
My pastor after finding out wrote a letter to DTS, and Hal was then accepted.
Same thing occurred with Chuck Swindoll, whom my pastor needed to write DTS, and was then accepted.

Late Great Planet Earth was found in the room of one of Israel's prime ministers after his death. I can not locate which one at this time, but had seen Hals Lindsey mention it in the past.

To make a long story short. Late Great Planet earth had its roots in Hal Lindsey gaining access to his pastor's thesis when he was working on towards his doctorate. It was never finished because pastor R.B. Thieme Jr became much too busy studying eight hours a day and teaching six nights a week to his avid congregation, and not to mention, an audio ministry that boomed world wide.

R.B. Thieme later was a wee bit upset with some things Hal said in his book because of some of Hal's speculations at times. And, RBT did not like that you could not get the book without paying money for it. Other than that? Hal mentions R.B. Thieme in several of his books.

In the Devil's world you will not get great reviews of someone doing an excellent work of exegeting God's Word from the original languages. Its expected to be lied about. Be that as it may. RBT's daily messages have been recorded and are available free of charge for anyone wanting to learn the Scriptures from the original languages.

I just remembered another.

Billy Graham once asked RBT to privately mentor him. But, RBT was so busy with his own church he had to turn Billy Graham down.
Yet, later , I am sure, Billy was able to access the recorded messages if he wanted them.

No money asked for. Will send teaching messages free of charge. https://rbthieme.org/index.html#tabs-3

We are caught right smack dab in the middle of a spiritual warfare.
Therefore.. misinformation will abound along with truth.
One must find out for himself.

grace and peace ....................
Interesting story. And the megabytes of irony with HL's documentary and book is that about a year after my conversion, I disavowed Historic Premillennialism and it's extreme cousin Dispensationalism. But it goes to show how how an infinitely wise God can even use error to bring someone to himself. So, I'm naturally hoping to see HL in heaven. Want to thank him personally. :)
 

Rufus

Well-known member
Feb 17, 2024
3,059
415
83
Yes. That is what Paul teaches in Romans 7.
"I was alive without the law once. But when the law came, sin came to life, and I died."
You totally miss Paul's point. Plus he'd be contradicting himself with other passages.
 

Rufus

Well-known member
Feb 17, 2024
3,059
415
83
The scripture does not say that without faith in the gospel, nor dors it say that without faith in Jesus Christ, it is impossible to please God. Clearly those listed in Hebrews were ignorant of the NT gospel and thd life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ snd yet pleased God with faith.
But the OT saints preached the gospel, such as Noah. The OT saints' faith was in the promised Messiah insofar as that was revealed to them by God. That promise began in Gen 3:15.
 

Cameron143

Well-known member
Mar 1, 2022
20,080
6,883
113
62
The scripture does not say that without faith in the gospel, nor dors it say that without faith in Jesus Christ, it is impossible to please God. Clearly those listed in Hebrews were ignorant of the NT gospel and thd life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ snd yet pleased God with faith.
Jesus said Abraham rejoiced to see His day and saw it.
Who do you suppose Abraham talked and met with during His lifetime?
 

PaulThomson

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2023
3,505
468
83
Mr. Studer, Sir, I have a question for you. You claim that the spiritually dead -- the natural man has sufficient natural understanding to do understand that which is not natural -- but spiritual? Is that right? But how can this be since God-hating dead people don't seek after spiritual understanding?
You are straw-manning. You are citing others, but are inserting your erroneous and unbiblical definitions of their words into their statements, instead if applying their own biblical definitions of their own words into their statements. If you disagree that someone's definition is unbiblical, you need to offer a persuasive argument for your own definition, and not just declare your definition biblically-based on your presumption of your having some divinely imparted gnosis.
 

HeIsHere

Well-known member
May 21, 2022
6,339
2,465
113
But Paul said there was no good thing in his flesh. And Jesus clearly taught that no mere mortal is good -- but only God alone. So, if no human being is intrinsically good, then this can only mean he's evil; for there is no middle ground between Good and Evil.
Where did I state a human is intrinsically good?
 

PaulThomson

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2023
3,505
468
83
But the OT saints preached the gospel, such as Noah. The OT saints' faith was in the promised Messiah insofar as that was revealed to them by God. That promise began in Gen 3:15.
Correct. The faith required and which pleases God is accordong to yhe light one has. The objects of faith required of unreached tribes in jungles is not the same as the objects God requires one who has the old testament to believe. And God is pleased with faith in a broader range objects if one has heard the full gospel.
 

Cameron143

Well-known member
Mar 1, 2022
20,080
6,883
113
62
The scripture does not say that without faith in the gospel, nor dors it say that without faith in Jesus Christ, it is impossible to please God. Clearly those listed in Hebrews were ignorant of the NT gospel and thd life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ snd yet pleased God with faith.
There is no relationship with God apart from Christ. There is one mediator between God and man...the man Christ Jesus. And no one knows the Father except the Son and those He reveals Him to.
 

Genez

Junior Member
Oct 12, 2017
3,450
539
113
Yes. That is what Paul teaches in Romans 7.
"I was alive without the law once. But when the law came, sin came to life, and I died."
We need more context here, please.

What shall we say, then? Is the law sinful? Certainly not! Nevertheless, I would not have known
what sin was had it not been for the law. For I would not have known what coveting really was
if the law had not said, “You shall not covet.”


But sin, seizing the opportunity afforded by the commandment, produced in me every kind of coveting.
For apart from the law, sin was dead.


Once I was alive apart from the law; but when the commandment came, sin sprang to life and I died.
I found that the very commandment that was intended to bring life actually brought death.


Romans 7:7-10


Paul, while alive as a human, while he did not know the law?
At that time he was yet dead to the law.
While dead to the law? He did not know what sin was.

But when the Law was learned by him?
His old (carefree) life had died.
For the Law and the knowledge of sin produced what in Paul?
It had killed his ability to be living his old carefree life!
Hence? ... "He died!"

grace and peace .......
 

Rufus

Well-known member
Feb 17, 2024
3,059
415
83
I really haven't ignored much of anything, no matter how unbiblical it is, until I've seen how impossible it is to discuss actual Scripture in context.

I have begun to ignore some of your writing. I'm ignoring what you say after this above statement. You don't seem to realize that at some point of watching you ignore Scripture, it just becomes monotonous. I'm resolved for you to end up seeing my discussing Scripture in the same way.

Don't feel singled-out. I'm beginning to ignore some others also. When someone starts telling me I don't know God because I might not ask Him to charge, or replace, or miraculously resolve my dead car-battery issue, it's coming to be time to move on. When I was a pup I unknowingly tried and presumed upon God many times in many ways. He's taught me experientially and through His Word and/namely Spirit how to relate to Him. I work with Him daily to grow in that relationship and in understanding His Word.

Honestly, I laid out some very basic definitions and observations from several verses in Rom1 that I read as putting your argument to shame. All you have to do is look at each verse and tell me where I'm wrong in the definitions I pulled from one of the best Lexical resources we have. I'm prepared to discuss Scripture with you about faith or any important topic we both - mutually - care to discuss. But it must be a discussion about actual Scripture and the words God has used to speak to us.

My concern is that you seem to have no appreciation for God's ability to provide for and work with fallen human nature. He can create a universe and breath life into a pile of dirt and minerals. He can raise people from the dead and provide an entirely new race of human being in the process of becoming what we can barely begin to comprehend. Yet, if we listen to your thinking, He is unable to get into the mind and soul of a spiritually dead, but living human being, what He wants that being to fully understand and to choose to accept or reject. It makes no sense whatsoever.

The Word of God is our standard. None of our opinions are. This should be a discussion to get to the meaning of actual Scripture without having to wade through one another's sometimes bizarre analogies with mind-boggling proof-texting that are supposed to be accepted without even cautious hesitation. Simply put, you're posting to the wrong person if you think I'll accept your methodology and the error I see that comes from it.

It's the Text, Rufus. It's called the "canon" (kanōn) for a reason.
Shirely U. Jest. I have all the appreciation in the world! Besides, the bible tells us how God works with fallen human nature: It's called Resurrection or the New Birth. You should read the bible of which you boast you understand so well and learn about these two concepts and then explain to me how men can restore spiritual life to their own souls. Perhaps you can find for us a passage somewhere that teaches that mortal men have the power to raise the physically dead. Now...if you found something like that that would bring much credibility to your false gospel. I would be able to reason, then, that if mere mortals can do that, then maybe we can raise ourselves spiritually and reconnect with the Life of God. But anything short of this then I'm supposed to believe that there is such an animal on this planet as a free slave, and just conveniently ignore the fact that such an absurd notion violates the Law of Noncontradiction. And if that weren't bad enough, then I'd also have believe that an all-wise God was really sloppy in his metaphors. Why use "death" if natural man suffered a mere flesh wound from which he could heal himself? :rolleyes:
 

Rufus

Well-known member
Feb 17, 2024
3,059
415
83
The natural man is stuck in that he leaves himself with nothing but the choice between accepting Christ's death for himself or death for himself. And it is God's grace that man has, indeed, been left with that choice -- a choice that can only be made by God's grace.
FTFY.
 

HeIsHere

Well-known member
May 21, 2022
6,339
2,465
113
Its amazing to me...

That there are so many, who freely choose to believe, we do not have free will.
:D

Have you not heard, all men became automaton's at the fall, not only are they completely and utterly programmed,
they are devoid of rational thought,
love,
compassion,
ability to make moral choices,
ability to reason,
ability to respond to the Gospel truth.

No, no we can't have that, the Gospel is now a gnostic enterprise, only for the special illuminated