God and Time

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

posthuman

Senior Member
Jul 31, 2013
37,727
13,522
113
#21
You speculate, "
God is not limited by time in either sense, but chooses to operate in the time frame He created."

And then you declaim speculation as a waste if time.

Funny!
that nothing can constrain God is not speculation, because it is written, for Him nothing is impossible. neither is it that He chooses to operate in the framework of the universe He created, because it is clearly seen that we wait for Him now; that just as He appeared at just the right time, He will also return at exactly that time which is perfect.

the difference between speculation and inference is incontrovertible evidence and clear logic, as opposed to things we cannot fully understand & so cannot fully justify.

we do not understand time. in this universe it seems inescapable, fundamental, but it also cannot be touched or measured directly - we derive it from the apparent changes in the relative positions of all the matter and energy of the universe, but we don't independently observe it, outside of motion - that is, outside of a differential between two observed arrangements of matter. we can't perceive the difference between physical motionlessness and timelessness.

So what can we say about God and time based on what we can see?
we know He speaks of the future as though it is already the past ((Isaiah 46:10, Romans 4:17)) and we know He does His works in time, even though He finished them before He made the world ((Hebrews 9:26, Revelation 13:8)) - are these opposing one another? they may seem to be, but they cannot be, because He is God. so they are a mystery, yet to be shown to us. God is both wholly separate from time ((He is therefore not equal to time)) and it is His pleasure to do His will in time - while that will is also done as though it is itself not in time at all but eternal.

"His arm is not shortened" - He is not rendered incapable of action by being independent of time. He reveals Himself and His work to us using time, and that person and that work He reveals, are operating both throughought and without time.

in the same way, Paul, He is independent of space, for the Word says both "nothing is hidden from Him" and "seek Him while He may be found"
 

montana123

Well-known member
Oct 9, 2021
852
286
63
#24
An interesting philosophical concept to consider is the notion of God’s relationship to time. Many Christian are quick to claim that God is not subject to time. This view is known as atemporalism. At first glance, this view seems sound as it affirms God’s immutability, highlights God’s omniscience and seeks to exalt God as one who sits over the constraints of time.

However, there are some serious concerns with this view. First, if this view is correct, God exists in a constant state of stasis. Everything would be a frozen present to God. Thus, creation, redemption and recreation would all be simultaneous events for God. In fact, it would call into question the very concept of God creating the world ex nihilo. For, how could God create the universe which had not previously existed if, for God, there could never be a first moment of creation. Second, the biblical notion that God became flesh would also be called into question as, there would never be a moment for God when God was not Jesus of Nazareth. Finally, this notion would cause us to reconsider God’s interactions with humanity we see in Scripture that is replete with warnings, answered prayers, forgiveness, anger, love and other acts which indicate God is responding and interacting with humanity based on human actions in time. This view is also popular among Calvinists as they use this philosophical notion as justification for God‘s predetermination of the elect and damned based on his sovereign declaration rather than human response. It would only make sense that if everything is a frozen constant to God, then the moment of creation would also be the moment of salvation. God knowing everything prior to creation would have created the world in such a way as to have predetermined all outcomes.

A second view on God‘s relationship with time is temporalism. This view suggests that God exists in time. In the same way humans are subject to time, so is God. Yet for God, his past is infinite as well as his future. In some ways, this fits many of the Biblical descriptions of God’s interaction with time as he is referred to as one who is “from everlasting to everlasting,” “the first and the last,“ and “before all time and now and forever“ (Jude 25). This is not to say that God is subject to time, as if he is inferior to time itself. Rather, that time is part of God’s essence or being. Theologians from this view hold a range of different theological positions from Reformed theologians, Arminians and openness theologians.

A third view would argue that God is metatemporal. Similar to the temporal view, this view claims that God does exist in time. However, God does stand outside the human timeline. This view holds that there is created time and uncreated time. God stands outside the created timeline of the universe he made, but still exists in his own time which is part of his very essence. Thus, God does interact with humanity based on the flow of time and God, himself, along with his thoughts and actions do have a past, present and future. So the encounters with humanity along time are not merely anthropomorphic as atemporalists would argue, but are genuine responses to past and present actions.

What are your thoughts about God and time? I am interesting in discussing your thoughts and their implications on how we understand the teachings of Scripture.
Rev 10:5 And the angel which I saw stand upon the sea and upon the earth lifted up his hand to heaven,
Rev 10:6 And sware by him that liveth for ever and ever, who created heaven, and the things that therein are, and the earth, and the things that therein are, and the sea, and the things which are therein,

that there should be time no longer.

There is no such thing as time for it does not exist, and time is not a universal principle, but it is a temporary measurement that applies to the creation concerning mankind.

Before the creation there is no time for all things go on the same with nothing to be scheduled.

Time only applies to the creation as a measurement tool for things are scheduled concerning God's schedule, and the things that people schedule.

And the sun is the measuring tool that measures a day, and then we break it down to hours, minutes, and seconds, and build it up to weeks, months, and years.

When the saints are at the New Jerusalem there will be no time for all things go on the same, and there is nothing to be scheduled.

Time is not a universal principle but only used for the creation as a measuring tool, and then will not be needed anymore.

The sun is the measuring tool for time but the sun will pass away for at the New Jerusalem the sun will be gone.

Time is a creation like all creation and will pass away like all creation for time is not a universal principle, so it has no bearing on anything apart from the creation for it does not exist.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
59,815
29,194
113
#25
When the saints are at the New Jerusalem there will be no time for all things go on the same, and there is nothing to be scheduled.
The city has no need of sun or moon to shine on it, because the glory of God illuminates the city,
and the Lamb is its lamp. By its light the nations will walk, and into it the kings of the earth will
bring their glory. Its gates will never be shut at the end of the day, because there will be no night there.


And into the city will be brought the glory and honor of the nations. From Rev 21. Sounds like time passing to me...
 

maxwel

Senior Member
Apr 18, 2013
9,526
2,608
113
#26
that nothing can constrain God is not speculation, because it is written, for Him nothing is impossible. neither is it that He chooses to operate in the framework of the universe He created, because it is clearly seen that we wait for Him now; that just as He appeared at just the right time, He will also return at exactly that time which is perfect.

the difference between speculation and inference is incontrovertible evidence and clear logic, as opposed to things we cannot fully understand & so cannot fully justify.

we do not understand time. in this universe it seems inescapable, fundamental, but it also cannot be touched or measured directly - we derive it from the apparent changes in the relative positions of all the matter and energy of the universe, but we don't independently observe it, outside of motion - that is, outside of a differential between two observed arrangements of matter. we can't perceive the difference between physical motionlessness and timelessness.

So what can we say about God and time based on what we can see?
we know He speaks of the future as though it is already the past ((Isaiah 46:10, Romans 4:17)) and we know He does His works in time, even though He finished them before He made the world ((Hebrews 9:26, Revelation 13:8)) - are these opposing one another? they may seem to be, but they cannot be, because He is God. so they are a mystery, yet to be shown to us. God is both wholly separate from time ((He is therefore not equal to time)) and it is His pleasure to do His will in time - while that will is also done as though it is itself not in time at all but eternal.

"His arm is not shortened" - He is not rendered incapable of action by being independent of time. He reveals Himself and His work to us using time, and that person and that work He reveals, are operating both throughought and without time.

in the same way, Paul, He is independent of space, for the Word says both "nothing is hidden from Him" and "seek Him while He may be found"
Omniscience & Foreordination are sufficient to account for all of God's statements about the future.

We should be very careful when we look at God speaking of his omniscience and foreordination, and reading into that some necessity for God to break with the normal temporal order. As this is not a logical necessity, and is not required by the text.

God's omniscience and providence are enough to account for every statement he makes about the future.

.
 

Dino246

Senior Member
Jun 30, 2015
25,369
13,729
113
#27
You speculate, "
God is not limited by time in either sense, but chooses to operate in the time frame He created."

And then you declaim speculation as a waste if time.

Funny!
Glad I could provide you with some entertainment.

However... are you sure my statement was speculative?
 

PaulThomson

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2023
3,467
451
83
#28
Glad I could provide you with some entertainment.

However... are you sure my statement was speculative?
Yes. What is your proof that God is not limited by time ,in the same way He is not limited by love or Justice. What is your proof that God is not by nature spatial and temporal?
 

PaulThomson

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2023
3,467
451
83
#29
No. My body is not spirit. But God's spirit could fill all space, not just in our continuum but in all continua. All things whatsoever could exist within, but distinct from, the greater infinite pace of God's body.
 

PaulThomson

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2023
3,467
451
83
#30
So, your claim that God is not constrained by time is merely speculative. God could be constrained by time in the same way that He is constrained by love and truth. Not because the time he experiences is something other that Himself to which He is subject, but because it is something that He is by nature: loving, truthful and temporal.
 

PaulThomson

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2023
3,467
451
83
#31
God created time . He’s eternal without beginning or end . Time is part of creation it’s a measurement of the earths revolutions around the sun.
God created the sun, moon and stars as sign and to measure the passage of time that was already in play. Scripture does not say anywhere that God created time itself.
 

Cameron143

Well-known member
Mar 1, 2022
18,893
6,488
113
62
#33
No. My body is not spirit. But God's spirit could fill all space, not just in our continuum but in all continua. All things whatsoever could exist within, but distinct from, the greater infinite pace of God's body.
Spirit isn't corporeal.
 

Pilgrimshope

Well-known member
Sep 2, 2020
13,885
5,630
113
#36
God created the sun, moon and stars as sign and to measure the passage of time that was already in play. Scripture does not say anywhere that God created time itself.
Ok
 

Cameron143

Well-known member
Mar 1, 2022
18,893
6,488
113
62
#37
Do you have a scripture that says spirit isn't corporeal, or is that speculative? BTW, I'm not saying spirit is the body. it inhabits
I don't know of any scripture that says specifically. But it does distinguish between flesh and spirit. Also, when Jesus died, His body was laid in the tomb, but He commended His Spirit to God.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
59,815
29,194
113
#38
So, your claim that God is not constrained by time is merely speculative. God could be constrained by time in the same way that He is constrained by love and truth. Not because the time he experiences is something other that Himself to which He is subject, but because it is something that He is by nature: loving, truthful and temporal.
God is temporal in your view? Yikes.

temporal
ADJECTIVE
  1. of or relating to time as opposed to eternity
    of or relating to earthly life
 

Dino246

Senior Member
Jun 30, 2015
25,369
13,729
113
#39
Yes. What is your proof that God is not limited by time ,in the same way He is not limited by love or Justice. What is your proof that God is not by nature spatial and temporal?
Scripture.
 

Chaps

Active member
Apr 3, 2024
307
114
43
California
#40
I don't know if you're reading someone else's points here because it seems to me that you're new at this but it's a fun subject nonetheless.

The "Challanges" that you posted are ideas that you have in your mind so they're your challenges not my challenges.
Because again you're missing the point of the fish-bowl where we will have concepts and language barriers when trying to describe anything outside of our own experience in this universe.

I don't know if you've studied this enough to consider the following:

* What we perceive as "Time" may not be time at all. We are biological beings and the whole universe is in a constant state of change. This change may be perceived as time for us for many practical reasons including survival.
* If time does truly exist and flows like a river, you still have no idea what kind of physics you're dealing with outside of this universe to even call a concept like Time and label it "Time" as we experience it. So you need new language, concepts and physics.

So if we can't understand what Time is, how can you even ask a question about a frozen Creator interacting with a moving object like us? Especially since the Creator created what we perceive as time.
Have you really looked into the concept of time at all? Because i have seen several documentaries by very bright physicist and no one has any idea what Time is.
I dont know what you mean by me being “new to this” or that I haven’t “really looked into the concept of time at all.” I’m not sure if thats just your way of suggesting I sound silly or that you know a lot more than me. I’m more than happy to learn, but I guess you’ll need to do more than point to some random documentaries you watched on tv once.

I am more than happy to admit a fair amount of naïveté on this subject, however, I dont think the categories I listed come from sources that are unfamiliar with the subject. Atemporalism is a view held by proponents such as Plato, Plotinus, Augustine, Boethius, Anselm, Thomas Aquinas, Paul Helm and Norman Geisler. Temporalism is held by proponents such as William Ockholm, Oscar Cullman, Nicholas Wolterstoff, Steven Davis, Clark Pinnock, John Feinberg and others.

So, I just write that to say that a lot of literature has been written on the topic, so it’s not like I am the first one to ponder it or come up with these categories. Also I think it’s not really an answer to just say that “we can’t understand what Time is” and dismiss the subject altogether. While we may still be figuring time out from a physics perspective, from a philosophical perspective we can understand enough to discuss the reproductions of God acting within the framework of a past, present or future, or God being sovereign over time such that past, present and future do not apply to Him.

I guess I would surmise by saying that it’s fine if you dont feel there is value in the discussion, but clearly this has been a topic discussed for millennia and is still discussed today among philosophers and theologians. I dont think me bringing it up or discussing the challenges with different views (that are not my own challenges by the way but debates philosophers have posed for hundreds, if not thousands of years).

Anyway, I was just looking for an interesting discussion and thoughts on these views. I just dont see the need to make it sound like it’s silly to have questions about different views or that a varying opinion means someone is ignorant.