I don't disagree with your overall conclusion. But as recently as 2020 the UAE and Bahrain signed treaties. And Saudi Arabia was just about to.
Abraham Accords:
The Abraham Accords were certainly a thing, but:
1.) They represented a very small percentage of the Arab nations.
2.) They didn't generate any "love" in the Arab world... just some "tolerance" in a couple of places, which was always tenuous.
3.) There's no historical reason to think any peace agreements are going to enjoy any longevity.
4.) And regarding Israel having peace with descendants of Ishmael: there is a lOT of controversy about which Arabs, and what percentage of them, are genuinely descendants of Ishmael in the first place.
(Muslims claim all Arabs are descended from Ishmael, but historians and scholars don't agree... so there's that.)
So yes, there were peace accords, limited, in only a few places, for a short time, and tenuous.... but peace accords.
Real Issue at Hand - Arabs in Current Conflict:
1.)The real issue at hand is not an issue of just any Arabs anywhere, but the PARTICULAR Arabs in conflict with Israel, and those supporting them.
2.) Doesn't look promising: when polled, around 60%-70% of palestinians usually say they support Hamas.
3.) Problem is more than just Hamas: there were at least 7 different jihadist groups participating in the recent attack on Israel.
4.) Problem with the jihadist supporters: As we all know, Iran and other Arab nations support the jihadists in palestine, and are doing everything to escalate the conflict into a much larger war with Israel.
5.) The other Arab countries WANT this conflict, and WANT the palestinians to fight, like cannon fodder, till everyone is destroyed.
(This is why NO ARAB NATION WILL TAKE PALESTINIAN IMMIGRANTS. Their Arab brothers are keeping them bottled up there, so they have no choice but to act as a proxy, and fight against Israel. Their Arab brothers are using them as cannon fodder, just using them up as a disposable proxy to die fighting Israel... and they don't care in the least.)
6.) The current DESIRE of the jihadis and many palestinians is NOT to seek peace, or liberation, or some kind of improvement in their lives... what they DESIRE is to take ALL OF THE LAND, DRIVE EVERY ISRAELITE OUT, and KILL JEWS. It's impossible to make peace with someone who wants no peace.
Conclusion:
A.) If we consider all the points above, I simply cannot see any earthly way, any human way, to achieve any peace in Palestine.
B.) If we want to talk about a "divine way" forward... then we're back to debates on eschatology.
Cameron, I always enjoy your posts.
Hope you have a great Lord's Day tomorrow, and a great weekend.
God Bless Brother.
.