Which web browser are you using to print to pdf? I ask because I often use firefox, and sometimes printing to pdf doesn't do all that I need.
Are you using Linux Mint?
If press <ctrl>+p or go to print through the menu
>More Settings
Set to US Letter
Change Scale to about 60% (play around with this until you find a size that you like)
You can also try changing Format to "Simplified" but this can erase the quote boxes which can make it confusing.
If you test this out, I think this is more in line with what you are looking for.
If you change "Destination" to "Save to PDF" it will make a PDF with the print settings. From a PDF you can print specific pages instead of the whole webpage.
Maybe this isn't what you're looking for, but I'll try my best to help you troubleshoot