Punishment is due...but not for those who "walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit
The Bible certainly makes a distinction between the
Just Man who falls 7 times and rises again, and the
Presumptuous Man who habitually, impenitently sins and is guilt of the "great transgression" -- between the sin that is "
not unto death" and the sin that is "
unto death".
If we're willing to recognize the distinction, then the fact that we've all broken the Sabbath (or any other laws) in the past is inconsequential, right or wrong? What matters is, "Are we convicted by the Holy Spirit of our guilt and sought repentance -- or -- are we in danger of grieving away the Holy Spirit Who seals us unto the day of redemption with the "Seal of God", which is His law (
Isaiah 1:18 KJV) ?