Not By Works

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
May 23, 2020
1,558
313
83
Only for those that are not under grace...those that are under grace my Bible tells me that sin shall have no dominion over them.

Your keeping yourself good is
Law Keeping 101
So you who are under grace such that sin has no dominion over you, how is that working out for you? Are you sinless now? Do those who live and work with you find that you are sinless since you are under grace and sin has no dominon over you in your words and deeds?
 
May 23, 2020
1,558
313
83
I have witnessed @jackrosie talking with you for quite a few days about her relationship with God and assurance of salvation, and now you say none do? :oops:(n) Many others do too, while you absolutely pooh-pooh their assurance of salvation.


Why should we doubt ours?
1. I don't ask you to doubt your salvation. I ask you to focus on obeying the God you claim you have relationship with.
2. Jackrosie telling us how God supposedly took control over her such that she was powerless to resist HIm is not talking about her relationship with God. I do not know what happened to her but either her understanding is off or something else is at work.
3. You need to point out where you see this because I do not see that others have been doing this. I have talked with you enough to know that what you claim to see is not always there for others to see. Do you have any examples besides the "overpowering experience JR had where she had no choice but to surrender?" (I am not childish enough to use the jeers and emocons. It is like being in kindergarten at times where adult responses to matters are not possible.)
 
Oct 25, 2018
2,377
1,198
113
And everyone who lives and works with you finds that you are like Christ in word and deed? Or is this a statement of faith?
Yes. I’ve worked with them ~ 13 years. If they don’t know I’m a Christian, then there’s something wrong. But they know I’m His. :)
 
E

EleventhHour

Guest
If the goal is to convince yourself you are saved, I guess this works.

If the goal would be to walk humbly with God hearing that still small voice, it won’t happen. You might not care about the sufferings others experience from your sin but God does.

Still licking your wounds I see... lost you attempts to have a little protégé....

You believe yourself to be saved yet deny others are saved!

Your mask is slipping again.

We are indeed set free sin once and for all.. @jackrosie understands the principles of the faith far better than you.

You think you please God with your daily sin confession for salvation.

God judged and forgave all sins when Jesus was dying.... so basically you stand in untruth, unrighteousness by denying the essence of the Gospel.

And you should be ashamed they way you address people with your haughty attitude ....especially since they are right and you
typically and most often are wrong.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
61,164
30,312
113
1. I don't ask you to doubt your salvation. I ask you to focus on obeying the God you claim you have relationship with.
2. Jackrosie telling us how God supposedly took control over her such that she was powerless to resist HIm is not talking about her relationship with God. I do not know what happened to her but either her understanding is off or something else is at work.
3. You need to point out where you see this because I do not see that others have been doing this. I have talked with you enough to know that what you claim to see is not always there for others to see. Do you have any examples besides the "overpowering experience JR had where she had no choice but to surrender?" (I am not childish enough to use the jeers and emocons. It is like being in kindergarten at times where adult responses to matters are not possible.)
Interesting how you wish to dictate how others are supposed to relate to God, and deny their experience/s in the way you choose to see it, though others understand. Interesting, but not surprising. Little emoticons are offensive to you also? Wow. It seems you have a lot of problems. Your biggest one may be yourself. Just something to consider.
 
May 23, 2020
1,558
313
83
Yes. I’ve worked with them ~ 13 years. If they don’t know I’m a Christian, then there’s something wrong. But they know I’m His. :)
That is not what I asked. I asked if your words and behaviour show that you are indeed free from all wrong towards them. Do you never ever do any wrong to any person because you are now under grace and free from sin? Free from sin means you do not sin. Do you?
 
Oct 25, 2018
2,377
1,198
113
That is not what I asked. I asked if your words and behaviour show that you are indeed free from all wrong towards them. Do you never ever do any wrong to any person because you are now under grace and free from sin? Free from sin means you do not sin. Do you?
Why do I feel like I’m on a witness stand? I’m not sinless, no. And neither is any true believer.
 
E

EleventhHour

Guest
So you who are under grace such that sin has no dominion over you, how is that working out for you? Are you sinless now? Do those who live and work with you find that you are sinless since you are under grace and sin has no dominon over you in your words and deeds?
It is working as it should because that is the essence of the Gospel.

Do you even know the Gospel... did I state I am sinless .... No

I stated it has no dominion... because it is God that works in me to will and to act on behalf of His good purpose.

Do you understand Grace at all?
 
May 23, 2020
1,558
313
83
Still licking your wounds I see... lost you attempts to have a little protégé....
Not at all. I am sorry for her that she will become like you and did so within minutes of her deciding to follow you, but that is not my problem.
You believe yourself to be saved yet deny others are saved!
Who did I deny was saved?? I asked others to obey God. I did not judge anyone to be unsaved. This is the fruit of your theology. You falsely accuse.
Your mask is slipping again.
Not wearing one, you are mistaken.
We are indeed set free sin once and for all.. @jackrosie understands the principles of the faith far better than you.
Well, when you stop sinning in your posts, then we can talk. So far the freedom from sin is not apparent.
You think you please God with your daily sin confession for salvation.
Never said any such thing. You do not understand my position. I do not think about my salvation. I think about walking with Him and what He has for me each day.
God judged and forgave all sins when Jesus was dying.... so basically you stand in untruth, unrighteousness by denying the essence of the Gospel.

And you should be ashamed they way you address people with your haughty attitude ....especially since they are right and you
typically and most often are wrong.
I am direct, not haughty. And I do not flatter as some do here. My only desire is to present a walk with God that does not claim lofty holiness void of real love towards God and man but a real fellowship with Him that any man can have who is willing to pay the price. It is there. And it is not claimed by faith as he does not grant it to those who insist they have it already.
 
May 23, 2020
1,558
313
83
Interesting how you wish to dictate how others are supposed to relate to God, and deny their experience/s in the way you choose to see it, though others understand. Interesting, but not surprising. Little emoticons are offensive to you also? Wow. It seems you have a lot of problems. Your biggest one may be yourself. Just something to consider.
What experiences except the unpleasant one of JR who was so overpowered she had no choice?

The emotons are not offensive to me. Your understanding is wrong on many accounts. They are childish. But there are some adults here who can exchange in words. One just recognizes the babes who can only make faces instead.

There are many who have walked with God and as a result experienced the jeers and laughter and mocking from others. This is part of the price. One has grace from Him to call a spade "a spade" and still love the cards.
 
May 23, 2020
1,558
313
83
It is working as it should because that is the essence of the Gospel.

Do you even know the Gospel... did I state I am sinless .... No

I stated it has no dominion... because it is God that works in me to will and to act on behalf of His good purpose.

Do you understand Grace at all?
IF the others around you to do not ALSO see that God is working in your to will and act on behalf for HIs good purpose, then it is not happening.

But I know the gospel often preached. You claim lofty descriptions for your life and deeds by faith and do not have to actually have any of that happen in real life choices is generally the "gospel" although I do not know how far you take it. IT is the "I am freed from sin and if you don't believe it I am going to hate you and beat you up" kind of response to others. What one actually does is divorced from the "delivered from sin" theology. Results in a lot of sin being done in the world. One member on a different thread asked a question because she has observed christians doing a number of very sinful choices and was wondering about it. This is exactly what I mean. Loudly claim delivered from sin and then being free to sin.
 
E

EleventhHour

Guest
Not at all. I am sorry for her that she will become like you and did so within minutes of her deciding to follow you, but that is not my problem.
Who did I deny was saved?? I asked others to obey God. I did not judge anyone to be unsaved. This is the fruit of your theology. You falsely accuse.
Not wearing one, you are mistaken.Well, when you stop sinning in your posts, then we can talk. So far the freedom from sin is not apparent.Never said any such thing. You do not understand my position. I do not think about my salvation. I think about walking with Him and what He has for me each day.
I am direct, not haughty. And I do not flatter as some do here. My only desire is to present a walk with God that does not claim lofty holiness void of real love towards God and man but a real fellowship with Him that any man can have who is willing to pay the price. It is there. And it is not claimed by faith as he does not grant it to those who insist they have it already.
Jesus paid the price... and yes we do have it already because it is not our self effort... but what Jesus accomplished that lives within us.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
61,164
30,312
113
It is working as it should because that is the essence of the Gospel.

Do you even know the Gospel... did I state I am sinless .... No

I stated it has no dominion... because it is God that works in me to will and to act on behalf of His good purpose.

Do you understand Grace at all?
I don't think so, since the assertion that nobody (emphasized by following that claim with "not one") talks about their relationship with God as regards salvation shows an incredible blindness to the fact that saying we are saved by grace through faith is an affirmation of our relationship with God as it pertains to salvation... and that is specifically how God designed it :) His Word will not return void (y)
 
May 23, 2020
1,558
313
83
I don't think so, since the assertion that nobody (emphasized by following that claim with "not one") talks about their relationship with God as regards salvation shows an incredible blindness to the fact that saying we are saved by grace through faith is an affirmation of our relationship with God as it pertains to salvation... and that is specifically how God designed it :) His Word will not return void (y)
Using the word "relationship" in a sentence with the word "salvation" is not talking about your relationship with God. But I asked you for examples because except for the strange one of JR, which was an experience not a relationship, I cannot recall any of you doing this. YOu claim it happens all the time and I do not see it. IS the above an example??? YOu mention the word in the same sentence and think that is talking about the relationship??
 
E

EleventhHour

Guest
IF the others around you to do not ALSO see that God is working in your to will and act on behalf for HIs good purpose, then it is not happening.

But I know the gospel often preached. You claim lofty descriptions for your life and deeds by faith and do not have to actually have any of that happen in real life choices is generally the "gospel" although I do not know how far you take it. IT is the "I am freed from sin and if you don't believe it I am going to hate you and beat you up" kind of response to others. What one actually does is divorced from the "delivered from sin" theology. Results in a lot of sin being done in the world. One member on a different thread asked a question because she has observed christians doing a number of very sinful choices and was wondering about it. This is exactly what I mean. Loudly claim delivered from sin and then being free to sin.
Your rhetoric means very little.

Unless you have facts do not bring your biases and faulty perceptions into the conversation.