The Virgin Porn Addict -- Why Do We Differentiate So Much Between Sins of the Heart and the Body?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Aug 2, 2009
24,644
4,305
113
#21
In the heart it's the same... I'm saying if I was married to someone who watched it then I would feel hurt and betrayed, because like Jesus said, it is committing adultery in the heart. I literally could not be with someone because of it, it's just the same as if he had committed adultery.
So you're saying that looking at porn is the same as cheating?

If so, is wanting to murder someone the same as actually committing murder? Do you think God views actual murder just as bad as someone only thinking about murder?
 
M

morefaithrequired

Guest
#22
Pretty sure my parents were both virgins. it was common in those days. then they 7 kids.
sorry that might irrelevant here.
 

Butterflyyy

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2019
1,610
1,318
113
#23
So you're saying that looking at porn is the same as cheating?

If so, is wanting to murder someone the same as actually committing murder? Do you think God views actual murder just as bad as someone only thinking about murder?
God looks at the heart. I also am concerned with a man's heart aswell as the manner in which he lives his life outwardly. Obviously the physical act of murder has much more serious implications than the desire to do it, however, that desire could come to fruition eventually if it is in the heart.
The point is, this thread is about sexual sin, not murder. So what I am saying is that for me, the implications are that I could not be with a spouse who looks at porn; I would have to separate myself from them; ultimately if I was certain they had overcome the problem then there would be the potential for reconciliation; whereas if the spouse had actually committed the act then there would be no reconciliation only divorce. So yes the consequences are more far reaching if the act has been committed, however it is still spiritual adultery in the heart and it is still an action that would have serious physical consequences.
You cannot get a murdered person back and for me personally, the same applies to a marriage where there has been adultery. At least there is a chance for repentance before it gets as far as these acts being committed, but I guess Jesus is showing that there is a real danger of these things happening if they are in the heart. And for someone to look at another with lust in their heart means that they have already committed the act in their heart, which is why it would have the consequences I described. It's about truth isn't it.
 

Adstar

Senior Member
Jul 24, 2016
7,581
3,616
113
#24
Some may differentiated.. But the Bible doesn't and i don't.. Sin in thought is equal to sin in deed.. Jesus established this with his teaching::

Matthew 5: KJV
27 "¶ Ye have heard that it was said by them of old time, Thou shalt not commit adultery: {28} But I say unto you, That whosoever looketh on a woman to lust after her hath committed adultery with her already in his heart."
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
27,227
9,293
113
#25
In modern-speak: "If the only reason you're not doing it is because you're afraid you'll get caught, but you would do it if you could figure out a way to do it without getting caught, to God that's just as bad."
 

Adstar

Senior Member
Jul 24, 2016
7,581
3,616
113
#26
Pretty sure my parents were both virgins. it was common in those days. then they 7 kids.
sorry that might irrelevant here.
So you're saying that looking at porn is the same as cheating?

If so, is wanting to murder someone the same as actually committing murder? Do you think God views actual murder just as bad as someone only thinking about murder?
Just hating a brother is equivalent to murder..

1 John 3: KJV
15 "Whosoever hateth his brother is a murderer: and ye know that no murderer hath eternal life abiding in him."
 
Aug 2, 2009
24,644
4,305
113
#27
God looks at the heart. I also am concerned with a man's heart aswell as the manner in which he lives his life outwardly. Obviously the physical act of murder has much more serious implications than the desire to do it, however, that desire could come to fruition eventually if it is in the heart.
The point is, this thread is about sexual sin, not murder. So what I am saying is that for me, the implications are that I could not be with a spouse who looks at porn; I would have to separate myself from them; ultimately if I was certain they had overcome the problem then there would be the potential for reconciliation; whereas if the spouse had actually committed the act then there would be no reconciliation only divorce. So yes the consequences are more far reaching if the act has been committed, however it is still spiritual adultery in the heart and it is still an action that would have serious physical consequences.
You cannot get a murdered person back and for me personally, the same applies to a marriage where there has been adultery. At least there is a chance for repentance before it gets as far as these acts being committed, but I guess Jesus is showing that there is a real danger of these things happening if they are in the heart. And for someone to look at another with lust in their heart means that they have already committed the act in their heart, which is why it would have the consequences I described. It's about truth isn't it.
Well if you meant someone with a porn addiction, then I totally understand. I thought you meant you couldn't be with someone who looked at porn even once.
 

Butterflyyy

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2019
1,610
1,318
113
#28
Well if you meant someone with a porn addiction, then I totally understand. I thought you meant you couldn't be with someone who looked at porn even once.
I feel it's once it's adultery in the heart.
I would leave.
 

Butterflyyy

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2019
1,610
1,318
113
#29
Well if you meant someone with a porn addiction, then I totally understand. I thought you meant you couldn't be with someone who looked at porn even once.
How many times do they look and lust before it's addiction?
Am I not enough that they need to list after someone else even once?
It is unfaithfulness in the heart- unfaithfulness to me and to God and it needs truly repenting of; trust would be damaged, my heart would be broken; it would take time and prayer before I could go back.
 

Dino246

Senior Member
Jun 30, 2015
25,404
13,746
113
#31
With regard to this topic in particular I don't think there is a distinction between physical sin and sin of the heart; Jesus said that, as you quoted.
I know that the pain in my heart and sense of betrayal if my spouse had watched porn is the same feeling as if he had sinned physically. It's all about the heart really isn't it?
I asked a Christian counselor about this once... he confirmed, having counseled many women whose husbands had done both, that the feelings are the same.
 

Dino246

Senior Member
Jun 30, 2015
25,404
13,746
113
#32
So if a man caught his wife looking at porn once and she begged for forgiveness, he has a biblical excuse to leave?
Unfortunately, "begging for forgiveness" is not repentance, despite what a lot of Christians seem to think. Repentance is an acknowledgement of the wrongness of the action and a subsequent change in behaviour. Any sinner will beg for forgiveness when caught and threatened with unpleasant consequences. This goes for men and women.
 
M

MegMarch

Guest
#33
I asked a Christian counselor about this once... he confirmed, having counseled many women whose husbands had done both, that the feelings are the same.
Yes. I think as women we can probably logically and rationally understand they aren’t exactly the same thing, but the pain that results from both feels very similar if not the same.
 

BrotherMike

Be Still and Know
Jan 8, 2018
1,617
1,671
113
#34
Repentance is an acknowledgement of the wrongness of the action and a subsequent change in behaviour.
Agreed assuming this is a course of action they would take.
 
M

MegMarch

Guest
#35
For myself, watching porn is a dealbreaker. If we aren’t married, I would break up with the person so they can work on this with the Lord. If I was married to someone who was watching porn, at the very least, we would separate and seek counsel. It might result in reconciliation, but it might not.

I have broken up with people over this because eventually it always comes out. The Lord reveals what is hiding in the dark.
 

BrotherMike

Be Still and Know
Jan 8, 2018
1,617
1,671
113
#36
Satan loves to kill steal and destroy and I’m sure he uses porn to do that. I really don’t understand why a married person or couple would partake in that when God gave them each other. Love and focus on your spouse it’s so much more meaningful.
 

Dino246

Senior Member
Jun 30, 2015
25,404
13,746
113
#37
There is no justification for sin, period.

Viewing porn is one sin among many that damage a marriage. It is stereotypically a male problem (though is increasingly common among females), and it is in this context that I'm addressing it. My comments regarding males and females are generalities, and as such, there are always exceptions.

The sin that men commit, such as physical violence and viewing of porn, does damage to their wives, and I'm not arguing that. However, the sin that women commit, such as emotional adultery, manipulation, disrespect, and refusing sex, do damage to the same degree to their husbands. Such behaviour will tear holes in his confidence, identity, and self-worth, and will push him away from you. It is exactly the opposite of the edifying behaviour that would strengthen the marriage.

If you as a wife are watching soap operas, reading romance novels, and "going out with the girls", are you any better than the husband who looks at porn? Are you not looking for something in others that you don't find in your husband?

When we consider the sin of the other person as "worse" than our own, we basically justify or excuse our own; that is not repentance, and it certainly won't heal a damaged marriage. Better that we each look to Jesus, measure ourselves against His standard of righteousness, and seek His help to treat our spouse as He desires.
 
M

MegMarch

Guest
#38
There is no justification for sin, period.

Viewing porn is one sin among many that damage a marriage. It is stereotypically a male problem (though is increasingly common among females), and it is in this context that I'm addressing it. My comments regarding males and females are generalities, and as such, there are always exceptions.

The sin that men commit, such as physical violence and viewing of porn, does damage to their wives, and I'm not arguing that. However, the sin that women commit, such as emotional adultery, manipulation, disrespect, and refusing sex, do damage to the same degree to their husbands. Such behaviour will tear holes in his confidence, identity, and self-worth, and will push him away from you. It is exactly the opposite of the edifying behaviour that would strengthen the marriage.

If you as a wife are watching soap operas, reading romance novels, and "going out with the girls", are you any better than the husband who looks at porn? Are you not looking for something in others that you don't find in your husband?

When we consider the sin of the other person as "worse" than our own, we basically justify or excuse our own; that is not repentance, and it certainly won't heal a damaged marriage. Better that we each look to Jesus, measure ourselves against His standard of righteousness, and seek His help to treat our spouse as He desires.
Hopefully my comment didn’t come across as I view myself as sinless and could do no wrong. I completely agree with what you said here. Women can do things that can make a man feel disrespected in the same way that can cause a lot of pain as well. Guys could have similar dealbreakers such as she puts me down and disrespects me in front of my friends, which can be just as damaging to a man.

I was just addressing porn because that was brought up.
 
L

LittleMermaid

Guest
#39
As a virgin, it's a little disheartening to think that my future spouse has probably already had sex with someone else. Maybe even several others. That makes me so sad.

I was taught as a teen in youth group, that once you have sex with someone, you become one with that person. So it kinda annoys me that my future husband might have become one with someone else.

One of the scariest parts of sex for me is that he may compare me to previous lovers. With pornography, well what can he compare? Maybe that I don't look like the women in the videos...which is concerning too. But when the man or woman has already had sex, well there might be more comparison. I'm afraid he might think "So and so was better at this" or "So and so was more pleasing." LOL I feel gross just typing this here but I'm trying to make a point.

With pornography it's just a daydream. With sex, it's actually real and they did become one. That's part of their shared history together. There was touching, kissing, exchanging of fluids, holding, cuddling etc. It makes me so nauseous to even think about. lol But I do agree that pornography and pleasing one self is a sin and should be stopped. I believe they too cause many issues in a marriage.

I'm not saying I judge those who have had sex. I think my hang ups are more my own problem. I am very insecure and very anxious. And very jealous! lol

I have prayed to God about this and he basically told me that I am not waiting for my husband. I am waiting for Him, for Christ. I saved myself because that's what my Father in heaven wants from me. I didn't save my virginity for a man. And in a way, that made me feel much better. It made me realize that I was being prideful. I shouldn't expect something so difficult from my future spouse.
 
L

LittleMermaid

Guest
#40
I wanted to add...
I would much rather marry a man that has been with many women and has his heart out for Jesus now, than a man who is a virgin and is addicted to porn.