A NON-CHARISMATIC UNDERSTANDING OF TONGUES
- Thread starter VCO
- Start date
-
Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.
If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!
To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
What I wrote is not my thoughts on how tongues are applied, but rather how scripture is enacted on and put into practice.
The person operating the spiritual gift of speaking out in tongues edifies themselves (building up their faith); the gift of
interpretation given by the Holy Spirit edifies the congregation through: A) confirming the previous spiritual gift, and
B) allowing all to receive wisdom and instruction from God directly.
No understanding of the gift of tongues is necessary by any person as the interpretation is given by the Holy Spirit and not by any person's natural mind.
The gift of various tongues is only operated within a church meeting and therefore is always accompanied by interpretation through
the Holy Spirit.
This gift distributed within the church is different to the sign of praying in a new tongue that is given to everybody that is baptized in the Holy Spirit: these signs shall follow them that believe …
Walking in gthe Spirit or walking with the Lord is essentially what all the epistles are about. They are written to the Spirit-filled
church for the purpose of not just salvation theology, but very much on how to live as a Christian and to become children of light.
Romans 12 and Galatians 5 are two chapters that come to mind and are helpful on this topic.
The person operating the spiritual gift of speaking out in tongues edifies themselves (building up their faith); the gift of
interpretation given by the Holy Spirit edifies the congregation through: A) confirming the previous spiritual gift, and
B) allowing all to receive wisdom and instruction from God directly.
No understanding of the gift of tongues is necessary by any person as the interpretation is given by the Holy Spirit and not by any person's natural mind.
The gift of various tongues is only operated within a church meeting and therefore is always accompanied by interpretation through
the Holy Spirit.
This gift distributed within the church is different to the sign of praying in a new tongue that is given to everybody that is baptized in the Holy Spirit: these signs shall follow them that believe …
Walking in gthe Spirit or walking with the Lord is essentially what all the epistles are about. They are written to the Spirit-filled
church for the purpose of not just salvation theology, but very much on how to live as a Christian and to become children of light.
Romans 12 and Galatians 5 are two chapters that come to mind and are helpful on this topic.
You can easily edify someone by speaking a language they understand, so understanding is the main thing when it comes to edification- the reason tongues MUST be translated for the members of the church to be edified. Speaking unknown things can not and will never edify anyone. But of course you didn't get Paul on matters self edification- he simply meant the understanding remains with you and can not be transferred to others and it is not a wonderful thing.
-
3
-
1
- Show all
The gift of speaking in tongues by getting the babtism with the Holy Spirit is a teaching which is little older then 119 years. Why should somone follow such a false doctrine?
That you made this expierience is no proof that it is right.
How many miracles are done in the name of Christ, but are from the enemy? The Lord himself said: that people will tell him we have cast out demons and have done miracles in your name. And He will say, go away I dont know you.
Btw, how spiritfilled where the corinthians? They are really no example for a spiritfilled church. And the seems to have the most problems with the gift of speaking in tongues.
That you made this expierience is no proof that it is right.
How many miracles are done in the name of Christ, but are from the enemy? The Lord himself said: that people will tell him we have cast out demons and have done miracles in your name. And He will say, go away I dont know you.
Btw, how spiritfilled where the corinthians? They are really no example for a spiritfilled church. And the seems to have the most problems with the gift of speaking in tongues.
-
2
-
1
- Show all
E
How do you know when you do not even know what your praying?
I mean really man, come on!!
1. I babble incoherently
2. Something happens and appears to be blessed by God (whether it is or not is open to discussion)
3. My Babble had to be a prayer for that thing that happened so it was fulfilled.
That edifies you more than this?
1. A man prays (in his own language) for his wife to be healed of a tumor in her head
2. In corporate prayer in church, Everyone prays for this mans wife to be healed
3. Next time the wife goes to get checked, the tumor is GONE
4. The man AND THE CHURCH are EDIFIED as they have WITNESSED a miracle of God as well as answered prayer.
PS. I witnessed this very thing when a girl in our church was diagnosed with emphysema and two holes in her lung that miraculously disappeared with no medical reason (A TRUE MIRACLE which was enacted by the whole church praying in the spirit)
I mean really man, come on!!
1. I babble incoherently
2. Something happens and appears to be blessed by God (whether it is or not is open to discussion)
3. My Babble had to be a prayer for that thing that happened so it was fulfilled.
That edifies you more than this?
1. A man prays (in his own language) for his wife to be healed of a tumor in her head
2. In corporate prayer in church, Everyone prays for this mans wife to be healed
3. Next time the wife goes to get checked, the tumor is GONE
4. The man AND THE CHURCH are EDIFIED as they have WITNESSED a miracle of God as well as answered prayer.
PS. I witnessed this very thing when a girl in our church was diagnosed with emphysema and two holes in her lung that miraculously disappeared with no medical reason (A TRUE MIRACLE which was enacted by the whole church praying in the spirit)
-
2
- Show all
My turn to ask a question.
1 Corinthians 10:23-24 (NASB)
23 All things are lawful, but not all things are profitable. All things are lawful,
but not all things edify.
24 Let no one seek his own, but that of his neighbor.
1 Corinthians 14:19 (NASB)
19 however, in the church I desire to speak five words with my mind so that I may instruct others also,
rather than ten thousand words in a tongue.
1 Corinthians 14:4 (NASB)
4 One who speaks in a tongue edifies himself;
but one who prophesies edifies the church.
Now, my question:
DID PAUL give us a REASON to speak in tongues,
Or rather, NOT to speak in Tongues ? ? ?
-
4
- Show all
I would think God gave a law in regard to the doctrine of tongues in order to help us cofirm what the sign of tongues represents. And not the work of tongues as God's word. Two different doctrines one as a sign the other a work of prophecy by which men can believe God
Tongues, is God's word as prophecy interpreted into all the nations of the world . God's word Tongues is God's interpretation. His name is Jealous in that way he will not share his glory with the clay he is forming ChristThere is no sign for those who believe the work of prophecy .
I would offer. Paul does not discourage hearing the word of God or prophesying "declaring tongues" (God's word) as that spoke in the language of many nations as his interpretation to them. It is that which comes from seeking His approval .
What he does discourage is unbelief (no faith) It is what the sign of tongues confirms, no faith, unbelief.
God bringing his interpretation in the language of all the nations of the world to confirm unbelief as sign using Jewish flesh a sign that speaks to the whole world . Sign are never limited to the flesh of one nation .One nation can be used as a sign . But never the substance of faith, belief . The word of God speaks to all who hear tongues and believe God .
Look to the law in the tongues doctrine which confirms God mocks with stammering lips those who mocks him and refuse to believe .Its foundation is found in Isaiah 28. The sign is confirmed in Acts 2 the idea of "signs gift" disappears and is replaced with spiritual gifts (unseen) things of faith. We have a living hope of a new body that will not age as in death .All saints died not receiving the promise but have received a better hope that surpass our understanding His veiled glory . That glory will be the light of new home. there will be no more night.
2 Corinthians 5:7 (For we walk by faith, not by sight
Our God is the father of many nations He I think never makes His wisdom about the flesh of a Jew and gentile .We do not wrestles against flesh and blood. Again the gospel is a picture to the whole world. Tongues is part of that picture .
What are we showing the world that knows not Christ in respect to the unseen God we are following . . Would God say if you feel moved by a spirit put on a show, make a noise that has no meaning, fall back slain in the spirit ?
Would that performance called a time for a sign gift give a unbeliever enough information to interest them or would the unbeliever think. What a bunch of loony tunes making noises ?
The very beginning of what?
Really in respect to the foundation of the Tongue doctrine? (Isaiah 28 ) God mocking Jew with stammering lips as a sign against those with no faith.
I thought Isaiah was before Paul ? Does Paul quote it (Isaiah 28 ) as the foundation the law in In 1 Corinthians 14? Or is context not important?