Sorry bro, nice guys finish last, read the psychology.
Perhaps it's just a reflection of the wicked corrupt and fallen world in which we live, but it's true none the less.
Girls (Christians and otherwise) might all say they want to marry a nice loving godly man who will love them forever and treat them like a princess, but the cold reality is they will fall in love with the arrogant sleezy druggie unemployed looser who's good with words (and then wonder why he cheats on her or gets her pregnant then leaves)
If your are one of those poor nice guys you MIGHT have a chance with the woman of your dreams if you are persistent, have status or become financially successfull.
If you are prepared to seriously compromise your integrity, then you too can become the arrogant wicked man women will love, but as Christians that's really not an option.
You might also try going to a smaller, more conservative church where the eligible serious Christian girls have limited access to boys.
It's all a sick game really, but sadly it's not a game.