Not By Works

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Seohce

Senior Member
Jul 15, 2016
1,386
54
48
I do not mind heat and banter from those who disagree because I dish it out as much as I get it, but to say I believe and teach one can can call Allah Lord goes beyond "Wbanter and heat into character assassination.....not good at all.....
HOW ABOUT WHEN SOMEONE SAYS THAT OUR LORD JESUS "WAS CURSED", DOES THAT MATTER TO YOU?
 

VCO

Senior Member
Oct 14, 2013
11,995
4,615
113
I'm here to share from the scriptures about the discussion topic.
I have been ridiculed and attacked, slandered and lied about, by simply posting a scripture and asking questions.


This is a Bible study, where Christians are supposed to gather and study the Bible.


How is asking a person an honest question, passing judgement on them?





Please point out in my previous post's where I have judged anyone.



JPT



It seems like a silly, hypothetical question. And I am not sure WHY you would ask it. But, I do not think it would be normal for Born Again Christian to even consider renouncing CHRIST. If they want to shoot me, I am ready to go HOME! Martyrdom advances the cause of CHRIST!
It happened before, and it will happen again.

Here is the Letter to the PERSECUTED CHURCH at Smyrna:

Revelation 2:8-11 (HCSB)
8 “Write to the angel of the church in Smyrna: “The First and the Last, the One who was dead and came to life, says:
9 I know your affliction and poverty, yet you are rich. ⌊I know⌋ the slander of those who say they are Jews and are not, but are a synagogue of Satan.
10 Don’t be afraid of what you are about to suffer. Look, the Devil is about to throw some of you into prison to test you, and you will have affliction for 10 days. Be faithful until death, and I will give you the crown of life.
11 “Anyone who has an ear should listen to what the Spirit says to the churches. The victor will never be harmed by the second death.



NOTICE: There is NO CONDEMNATION for the Persecuted Church. Most of the Letters to the Churches, have condemnation for what they are doing wrong, but NOT the SMYRNA Church, nor the Philadelphia Church. The REASON there is NO Condemnation for the Persecuted Church, is BECAUSE THE MINUTE THE PERSECUTION STARTS, the phony, non-born again Believers GET OUT. So perhaps a BETTER analogy to make, is "Would you remain in a Church where all your Neighbors made Fun of you for worshiping there?" It don't take much of the Persecution, to start getting the Phonies OUT.
 

PS

Senior Member
Jan 11, 2013
5,399
695
113
HOW ABOUT WHEN SOMEONE SAYS THAT OUR LORD JESUS "WAS CURSED", DOES THAT MATTER TO YOU?
Born sinless and no longer cursed by our sins after conquering sin and death.

I would say, "Thank you Lord for taking the curse of my sins upon yourself so that I might be redeemed from the curse of the law and made right with God." (2Co 5:21) Now, Jesus the purified one after conquering the curse of sin saves all those who come to Him believing. Jesus, who is alive for evermore having conquered death, has the keys of heaven and hell and in the context of the thread quite simply it is Jesus who saves us from our sin and not our works. "There is life for a look at the crucified one."
 

Mel85

Daughter of the True King
Mar 28, 2018
10,910
6,897
113
Over 3,200 pages and over 65,000 posts of non-stop misrepresenting other user's positions, name calling, general rudeness, and calling into question the salvation of other users (by both sides of the debate). In all of that no one has convinced another that their stance was incorrect regardless of how many hundreds of times the evidence was portrayed.

This thread went toxic within days of it's origin and no matter how many infractions get issued it doesn't get any better.
Back by popular demand. :)

I understand Oncefallen not wanting to deal with this thread anymore so I will try to handle any reports in it until or unless I also give up :)

We would like to ask everyone to please try to be civil and even friendly :)
Sorry, then why are y’all continuing to keep this thread going if y’all know aint nobody listening to each other?
 
Oct 31, 2015
2,290
588
113
It seems like a silly, hypothetical question. And I am not sure WHY you would ask it. But, I do not think it would be normal for Born Again Christian to even consider renouncing CHRIST. If they want to shoot me, I am ready to go HOME! Martyrdom advances the cause of CHRIST!
Amen!

I agree.

However, things are going to get ugly on planet earth, before that glorious Day when the Lord returns.

It’s when they have your family and the gun is pointed at your little daughter or grand daughter, that things get real.


The enemy is merciless and cunning, full of rage, knowing his time is short.


Jesus said it this way -

  • because lawlessness will abound, the love of many will grow cold.

9 “Then they will deliver you up to tribulation and kill you, and you will be hated by all nations for My name’s sake. 10 And then many will be offended, will betray one another, and will hate one another. 11 Then many false prophets will rise up anddeceive many. 12 And because lawlessness will abound, the love of many will grow cold. 13 But he who endures to the end shall be saved. 14 And this gospel of the kingdomwill be preached in all the world as a witness to all the nations, and then the end will come. Matthew 24:9-14


Can we still love our brother, who out of fear or greed, turned in our family so that the situation where the gun is pointed at our family in hopes of getting us to turn away from Christ are successful ?


Whoever hates his brother is a murderer, and you know that no murderer has eternal life abiding in him.
1 John 3:15


We in America haven’t had to face this kind of persecution... yet.


Are we ready?



JPT
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
My answer is that I am not qualified to judge another mans salvation. I leave the judging to God. My mind comes up with all sorts of things and verses that make me refuse to be the judge. And that you would pronounce that judgement makes me cringe for you.
I am so sick of hypotheticals which do nothing to support ones cause, yet force people to try to be God and judge someones salvation because of some sin, who gave us the right or ability to cast stones (judge a person) when we deaerve to be judged ourselves (let he who has no sin casr first stone) yet people want to be stone throwers, or demand we cast stones ourselves.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Back by popular demand. :)

I understand Oncefallen not wanting to deal with this thread anymore so I will try to handle any reports in it until or unless I also give up :)

We would like to ask everyone to please try to be civil and even friendly :)
I wanted to thank you also, there have been some people changed, and some admit they have learned alot, i have even learned some things in this thread, its bound to be the most heated thread due to subject matter. But in the grand scheme of christianity or Gods people, it has been the most important hotly debated topic since mankind was created.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I'm here to share from the scriptures about the discussion topic.


I have been ridiculed and attacked, slandered and lied about, by simply posting a scripture and asking questions.


This is a Bible study, where Christians are supposed to gather and study the Bible.


How is asking a person an honest question, passing judgement on them?





Please point out in my previous post's where I have judged anyone.



JPT
Before you start crying wolf you should take responsibility for yourself slandering others,

And your in sin demanding someone who would be judged himself judge anoher person who has sinned.


And while we are at it, if you have kids, its good to know if out of fear if they renounce you as their oarent you will disown them as your children.
 

PS

Senior Member
Jan 11, 2013
5,399
695
113
Before you start crying wolf you should take responsibility for yourself slandering others,

And your in sin demanding someone who would be judged himself judge anoher person who has sinned.

And while we are at it, if you have kids, its good to know if out of fear if they renounce you as their oarent you will disown them as your children.
Red.
Oh dear.
 
N

NoNameMcgee

Guest
Sorry, then why are y’all continuing to keep this thread going if y’all know aint nobody listening to each other?

i personally used to be a sinless perfectionist....

i thought of many brothers and sisters here were wicked sinners on the way to hell
i used to insult and accuse some of them too...

after constant debate from people who did not seem to be lying about what they believe or twist my words and making so much sense.....

even though i spent years in study
sometimes 15 hours a day
i realized.... there was a slim chance..... maybe... i was wrong
i think this was God using brothers and sisters to plant seeds of truth in me

some harshly
some were gentle
some went back and forth
some were just in the middle and non-stop


so even as a stubborn rude self righteous young man who thought i was ready to be a preacher to the world

i layed everything i thought i knew back at Gods feet

many sleepless nights
many tears
many prayers
and many hours of study later

bit by bit

begging God to show me the truth
asking to only see what He wants me to see
asking to be delivered from itching ears
asking to be delivered from my own understanding if it is incorrect

and asking for truth

He broke my false gospel from me.....


this thread was one of the many tools God used to not only reprove and chasten me
God used it to bring me assurance and give me truth


not only me
i have personally seen God use this site as a tool for many to grow from what has been said here

i can pull up many posts of me calling brothers and sisters here sin loving liars from when i thought our own walk saved us and others pointed to Jesus
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,401
113
So your answer to my question is "yes" a believer who is being persecuted, and who renounces Jesus as Lord, and converts to Islam by confessing Allah as Lord, is still saved?


Now when I said before, exactly this same thing, saying that those who promote OSAS, are teaching people that believers can turn away from Christ and become Muslim, while under persecution, and you went ballistic and reported me because you would never teach such a thing, but now wee see I was exactly right.




JPT
Now you are embellishing what you said to me.....exactly why most reject what you say....you like to make a blanket statement, then twist it or embellish it to your favor.....your modus operandi.......
 
N

NoNameMcgee

Guest
dc to me you seem like someone who tries to justify sin and condem those who speak of repenting


if youre going to speak of salvation you should bring up the change of heart Jesus provides in those who do have faith



youre right


no amount of works will ever gain a sinner access to heaven

correct



but no one with faith is the same before and after they recieve the gift of Faith
this is me trying to suggest the changes God makes in us

make it so we eventually stop sinning...

i was also looking to suggest if you do indeed sin

you are no longer saved

You have been here what 9 days or so....go read every thread I have posted in and then come back bro....I have NEVER condemned one who preaches repentance pal.....nor do I EXCUSE SIN, but rather I ACKNOWLEDGE the bible's perspective on it....this thread is about salvation based upon faith void of works....NOT A THREAD ON SIN AND REPENTANCE....
this is dcon sticking to the meat and bread of the topic.... only seeing me poke at the truth (we are saved by Jesus... not self) and not knowing where i stand but having a feel for it
he set up the next argument.....

"void of works" to say to me
"do you understand He saves and keeps His children save by HIS GRACE through faith and not according to your walk"
i read your words, you appear how you appear
this is me claiming in a subtle way he is not a son of God.... not a new man but a lost man blinded for love of sin
K....pull up any and all quotes that states or shows I argue in favor of sin since you have been on this site.....I will wait for you to look....NONE support sin or argue in favor of sin.....so....pull up the quotes or be found false like spongebob!
now dcon sees that i reject the truth and was a cunning type of man who was making broad statements to earn favor of those who saw the conversation

so he layed it all on the table

this was tame

but on my earlier account
and on nonamemcgee

i went after him maybe 8 times in total openly

but it was one of the times i tried to accuse him

then believed in my heart i was wrong not wanting to lie to myself or lie about him (lose my salvation from what i believed)


some of my attempts to show if you sin you are not saved would be like

"can a good tree produce bad fruit?"

then follow with word games to those who answered me

(much like i see some of those still in the same error i was in do)
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,401
113
i personally used to be a sinless perfectionist....

i thought of many brothers and sisters here were wicked sinners on the way to hell
i used to insult and accuse some of them too...

after constant debate from people who did not seem to be lying about what they believe or twist my words and making so much sense.....

even though i spent years in study
sometimes 15 hours a day
i realized.... there was a slim chance..... maybe... i was wrong
i think this was God using brothers and sisters to plant seeds of truth in me

some harshly
some were gentle
some went back and forth
some were just in the middle and non-stop


so even as a stubborn rude self righteous young man who thought i was ready to be a preacher to the world

i layed everything i thought i knew back at Gods feet

many sleepless nights
many tears
many prayers
and many hours of study later

bit by bit

begging God to show me the truth
asking to only see what He wants me to see
asking to be delivered from itching ears
asking to be delivered from my own understanding if it is incorrect

and asking for truth

He broke my false gospel from me.....


this thread was one of the many tools God used to not only reprove and chasten me
God used it to bring me assurance and give me truth


not only me
i have personally seen God use this site as a tool for many to grow from what has been said here

i can pull up many posts of me calling brothers and sisters here sin loving liars from when i thought our own walk saved us and others pointed to Jesus
Exactly.....I keep posting because of the false dogma that gets peddled such as --->salvation is loseable and it must me earned, maintained, kept or embellished with works.....both false.....!
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,401
113
this is me trying to suggest the changes God makes in us

make it so we eventually stop sinning...

i was also looking to suggest if you do indeed sin

you are no longer saved



this is dcon sticking to the meat and bread of the topic.... only seeing me poke at the truth (we are saved by Jesus... not self) and not knowing where i stand but having a feel for it
he set up the next argument.....

"void of works" to say to me
"do you understand He saves and keeps His children save by HIS GRACE through faith and not according to your walk"


this is me claiming in a subtle way he is not a son of God.... not a new man but a lost man blinded for love of sin

now dcon sees that i reject the truth and was a cunning type of man who was making broad statements to earn favor of those who saw the conversation

so he layed it all on the table

this was tame

but on my earlier account
and on nonamemcgee

i went after him maybe 8 times in total openly

but it was one of the times i tried to accuse him

then believed in my heart i was wrong not wanting to lie to myself or lie about him (lose my salvation from what i believed)


some of my attempts to show if you sin you are not saved would be like

"can a good tree produce bad fruit?"

then follow with word games to those who answered me

(much like i see some of those still in the same error i was in do)
I appreciate your honesty.....one of a few willing to openly admit to their incorrect view that was changed by God, the word and those whom he used to lay it out....The thing with you was simple....you were (enlarged) open to learning and instruction and God blessed you because of it......!!
 

Mel85

Daughter of the True King
Mar 28, 2018
10,910
6,897
113
i personally used to be a sinless perfectionist....

i thought of many brothers and sisters here were wicked sinners on the way to hell
i used to insult and accuse some of them too...

after constant debate from people who did not seem to be lying about what they believe or twist my words and making so much sense.....

even though i spent years in study
sometimes 15 hours a day
i realized.... there was a slim chance..... maybe... i was wrong
i think this was God using brothers and sisters to plant seeds of truth in me

some harshly
some were gentle
some went back and forth
some were just in the middle and non-stop


so even as a stubborn rude self righteous young man who thought i was ready to be a preacher to the world

i layed everything i thought i knew back at Gods feet

many sleepless nights
many tears
many prayers
and many hours of study later

bit by bit

begging God to show me the truth
asking to only see what He wants me to see
asking to be delivered from itching ears
asking to be delivered from my own understanding if it is incorrect

and asking for truth

He broke my false gospel from me.....


this thread was one of the many tools God used to not only reprove and chasten me
God used it to bring me assurance and give me truth


not only me
i have personally seen God use this site as a tool for many to grow from what has been said here

i can pull up many posts of me calling brothers and sisters here sin loving liars from when i thought our own walk saved us and others pointed to Jesus
I’m glad that this thread has helped you in your walk with Christ :), however I do also think that it’s very dangerous for some of us to be arguing over Gods Holy Word especially when there are very new Christian brothers & sisters who have come through and have read some of the replies in here, in this thread....... it can be very discouraging for them.

I’m sure there’s more positive than negative posts in here (I hope), but during the times I’ve popped in, I’ve only read debates lol.

I’ve said what I need to say and now, I shall depart. May the peace of Jesus be with us all.
 

benhur

Senior Member
Feb 8, 2018
1,534
121
63
Amen!

I agree.

However, things are going to get ugly on planet earth, before that glorious Day when the Lord returns.

It’s when they have your family and the gun is pointed at your little daughter or grand daughter, that things get real.


The enemy is merciless and cunning, full of rage, knowing his time is short.


Jesus said it this way -

  • because lawlessness will abound, the love of many will grow cold.

9 “Then they will deliver you up to tribulation and kill you, and you will be hated by all nations for My name’s sake. 10 And then many will be offended, will betray one another, and will hate one another. 11 Then many false prophets will rise up anddeceive many. 12 And because lawlessness will abound, the love of many will grow cold. 13 But he who endures to the end shall be saved. 14 And this gospel of the kingdomwill be preached in all the world as a witness to all the nations, and then the end will come. Matthew 24:9-14


Can we still love our brother, who out of fear or greed, turned in our family so that the situation where the gun is pointed at our family in hopes of getting us to turn away from Christ are successful ?


Whoever hates his brother is a murderer, and you know that no murderer has eternal life abiding in him.
1 John 3:15


We in America haven’t had to face this kind of persecution... yet.


Are we ready?



JPT
My son is the perfect example. He was going to church and I thought he had a good handle on God and Jesus and had his eyes on the cross, was baptized in the spirit and in a water baptism and was a good person.

But one night at a party, somebody showed him a website that depicted Jesus not as the loving God, but as a monster. I knew something was wrong within a couple of weeks, it bothered him so much. He didn't tell me until years later why he finally gave up his witness to Jesus Christ.

For years, he hung out with people that knew not Jesus and in fact hated Jesus. So they searched the internet to prove that Jesus was a man made entity etc., etc., etc. And today he is still a good boy, but we can not talk too much about Jesus. So in my mind, my son is treading on thin ice. He once accepted and even confessed Jesus and now he does not. I fear for his eternal life.

Millions of Christians around the world are being subjected to this barrage of disinformation about God and Jesus, and they are leaving the church and turning their backs on Jesus. I fear for their eternal Lives.

Jesus is all about repentance and forgiveness, so I do not give up hope, but if my son does not repent and come back to Jesus, I fear he will be lost.

Do not ever give up hope. Remain faithfful, and let Jesus do his good works.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I’m glad that this thread has helped you in your walk with Christ :), however I do also think that it’s very dangerous for some of us to be arguing over Gods Holy Word especially when there are very new Christian brothers & sisters who have come through and have read some of the replies in here, in this thread....... it can be very discouraging for them.

I’m sure there’s more positive than negative posts in here (I hope), but during the times I’ve popped in, I’ve only read debates lol.

I’ve said what I need to say and now, I shall depart. May the peace of Jesus be with us all.
If it were any different ther topic, i would agree with you, but this is the gospel here, get this wrong has eternal consequences. Yes a new believer may be affected, but hopefully the right way, satan hates gods word, so when we see it attacked like it is in this thread, i come to expect it, so hopefull new believers see the meet of the discussion and sees and finds strength in his salvation and in his walk. And maybe even find he was wrong in his or her thinking like our brothere here.