Gender fluid Christian

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

HisHolly

Guest
Being created in God's image is bc 2 humans male and female were created and procreated.. all this bisexuality and intersexed is not apart of that.. sin came after..
The man in the dog suit is claiming to be a dog. AS I UNDERSTAND it, and again, I am new. Queer theology is saying something different. We are saying for example that intersexed people are created in Gods image also. And therefore, briefly, so am I
 
Last edited:

Off123123123

Senior Member
Apr 3, 2006
291
33
28
USA
I have read through the posts and have to say that I don't agree with most of you guys.
I think the Bible can be read from a queer perspective, and inform a Christian spirituality and morality non the less. There is much to be said on this issue and I am new to the study. But basically I do have to assert two things
1. That I have accepted the Lord Jesus Christ as my Lord and Savior.
2. That people a lot smarter than I have written on the subject in the affirmative of queer Christian spirituality and I am studying and agree so far.
Hello Jazzsinger. Thanks for being honest about your situation. You're correct the Bible can be read from a queer perspective, but it can be read from many perspectives, many of which are incorrect. I believe the queer perspective falls under the incorrect one.

I have no idea what it's like to struggle with gender identity issues, but like any other sin, I'm sure it's a monster to deal with. All of us deal with sin, and through Christ we have to mortify it daily.

I hope you don't continue to think this is God's way. It is not. But also, the issue may not go away simply by praying once, it may in fact be an everyday thing you fight for the rest of your life, just like any temptation.

Please know God has lots of grace and love for you, and desires to change you. Give it time and just keep going to God for grace everyday and keep fighting sin, like we all do.
 

Off123123123

Senior Member
Apr 3, 2006
291
33
28
USA
Fellow Christians, as frustrated as we are about a perceived agenda from the LGBTQ camp, I really think we need to check our snarky remarks that go along the lines of. . . "Well I'm going to identify as a dog, so now I'm a dog."

Those kinds of comments are not helpful, and if there is an honest seeker reading, they may just view us as jerks. I highly recommend reading a book by and about Rosaria Butterfield. She was a hardcore lesbian and activist but came to repentant faith after much patience. Reading her story opened my eyes to how we are viewed, and how much of what we say and do just makes us look like jerks.

https://www.amazon.com/Secret-Thoug...2&keywords=confessions+of+an+unlikely+convert
 
H

HisHolly

Guest
Being that I was actively living as a bisexual from early prepubescent until about 4 years ago.. I'm 34btw.. I actually don't count that comment as being off.. truth sets free, not garbage and coddling.. tact is important but discerning is more so.. the attitude they come with needs met head on.. it's the influence behind the activities not the person that needs addressing.. .
Fellow Christians, as frustrated as we are about a perceived agenda from the LGBTQ camp, I really think we need to check our snarky remarks that go along the lines of. . . "Well I'm going to identify as a dog, so now I'm a dog."

Those kinds of comments are not helpful, and if there is an honest seeker reading, they may just view us as jerks. I highly recommend reading a book by and about Rosaria Butterfield. She was a hardcore lesbian and activist but came to repentant faith after much patience. Reading her story opened my eyes to how we are viewed, and how much of what we say and do just makes us look like jerks.

https://www.amazon.com/Secret-Thoug...2&keywords=confessions+of+an+unlikely+convert
the person can be dealt with simultaneously.. I'm not saying they aren't important.. but it's not just emotions here.. it's spiritual lies and bondages
 
Last edited:

blue_ladybug

Senior Member
Feb 21, 2014
70,924
9,673
113
Actually, whoever made the remark about the dog, must've gotten it from the News forum. I believe there's an article in there about a guy in a dog suit asking if he can identify as a dog, since he's dressed like one..lol


Fellow Christians, as frustrated as we are about a perceived agenda from the LGBTQ camp, I really think we need to check our snarky remarks that go along the lines of. . . "Well I'm going to identify as a dog, so now I'm a dog."

Those kinds of comments are not helpful, and if there is an honest seeker reading, they may just view us as jerks. I highly recommend reading a book by and about Rosaria Butterfield. She was a hardcore lesbian and activist but came to repentant faith after much patience. Reading her story opened my eyes to how we are viewed, and how much of what we say and do just makes us look like jerks.

https://www.amazon.com/Secret-Thoug...2&keywords=confessions+of+an+unlikely+convert
 

presidente

Senior Member
May 29, 2013
9,165
1,795
113
I was referring to the dog video. I didn't mean the comment as snarky. It was something that came up in conversation earlier.

Something I'd like to point out is that I do not believe it is a sin to be gender-confused or even to be tempted with same sex attraction. The Bible says that for every temptation, God has provided a way of escape, that we may be able to bear it.

Compare the gender attraction issue to a 19-year-old young man who is tempted to fornicate with women, or just to look at them with lust. Women walking by in high skirts and low tops are a temptation. He can choose to avert his eyes, or to stare and look with lust. He can treat the young women like sisters, or he can try to manipulate them into bed with him. It is not a sin to be tempted. It is a sin if he gives in to the temptation.

Something else to keep in mind is how demons work on people's minds. I believe the project thoughts into people's minds to confuse and convince them, and that this happens with a lot of things including false religion, gender confusion, relationship decisions, etc.
 

Off123123123

Senior Member
Apr 3, 2006
291
33
28
USA
Being that I was actively living as a bisexual from early prepubescent until about 4 years ago.. I'm 34btw.. I actually don't count that comment as being off.. truth sets free, not garbage and coddling.. tact is important but discerning is more so.. the attitude they come with needs met head on.. it's the influence behind the activities not the person that needs addressing.. . the person can be dealt with simultaneously.. I'm not saying they aren't important.. but it's not just emotions here.. it's spiritual lies and bondages
CODDLING.png
............
 
Jan 27, 2015
2,691
367
83
I have read through the posts and have to say that I don't agree with most of you guys.
I think the Bible can be read from a queer perspective, and inform a Christian spirituality and morality non the less. There is much to be said on this issue and I am new to the study.
That's the problem right there. The idea is not to make the Bible fit your perspective; it's to let the Bible change your perspective.

The Bible is there to change you, not the other way around.

But basically I do have to assert two things
1. That I have accepted the Lord Jesus Christ as my Lord and Savior.
2. That people a lot smarter than I have written on the subject in the affirmative of queer Christian spirituality and I am studying and agree so far.
A God a lot smarter than them has already given His Word on the subject. I would go with Him. At our smartest, He's smarter.

1 Corinthians 1:25 - "For the foolishness of God is wiser than human wisdom, and the weakness of God is stronger than human strength."
 

presidente

Senior Member
May 29, 2013
9,165
1,795
113
The man in the dog suit is claiming to be a dog. AS I UNDERSTAND it, and again, I am new. Queer theology is saying something different. We are saying for example that intersexed people are created in Gods image also. And therefore, briefly, so am I
So, basically, it takes the fact that man was made in God's image, puts a spin on that story-- one way of reading it-- and totally disregards so much other commentary, or explains it away with sophistry and excuses.

I've heard some of this stuff before. What the Bible say about cross-dressing and same-gender sexual behavior is all negative. There is nothing positive in there.

Now, God is calling all men to repent. Are you willing to let go of past beliefs and be a disciple of Jesus? A disciple of Jesus must be His student and His follower. It requires a transformation of your thinking.
 
Mar 30, 2010
55
4
8
i thank you Lord Jesus for never calling me an Abomination, or of a depraved and reprobate mind as it has been written and as it has been said, Thank you Lord Jesus. You called us to be eunnanchs for the kingdom of heaven's sake, saying not every man can accept this saying but those that can should, and yet the Father in heaven said to go forth be fruitful and multiply. I know that You showed us that is not necessarily a sexual meaning for You called 12 disciples and they called others and so on therefore making You fruitfull as You multiplied. Also Adam was created a man, and also was women created from man, therefore could that be as to why we have the intersex? For Adam could have been the man he was created to be or the woman that was created out of him as in let them be intertwined for they ARE one. Thank you brethren for the discussion and considering, and thank you Lord Jesus for being You. Amen
 
Dec 16, 2012
1,483
114
63
Fellow Christians, as frustrated as we are about a perceived agenda from the LGBTQ camp, I really think we need to check our snarky remarks that go along the lines of. . . "Well I'm going to identify as a dog, so now I'm a dog."

Those kinds of comments are not helpful, and if there is an honest seeker reading, they may just view us as jerks. Reading her story opened my eyes to how we are viewed, and how much of what we say and do just makes us look like jerks.
Referring to a person who is facing these challenges and comes to these forums for help as 'The Lesbian' and 'a homo' are labels that are destructive and don't involve an educated, Christ centred approach that inspires change at all. Thanks for the link, I'll check it out.
 

Demi777

Senior Member
Oct 13, 2014
6,891
1,960
113
Germany
..as far as I know.. All 'gay or crossdressing people were killed.. not accepted before God...Nor was Adam Intersex. He was Male. And man wasnt good alone so he made Fe-male Eve..
 
T

Tintin

Guest
It is my understanding there were intersexed people in biblical times.
How were they socialized? There were no operations. As I understand it they were asked to CHOOSE which gender they were going to live by. I find this significant. If God creates an intersexed person, and in the days prior to operation ONE approach to this reality is for them to choose their gender. Isnt God creating an avenue for gender variance. In fact Adam was androgynous. This is accepted reality.
Evidence for any of this, please. Because you really could say any old bollocks and we'd 'have' to believe you. Also, Adam was not androgynous. He was very much a male. And Eve was very much a female. In fact, Adam was the manliest man that ever lived and Eve was the most womanly woman that ever lived, simply because they lived (for a short time) in perfect relationship with their Creator God and they weren't affected (for a short time) by sin and its consequences. They were made in the image of God. Male and female. That's it.
 
T

Tintin

Guest
The man in the dog suit is claiming to be a dog. AS I UNDERSTAND it, and again, I am new. Queer theology is saying something different. We are saying for example that intersexed people are created in Gods image also. And therefore, briefly, so am I
No. The man in the dog suit is only claiming to be a dog in this video. He's actually a mature, conservative (as in biblically-sound) Christian who dressed up as a dog to prove a point. In this post-truth world, anything goes. As long as it makes the person happy. Which is the complete antithesis of what the Bible teaches about truth and loving your neighbour as yourself.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
61,138
30,286
113
The man in the dog suit is not claiming to be a dog; he is asking people if making himself look like a dog actually makes him a dog. In connection to the issue of gender dysphoria one would have to assume he is attempting to make the point that a male who makes himself look like a female (or vice versa) is no more a female than a guy in a dog suit is a dog.
 
T

Tintin

Guest
The man in the dog suit is not claiming to be a dog; he is asking people if making himself look like a dog actually makes him a dog. In connection to the issue of gender dysphoria one would have to assume he is attempting to make the point that a male who makes himself look like a female (or vice versa) is no more a female than a guy in a dog suit is a dog.
Sorry, sis. I messed that up. You're right. He's not claiming to be a dog. He's asking people if making himself look like a dog actually makes him a dog. :)
 

sharkwhales

Senior Member
Jan 31, 2016
280
25
28
It is my understanding there were intersexed people in biblical times.
How were they socialized? There were no operations. As I understand it they were asked to CHOOSE which gender they were going to live by. I find this significant. If God creates an intersexed person, and in the days prior to operation ONE approach to this reality is for them to choose their gender. Isnt God creating an avenue for gender variance. In fact Adam was androgynous. This is accepted reality.
Hey Jazz -- Can you tell me where you got this understanding, that there were intersex people in the Bible that were asked to choose their gender? Or is that not what you're saying?

Also there are a lot of genetic problems in humanity which no one considers to be coming from God. God gave man power over creation, and because man abused that power, sickness & disease occurred. This includes birth defects like intersex disorders -- and they are called disorders for a reason, they inhibit the genitals from reproducing. They are not functionally androgynous.

God continues to allow those things, because he put them under our power to solve with Christ. That does not mean they are God's intention or God's design. Would you also say that down's syndrome, cleft palate, conjoined twins are God's design?

Also, how can you go from a few people having birth defects, to say that everyone else can also redefine themselves based on their mental state?

If someone feels dissonance with their physical sex, they do not need to reinvent the world to suit their dissonance. They need God to heal them of whatever is causing the dissonance.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
61,138
30,286
113
Sorry, sis. I messed that up. You're right. He's not claiming to be a dog. He's asking people if making himself look like a dog actually makes him a dog. :)
Thank you, and no worries, Tintin, there were others who said basically the same thing, so I just felt the record needed to be set straight (no pun intended :rolleyes:)
 

sharkwhales

Senior Member
Jan 31, 2016
280
25
28
Fellow Christians, as frustrated as we are about a perceived agenda from the LGBTQ camp, I really think we need to check our snarky remarks that go along the lines of. . . "Well I'm going to identify as a dog, so now I'm a dog."

Those kinds of comments are not helpful, and if there is an honest seeker reading, they may just view us as jerks. I highly recommend reading a book by and about Rosaria Butterfield. She was a hardcore lesbian and activist but came to repentant faith after much patience. Reading her story opened my eyes to how we are viewed, and how much of what we say and do just makes us look like jerks.

https://www.amazon.com/Secret-Thoug...2&keywords=confessions+of+an+unlikely+convert
I agree with approaching people with the loving truth of God; however the dog analogy isn't far off, because some people literally think they are dogs. It is part of the dissonance-driven culture. People must not let their dissonance and their feelings define them, but instead surrender those feelings to the Spirit of Truth and letting him dismantle them by revealing their source and removing them.

The Gospel is about transformation into a new creation; the world has no power to make itself new without Christ, so it has to rebrand corruption of the soul into a counterfeit form of transformation. And of course that creates suffering, either for them, or once they have completely surrendered to it, it creates suffering by dividing them from everyone who disagrees and inflaming the social discussion. "The soul is a wonderful servant but a cruel master"

However, when believers respond with a bad attitude, they make the truth harder to accept, and that attitude is coming from their soul too, not from the love of God. God loves these people. If we want to see the world transformed, we must also be transformed to love these people like God does.
 
T

Tintin

Guest
I agree with approaching people with the loving truth of God; however the dog analogy isn't far off, because some people literally think they are dogs. It is part of the dissonance-driven culture. People must not let their dissonance and their feelings define them, but instead surrender those feelings to the Spirit of Truth and letting him dismantle them by revealing their source and removing them.

The Gospel is about transformation into a new creation; the world has no power to make itself new without Christ, so it has to rebrand corruption of the soul into a counterfeit form of transformation. And of course that creates suffering, either for them, or once they have completely surrendered to it, it creates suffering by dividing them from everyone who disagrees and inflaming the social discussion. "The soul is a wonderful servant but a cruel master"

However, when believers respond with a bad attitude, they make the truth harder to accept, and that attitude is coming from their soul too, not from the love of God. God loves these people. If we want to see the world transformed, we must also be transformed to love these people like God does.
Yes, the whole man-identifying-as-a-dog experiment was to help to "...answer a fool according to his folly" as the Bible tells us to do.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.