I'm watching a program (again) about the American Civil war tonight. As a southerner, maybe as an easterner, I've grown up immersed in its history and I've never lost interest. I live near several battlefields and have visited many more - really more interested in the western theater than Lee's war in the east. Shiloh, Chickamauga, Lookout Mt., Nashville, and the trek to Atlanta - Resaca and the others, especially Kennesaw Mountain.
But all this left me wondering. How do folks in the west feel about the war? Does it have much of an impact or is there much interest in it at all? Even the folks from Texas who were part of the American Confederacy - has the war had much impact on you or is your interest in the war been something you've always had? How about Gypsy in Oregon or Catherder in California - does the war hold any wonderment for you?
I'm not sure it actually would touch people in the way it might a southerner. i have found artifact plenty of times - once a whole cannonball and several mini balls, even a union button once. There was still a stone fence built as part of a picket line near a neighborhood I lived in once when little.
To me, there's still a shadow of sorts that haunts this land. There's so many patches that are hallowed ground. There's still a kind of hushed dread in the thousand or so museums littering the south. Even the not so used rail lines form vanishing points that seem to moan still; a lonely look to a highway with historic markers around every bend. It seems every small town has black steel fenced in CSA tombstones on their boneyards with chiseled lettering shallow'd by a century and a half of rain.
Does it play a role in other's lives?
If some come to the dance only for the punch n cookies, that just means more room on the dance floor for us.It's weird to me how individuals will come here and attempt to dominate one specific thread but post in no other threads. It's kind of difficult to pay attention to someone's opinion when they don't make an effort to actually be part of the community.
If some come to the dance only for the punch n cookies, that just means more room on the dance floor for us.
![]()
I'm watching a program (again) about the American Civil war tonight. As a southerner, maybe as an easterner, I've grown up immersed in its history and I've never lost interest. I live near several battlefields and have visited many more - really more interested in the western theater than Lee's war in the east. Shiloh, Chickamauga, Lookout Mt., Nashville, and the trek to Atlanta - Resaca and the others, especially Kennesaw Mountain.
But all this left me wondering. How do folks in the west feel about the war? Does it have much of an impact or is there much interest in it at all? Even the folks from Texas who were part of the American Confederacy - has the war had much impact on you or is your interest in the war been something you've always had? How about Gypsy in Oregon or Catherder in California - does the war hold any wonderment for you?
I'm not sure it actually would touch people in the way it might a southerner. i have found artifact plenty of times - once a whole cannonball and several mini balls, even a union button once. There was still a stone fence built as part of a picket line near a neighborhood I lived in once when little.
To me, there's still a shadow of sorts that haunts this land. There's so many patches that are hallowed ground. There's still a kind of hushed dread in the thousand or so museums littering the south. Even the not so used rail lines form vanishing points that seem to moan still; a lonely look to a highway with historic markers around every bend. It seems every small town has black steel fenced in CSA tombstones on their boneyards with chiseled lettering shallow'd by a century and a half of rain.
Does it play a role in other's lives?
I know I'm not so far north and/or west as the folks you mentioned, but northwest enough that I don't live in an area with any Civil War history attached to it. My mom and her family grew up in Oklahoma, and I have a lot of ancestors from the South. I grew up at least hearing about that era a lot, and I've always been interested in it.
I don't think it ever could hold the same meaning for me as it does for you or others who are literally surrounded by memorials and battle sites and museums and just the Southern life in general. But for me, there's definitely a fascination with it all, a certain sentimental feeling about it. There's a tragic romance about it, for me. I'm sure a part of that is due to having watched/read Gone With the Wind (though reading it is such an entirely different experience than watching the film- the film is good, but the book is excellent and far more detailed about the war itself rather than Scarlett's screwed up love life). Another good book is The Widow of the South (which reminds me I should read that again). Anyway, my point is, my view of the Civil War is probably skewed, and I admit I don't know a whole lot about it, but it's definitely interesting and important to me.
When I was 17, I went on vacation with my mom, aunt, and grandma- we drove from here to Georgia and South Carolina and visited some of the old plantations and cemeteries and Fort Sumter and...I dunno, a heck of a lot of places connected to that time period and the war. It was a really amazing opportunity, I recognized that even as a teenager, and I'd love to go back and have more time to just see everything. To me, everything east and south of Kansas is like a fairy tale world...the land itself, the veil of green on everything, the history, the homes...I'm in love with it. There's just something awe-inspiring about standing in a place where men fought and died for what they believed in, something tragic about seeing slave cabins all lined up out of sight of the mansion on a plantation, something mystical about being surrounded by giant oaks and magnolias draped with Spanish moss and imagining a farewell scene between a soldier and a Southern belle in her hoopskirts (that might be Gone With the Wind getting to me again...).
Um...so...short answer: Yes, it holds meaning to some people over this way.
Beautiful post Cristen. Thanks for your thoughts. Gone With the Wind (the movie) does lend romance not really visible in the reality of it all. The war was this unfair mix of a much advanced gunnery technology and a warfare technique that was old as the war of 1812. It resulted in unbelievable numbers of casualties.
I have a bad fever. I want to get home so I am travelling by coach overnight (7 hour journey). I hope I will be okay.
Will be praying for you, brother. Get plenty of rest and fluids. Take a fever reducer too if you can (aspirin or tylenol or motrin).I have a bad fever. I want to get home so I am travelling by coach overnight (7 hour journey). I hope I will be okay.
I'm watching a program (again) about the American Civil war tonight. As a southerner, maybe as an easterner, I've grown up immersed in its history and I've never lost interest. I live near several battlefields and have visited many more - really more interested in the western theater than Lee's war in the east. Shiloh, Chickamauga, Lookout Mt., Nashville, and the trek to Atlanta - Resaca and the others, especially Kennesaw Mountain.
But all this left me wondering. How do folks in the west feel about the war? Does it have much of an impact or is there much interest in it at all? Even the folks from Texas who were part of the American Confederacy - has the war had much impact on you or is your interest in the war been something you've always had? How about Gypsy in Oregon or Catherder in California - does the war hold any wonderment for you?
I'm not sure it actually would touch people in the way it might a southerner. i have found artifact plenty of times - once a whole cannonball and several mini balls, even a union button once. There was still a stone fence built as part of a picket line near a neighborhood I lived in once when little.
To me, there's still a shadow of sorts that haunts this land. There's so many patches that are hallowed ground. There's still a kind of hushed dread in the thousand or so museums littering the south. Even the not so used rail lines form vanishing points that seem to moan still; a lonely look to a highway with historic markers around every bend. It seems every small town has black steel fenced in CSA tombstones on their boneyards with chiseled lettering shallow'd by a century and a half of rain.
Does it play a role in other's lives?