Hi ITL,
You wrote a great opening post! Thanks for bringing up this subject with a great deal of insight and wisdom.
Many of us here are long-term singles so you'll definitely find others here who are thinking the same way.
I think the older I get, the one thing I'm realizing about marriage is that marriage means serving someone else. When you sign up to get married, what you are really saying is, "I choose to serve this person for the rest of my life, despite what happens along the way. It doesn't matter what (or how much) goes wrong, or how differently it turns out than I expected -- I am making a promise and holy commitment to the Lord that I will be here and serve this person for the rest of my life, whether I'm happy or not."
And I know that for myself, grasping the thought of how God sees marriage, and not the world markets it, is incredibly intimidating.
I liked what The Indian Girl said about singles in the church being told that they are incomplete unless they marry and have families. Marriage seems to be the catch-all Christian Panacea for absolutely every ailment: Feeling lonely? Start looking for a spouse! Looking for a purpose in life? Marriage and a family will take care of that! Struggling with sexual feelings? Put out those flames with a one-way trip to the altar!!!
The problem for me is that I don't hear Christian married couples telling us that marriage is solving any of these issues in THEIR lives. Now, I'm sure there ARE some happy Christian marriages out there, but they seem to be increasingly rare, and I don't know about anyone else, but I don't hear very much about them. What I seem to observe more in my own life is tolerance, and the more of it I see, the less I think about getting married, because I know in my heart how miserable I would feel if I had to tolerate some of the situations married people are dealing with.
And yet, for some reason, so many of us think that we are going to be The Blessed Exception and that God is going to give them that One Perfect Unicorn to ride off into the sunset with.
I have often wanted to write a thread and poll in the CC Family Forum that says, "Marriage Cured My Porn Addiction (And Everything Else Wrong with My Life", because to me, this is what the church makes it sound like. "Get Married, and God Will Cause All Your Social Problems to Disappear and All Your Dreams to Come True!" But if we were able to ask married people honest questions about their married lives -- the really tough questions that are deemed as being too personal to ask, but are silently killing people -- what would the real answers be?
We all know that sexual feelings are meant to be dealt with in marriage. But how many married Christian people can honestly say, "Marriage fulfills everything I ever wanted, dreamed about, and hoped for in a sex life! I feel 100% satisfied, 100% of the time!" And even when we account for a sinful, imperfect world, how high could we expect those statistics to be? (80% satisfied, 70% of the time?) No matter how high the statistic, the devil will always be gnawing at us about whatever percentage we think is "missing", whether we are married or single.
I think similar stats could be applied to every other area marriage is supposed to "cure" as well: Loneliness, Companionship, Family Life, Spiritual Growth, Financial Health, and Purpose in Life. How satisfied do most married people feel in these areas, and how much of the time? If the CC Family Forum is any indication, not very many (although I realize that people who are struggling in their marriages are more likely to write about their challenges rather than people who are happily content.)
I often wonder if we forget that absolutely everything has a price. Some time back, a gentleman and I were considering the possibility of a long-distance relationship and then seeing where it went. But we couldn't even work out a regular phone schedule in order to have time to talk every couple of days. Like most couples I know, we worked opposite hours and I certainly wasn't going to call him and blab about the mundane details of my day when I knew he'd only be getting 4 hours of sleep before having to go back into work again. I might have been dying to tell him about something but I would wait until it was before a shift where he would get a little more sleep, so at times that meant waiting a week to bring it up -- or just deciding I could handle it alone without saying anything.
To me, it was even harder than being single because I had to plan all my waking, working, and sleeping hours around when we just might be lucky enough to have a full-on time eclipse in which we could manage to talk for even 30 minutes. I don't know if we might have gotten married if we had been given proximity and time, but I do know that the realities of life made it seem impossible to work with and that being friends has been much easier (albeit, sad, of course.)
We all want financial stability in a relationship, but all too often, the only way to get it means that you'll never get to spend any time together. Christian women say they want a good provider, but what I see in many marriages are couples who become joint single parents, taking turns raising their children by themselves at opposite hours as they try to keep up with ever-demanding work schedules.
But yet, somehow, we all hope and pray that God is somehow going to make our situation the exception with dream jobs that perfectly coordinate family time (and of course, a few very blessed families might find this.)
Only now, as I face those issues myself, can I fully appreciate the miracle that somehow my parents were able to manage with my Mom overseeing the household while my Dad worked 15+ hours a day, 7 days a week (and when things went wrong, which they often did, it felt like he lived at work 24/7.) We were very blessed in that he was eventually able to have some flexibility, almost always joining us for dinner and church on Sunday, but in all the hours before and after that, he was almost always at work.
I know this post might come across as bitter and cynical, but I think this is what happens to a lot of people -- we believe in fairytales and then wonder why marriage doesn't meet our expectations.
Society, and even the church, has turned marriage into some kind of "One Size Fits All" cure for every ailment we face in a fallen world, but once people get locked in and face the true reality of serving someone for the rest of their life, they realize that it DOESN'T actually cure those ailments, and many of the things they have struggled with will still be a struggle.
Marriage is simply an alternative approach to dealing with, but not completely solving our problems.