questions

[Suze]

Yes, and a second part was being a good husband by dissuading Eve from eating the forbidden fruit--
or from partaking of the tree of knowledge the forbidden way (without divine permission or God's guidance).

The early chapters of Genesis are worthy of very careful study . In particular , what God told Adam what he shouldn't do and , what Adam told Eve that she shouldn't do . There is a miss communication there . This to me is massively important . It points the way to why God has given us and preserved for us HIS WRITTEN WORD . We must rely on it , not on preachers . We MUST read God's Word ( all of it , old as well as new ) , for ourselves and b convinced of its Truth for and of ourselves . The first time God tells someone what they shouldn't do , they then pass the message on but INACCURATELY . As soon as we rely on a person , any person , to tell us the Truth , as soon as we place another human being between ourselves and God's Word , we r on dangerous ground . I'm not saying never listen to what anyone else has to say about the Truth , but I would say , make sure that u have studied God's Word for yourself , thoroughly , before u start listening to what humans have to say about it . God's Word is pure , we humans r not .

 

[Robertt]

Some may be missing the message meant to be communicated by God via the writer of Genesis,
which is that humanity was created to be good stewards of earth as they fellowship with God.
Naming new species as they are discovered was NOT the reason for writing.

each to their own search for answers

 

[Robertt]

Well, some thoughts are more blinding than others.
A truthseeker tries to be conscious of bias and strive for objectivity.
For example, I am biased toward believing God loves everyone based on 1Tim.2:3-4,
but I try to consider the Scriptures cited by TULIPists to see if I should convert.
(Not yet :^)

what is a Tulipist? please explain

There is truth and there is percieved truth. to each person our percieved truth is the only truth we have until God opens eyes and ears.

we can only see the truth that is revealed to us.

 

[Robertt]

There are two different communications here. It is surely implied in Genesis 2:19 that God communicate with Adam, otherwise Adam would not have known that God wanted him to name the animals.

“Out of the ground the LORD God formed every beast of the field and every bird of the air, and brought them to Adam to see what he would call them. And whatever Adam called each living creature, that was its name.” (Ge 2:19 NKJV)

Incidentally, I don't see anything there about naming new species as they are discovered. It says that God brought the animals to Adam for naming.

Secondly, God communicates with mankind through His written word, including Genesis. I agree that Adam naming the animals was part and parcel of his stewardship.

i guess adam had a different form of communication as written word didnt come until much later.

personally i think our reliance on only reading the word and not hearing it is why we sometimes disagree

 

[Robertt]

Yes, and a second part was being a good husband by dissuading Eve from eating the forbidden fruit--
or from partaking of the tree of knowledge the forbidden way (without divine permission or God's guidance).

intersitngly when eve was tempted she added a few words that God didnt tell adam
"not to even touch it"

perhaps adding things to Gods word is what makes it easier for some to be decieved.

 

[GWH]

what is a Tulipist? please explain

There is truth and there is percieved truth. to each person our percieved truth is the only truth we have until God opens eyes and ears.

we can only see the truth that is revealed to us.

A TULIPist is someone who believes in:

Total depravity
Unconditional election
Limited atonement
Irresistible grace
Perseverance is guaranteed

This is the objectional part of Calvinism.

I am a truthseeker, and I do not think that TULIP is true per GW.
Unfortunately, Augustine's false teaching was adopted by Calvin and popularized by Knox in Scotland
and in the US by Whitefield during the Greak Awakening.

 

[ewq1938]

How can that be still in the Garden of Eden? Adam was in Eden, and we are told that God brought all the animals to Noah there, not that they were all there already.

Where is it said that Noah was in Eden?

 

[ewq1938]

So what's your answer to this apparent difficulty ?

Adam was created after the day of rest, not before it. Adam did not have dominion over sealife because the garden was land locked, not near the sea/ocean. That's why he didn't name any sea creatures.

 

[DavidLamb]

Where is it said that Noah was in Eden?

Sorry, my mistake (simply carelessness!) I meant "Adam."

 

[ewq1938]

Sorry, my mistake (simply carelessness!) I meant "Adam."

God created new animals for Adam, in the garden. No mention of sealife because no sea in the garden.

 

[DavidLamb]

God created new animals for Adam, in the garden. No mention of sealife because no sea in the garden.

Yes, that seems a fair inference - that God brought only land animals and birds for Adam to name.

 

[GWH]

intersitngly when eve was tempted she added a few words that God didnt tell adam
"not to even touch it"

perhaps adding things to Gods word is what makes it easier for some to be decieved.

Good point. Subtracting too.

 

[GWH]

Adam was created after the day of rest, not before it. Adam did not have dominion over sealife because the garden was land locked, not near the sea/ocean. That's why he didn't name any sea creatures.

Yes, God has not had a day of rest since creating humanity.

 

[Suze]

Good point. Subtracting too.

Did eve add the words ? Or r they the words that Adam said to eve ? Maybe , Adam loved Eve so much that he added those words to dissuade her from even touching the tree . The way we might say to a child about not touching the stove , u know what ? Don't even go anywhere near it just in case . We shall never know for sure , not in this life anyway but I personally think that Adam added the words about not touching the tree because he was scared on Eve's behalf and just wanted to keep her away from it . Sadly , it made no difference who said what to whom . The corruption of God's Word by man ( or woman ) provided a foothold for the serpent . This has been repeated add nausium throughout history , which is why it's so important for all of us who profess Christianity to read God's Word for ourselves . I think that it illustrates that God cannot trust man to pass down His Word by mouth and why God has been so gracious in preserving and providing His Word for all to access by reading it .

 

[GWH]

Did eve add the words ? Or r they the words that Adam said to eve ? Maybe , Adam loved Eve so much that he added those words to dissuade her from even touching the tree . The way we might say to a child about not touching the stove , u know what ? Don't even go anywhere near it just in case . We shall never know for sure , not in this life anyway but I personally think that Adam added the words about not touching the tree because he was scared on Eve's behalf and just wanted to keep her away from it . Sadly , it made no difference who said what to whom . The corruption of God's Word by man ( or woman ) provided a foothold for the serpent . This has been repeated add nausium throughout history , which is why it's so important for all of us who profess Christianity to read God's Word for ourselves . I think that it illustrates that God cannot trust man to pass down His Word by mouth and why God has been so gracious in preserving and providing His Word for all to access by reading it .

Yes, the key part of the story is that they were together and cooperated in committing the first sin,
which was not asking God about what the serpent had told them that contradicted what God had said.