“Not Random Cruelty: God’s Judgments in Context — Understanding Divine Justice Through Scripture”

  • Thread starter Thread starter Blue155
  • Start date Start date
  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
B

Blue155

Guest
If you trace the biblical narrative, you see a consistent picture of God’s judgment in response to human wickedness:

1. Genesis 6:5 – The flood shows humanity’s pervasive evil and God’s righteous judgment on a global scale.

2. Genesis 13:13 – The men of Sodom are “exceedingly wicked and sinful against the Lord,” demonstrating concentrated societal wickedness.

3. Genesis 15:16 – God promises Abraham the land of Canaan, but delays the Israelites’ inheritance because the Amorites’ sin has not yet reached its full measure. This shows God’s patience and justice, giving nations time to repent.

4. Leviticus 18 & Deuteronomy 18:9–14 – God codifies His moral standards and warns Israel not to imitate the abominable practices of the surrounding nations.

5. Deuteronomy 9:4–5 – God clarifies the moral basis for judgment: Israel is not receiving the land because of their righteousness, but because of the wickedness of the nations being judged. This removes any notion of ethnic favoritism and frames the conquest as divine judgment, not genocide.

6. Deuteronomy 20 – Rules for warfare show that judgment was measured and often gave an opportunity for repentance (offering peace first, etc.).

7. 1 Samuel 15:3 (Amalekites) & Numbers (Midianites) – God’s judgments are specific, righteous, and always in response to persistent sin.

8. Jeremiah 19:9; Hosea 13:16; Isaiah 13:16 – Prophetic literature describes the consequences of wickedness and the certainty of God’s justice.

9. Joshua – The conquest shows the fulfillment of earlier promises and judgments, again framed around God’s patience, warnings, and justice.

10. 2 Thess. 1:8 - Scripture describes ultimate final judgment on the ungodly.

So, Genesis establishes the pattern: human wickedness, God’s warnings, opportunity to repent, judgment if persistent. By the time you get to Deuteronomy, Leviticus, and the historical books, this pattern is fully developed.

This helps counter critics who see these passages as random or cruel. They are part of a consistent, justice-driven narrative.

Psalm 19:9 – The judgments of the Lord are “true and righteous altogether.”

Deuteronomy 32:4 – God’s works are perfect; His ways are just.

Psalm 119:160 – His Word is true; the sum of His Word is truth.

From Genesis 6 with the flood, through Genesis 13–15 through Joshua and Jericho, to the destruction of Jerusalem, and the final judgment at the end of the world, every instance of divine judgment has context: persistent sin, rebellion, or corruption of God’s moral order.

Many critics of God judge His character by isolated passages they do not understand, rather than interpreting those passages in light of His revealed character and nature as a whole—most clearly and definitively displayed in Jesus Christ (Heb. 1:3; Col. 2:9).

If someone takes the parts of the Bible that describe God punishing sin (like warnings, judgments, consequences) and accepts those as true, but at the same time rejects or ignores the parts that explain why sin is bad and what disobedience really costs (like separation from God, death, or moral corruption), then they’re setting themselves up to see God as “unfair” or “cruel.” Instead of engaging with the God of the Bible who judges sin, they are engaging with a god in their mind who judges for no good reason.
 
If you trace the biblical narrative, you see a consistent picture of God’s judgment in response to human wickedness:

1. Genesis 6:5 – The flood shows humanity’s pervasive evil and God’s righteous judgment on a global scale.

2. Genesis 13:13 – The men of Sodom are “exceedingly wicked and sinful against the Lord,” demonstrating concentrated societal wickedness.

3. Genesis 15:16 – God promises Abraham the land of Canaan, but delays the Israelites’ inheritance because the Amorites’ sin has not yet reached its full measure. This shows God’s patience and justice, giving nations time to repent.

4. Leviticus 18 & Deuteronomy 18:9–14 – God codifies His moral standards and warns Israel not to imitate the abominable practices of the surrounding nations.

5. Deuteronomy 9:4–5 – God clarifies the moral basis for judgment: Israel is not receiving the land because of their righteousness, but because of the wickedness of the nations being judged. This removes any notion of ethnic favoritism and frames the conquest as divine judgment, not genocide.

6. Deuteronomy 20 – Rules for warfare show that judgment was measured and often gave an opportunity for repentance (offering peace first, etc.).

7. 1 Samuel 15:3 (Amalekites) & Numbers (Midianites) – God’s judgments are specific, righteous, and always in response to persistent sin.

8. Jeremiah 19:9; Hosea 13:16; Isaiah 13:16 – Prophetic literature describes the consequences of wickedness and the certainty of God’s justice.

9. Joshua – The conquest shows the fulfillment of earlier promises and judgments, again framed around God’s patience, warnings, and justice.

10. 2 Thess. 1:8 - Scripture describes ultimate final judgment on the ungodly.

So, Genesis establishes the pattern: human wickedness, God’s warnings, opportunity to repent, judgment if persistent. By the time you get to Deuteronomy, Leviticus, and the historical books, this pattern is fully developed.

This helps counter critics who see these passages as random or cruel. They are part of a consistent, justice-driven narrative.

Psalm 19:9 – The judgments of the Lord are “true and righteous altogether.”

Deuteronomy 32:4 – God’s works are perfect; His ways are just.

Psalm 119:160 – His Word is true; the sum of His Word is truth.

From Genesis 6 with the flood, through Genesis 13–15 through Joshua and Jericho, to the destruction of Jerusalem, and the final judgment at the end of the world, every instance of divine judgment has context: persistent sin, rebellion, or corruption of God’s moral order.

Many critics of God judge His character by isolated passages they do not understand, rather than interpreting those passages in light of His revealed character and nature as a whole—most clearly and definitively displayed in Jesus Christ (Heb. 1:3; Col. 2:9).

If someone takes the parts of the Bible that describe God punishing sin (like warnings, judgments, consequences) and accepts those as true, but at the same time rejects or ignores the parts that explain why sin is bad and what disobedience really costs (like separation from God, death, or moral corruption), then they’re setting themselves up to see God as “unfair” or “cruel.” Instead of engaging with the God of the Bible who judges sin, they are engaging with a god in their mind who judges for no good reason.
Isaiah 3:11, Proverbs 1:31 and Rev 22:12 frame the judgment of the wicked as the reward for what they have done.
 
Isaiah 3:11, Proverbs 1:31 and Rev 22:12 frame the judgment of the wicked as the reward for what they have done.
Isaiah 3:11 Woe unto the wicked! it shall be ill with him: for the reward of his hands shall be given him

Proverbs 1:31 Therefore shall they eat of the fruit of their own way, and be filled with their own devices

Revelation 22:12 12 And, behold, I come quickly; and my reward is with me, to give every man according as his work shall be.

Thanks. I can add that to my article.
 
If you trace the biblical narrative, you see a consistent picture of God’s judgment in response to human wickedness:

1. Genesis 6:5 – The flood shows humanity’s pervasive evil and God’s righteous judgment on a global scale.

2. Genesis 13:13 – The men of Sodom are “exceedingly wicked and sinful against the Lord,” demonstrating concentrated societal wickedness.

3. Genesis 15:16 – God promises Abraham the land of Canaan, but delays the Israelites’ inheritance because the Amorites’ sin has not yet reached its full measure. This shows God’s patience and justice, giving nations time to repent.

4. Leviticus 18 & Deuteronomy 18:9–14 – God codifies His moral standards and warns Israel not to imitate the abominable practices of the surrounding nations.

5. Deuteronomy 9:4–5 – God clarifies the moral basis for judgment: Israel is not receiving the land because of their righteousness, but because of the wickedness of the nations being judged. This removes any notion of ethnic favoritism and frames the conquest as divine judgment, not genocide.

6. Deuteronomy 20 – Rules for warfare show that judgment was measured and often gave an opportunity for repentance (offering peace first, etc.).

7. 1 Samuel 15:3 (Amalekites) & Numbers (Midianites) – God’s judgments are specific, righteous, and always in response to persistent sin.

8. Jeremiah 19:9; Hosea 13:16; Isaiah 13:16 – Prophetic literature describes the consequences of wickedness and the certainty of God’s justice.

9. Joshua – The conquest shows the fulfillment of earlier promises and judgments, again framed around God’s patience, warnings, and justice.

10. 2 Thess. 1:8 - Scripture describes ultimate final judgment on the ungodly.

So, Genesis establishes the pattern: human wickedness, God’s warnings, opportunity to repent, judgment if persistent. By the time you get to Deuteronomy, Leviticus, and the historical books, this pattern is fully developed.

This helps counter critics who see these passages as random or cruel. They are part of a consistent, justice-driven narrative.

Psalm 19:9 – The judgments of the Lord are “true and righteous altogether.”

Deuteronomy 32:4 – God’s works are perfect; His ways are just.

Psalm 119:160 – His Word is true; the sum of His Word is truth.

From Genesis 6 with the flood, through Genesis 13–15 through Joshua and Jericho, to the destruction of Jerusalem, and the final judgment at the end of the world, every instance of divine judgment has context: persistent sin, rebellion, or corruption of God’s moral order.

Many critics of God judge His character by isolated passages they do not understand, rather than interpreting those passages in light of His revealed character and nature as a whole—most clearly and definitively displayed in Jesus Christ (Heb. 1:3; Col. 2:9).

If someone takes the parts of the Bible that describe God punishing sin (like warnings, judgments, consequences) and accepts those as true, but at the same time rejects or ignores the parts that explain why sin is bad and what disobedience really costs (like separation from God, death, or moral corruption), then they’re setting themselves up to see God as “unfair” or “cruel.” Instead of engaging with the God of the Bible who judges sin, they are engaging with a god in their mind who judges for no good reason.
To know God you have to learn from God, and you either learn the hard way or the easier way, that's the general theme that's consistent through the whole bible, and fear of being disciplined is a good thing not a bad thing. 🙂
 
It may be a little limiting to consider God harshness in terms of punishment only. If one considers that the curse God placed on the ground after Adam and Even sinned, it may have been more for our benefit as our new selfish nature unimpeded would consume us. An environmental impediment would require us to help each other and perhaps show us the harmfulness of a selfish nature and thus show us our need for God.

That is was insufficient motivation might be seen in the changes afte the flood. Our shorter lifespan perhaps genetic changes as well as disease. Also the environmental changes such as winter and drought may have contributed to curbs on our selfishness and at least some interest of needing each other and God.

God does have wrath and it can be poured out for punishment and even cleansing. But we should not exclude consideration of additional purposes.
 
Isaiah 3:11, Proverbs 1:31 and Rev 22:12 frame the judgment of the wicked as the reward for what they have done.

We all are made in the image of God, yet none of us, at least me I am not God, seeing Psalm 82, thank you
 
To know God you have to learn from God, and you either learn the hard way or the easier way, that's the general theme that's consistent through the whole bible, and fear of being disciplined is a good thing not a bad thing. 🙂

I, choose from God to be disciplined by God not others or self. No fear in the risen Son. I can now freely learn from all my mistakes and I have made many of them to this day. I need God to lead, not me, thanks. I trust God to lead, anyone else?
Thank you Father for being willing to teach me and have taken care of sin through Son for me and all the people in the world. Woe is me Isaiah 6:1-7
 
I, choose from God to be disciplined by God not others or self. No fear in the risen Son. I can now freely learn from all my mistakes and I have made many of them to this day. I need God to lead, not me, thanks. I trust God to lead, anyone else?
Thank you Father for being willing to teach me and have taken care of sin through Son for me and all the people in the world. Woe is me Isaiah 6:1-7
yep it's what you call life from life my friend

But also the life returns to God, which ultimately means to me, is every person has a life, which means every person has an inherent will on them from the begining, and every person, as the word declares every person will have there conscience pricked by God, 🙂
 
It may be a little limiting to consider God harshness in terms of punishment only. If one considers that the curse God placed on the ground after Adam and Even sinned, it may have been more for our benefit as our new selfish nature unimpeded would consume us. An environmental impediment would require us to help each other and perhaps show us the harmfulness of a selfish nature and thus show us our need for God.

That is was insufficient motivation might be seen in the changes afte the flood. Our shorter lifespan perhaps genetic changes as well as disease. Also the environmental changes such as winter and drought may have contributed to curbs on our selfishness and at least some interest of needing each other and God.

God does have wrath and it can be poured out for punishment and even cleansing. But we should not exclude consideration of additional purposes.
For unbelievers, they believe God is harshness only, but He’s not.
 
For unbelievers, they believe God is harshness only, but He’s not.

It is not God being Harsh it is revealed in Psalm 82, the people doing this not God. Yet God has been being blamed for it, and is not true thank you